On a joint bank account, the drawer for the purposes of Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is the person who signed the cheque. Naming every account holder as an accused because the account was joint is the most common pleading error in cheque cases, and it gives the defence an easy application for quashing.
The drawer is a legal person, not an account
Section 138 speaks of a cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him with a banker. The obligation is his, and the notice must be served on him. Where two or more people hold an account, the account is joint but each cheque is drawn by whoever signs it, unless the mandate requires both signatures.
That distinction decides the array of accused. If only one holder signed, he is the drawer. The other holder may be liable on the underlying transaction, and may be a proper party to a civil suit, but he is not the drawer of the cheque and cannot be convicted under Section 138 merely because his name is on the account.
Where the mandate requires both signatures
Some joint accounts are operated jointly, with both holders required to sign each cheque. In that situation both have drawn the cheque, and both can be proceeded against. The account opening form and the mandate are the documents that prove it, and they should be obtained from the bank before the complaint is drafted rather than after the accused raises the point.
The same logic applies where one holder signs under a power of attorney from the other. The signatory is the drawer in form, but the principal authorised the drawing and the liability is his. Pleadings should spell out the authority, and the power of attorney should be annexed.
Companies, firms and the persons in charge
Where the account belongs to a company, Section 141 comes into play. Every person who, at the time the offence was committed, was in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the business of the company is deemed guilty, along with the company itself. The complaint must contain a statement of that role for each individual, not a bare recital that he is a director.
The section also allows a nominee director to escape where the offence occurred without his knowledge and he exercised due diligence, and it protects a person who was not in charge at the relevant time. A director who resigned before the cheque was issued, and whose resignation was filed with the Registrar of Companies, has a documentary defence that is hard to answer. Our page on cheque bounce deals with the company cases in more detail.
For a partnership firm, Section 141 applies through the definition of company, which includes a firm. The partners who signed and those in charge of the firm's business at the time are liable; a sleeping partner who had nothing to do with the transaction and can prove it may escape, though the burden is on him.
Joint account of husband and wife
The common family case deserves its own note. A wife who signs a cheque on a joint account for her husband's business debt is the drawer, and she can be prosecuted if the cheque bounces, because the statutory presumption does not care about the domestic arrangement. The reverse is also true: a husband cannot be prosecuted for a cheque his wife signed on their joint account, however much of the money went to his business, unless he is shown to be a party to the transaction and liable on it.
Where the money was borrowed by the husband and the cheque was signed by the wife at his request, the better course may be a civil suit against both, or a complaint against the wife with a pleading that the husband procured the issue. The criminal court will not infer liability from the marriage.
What the complaint must say
- The name of the account holder who signed the cheque, and the date of signature.
- The account number and the bank branch, with the return memo.
- For each accused, the specific role: signatory, person in charge, or partner.
- The transaction that gave rise to the debt, with dates and amounts.
- The statutory notice, and proof of service on each accused.
- That each accused received the notice and failed to pay within fifteen days.
A complaint that describes all the accused in one sentence and attributes responsibility collectively is vulnerable. Magistrates in Kolkata do insist on the individual role being stated, and a defective complaint is often returned at the filing stage rather than admitted.
The consequences of joining the wrong person
Two things happen. The wrongly joined accused files an application for quashing before the Calcutta High Court, and the whole complaint may be stayed while that is decided. Even where the complaint survives against the drawer, the pendency against the others gives the defence time and a bargaining counter.
There is also a cost consequence. A complaint against a person who is acquitted may expose the complainant to costs in an appropriate case, and it always weakens the complainant's credibility on the facts that matter.
Joint account and the civil remedy
Where the signatory has no means and the other holder has assets, the criminal route against the signatory alone may recover nothing. In that situation the complainant should consider a civil suit on the debt against all persons liable, with the dishonoured cheque as evidence, and consider attachment before judgement where there is material to show that assets are being moved. Recovery through a summary suit is discussed on our page on recovery suits.
The two proceedings can run together. A conviction is not a precondition to the civil claim, and a civil decree does not bar the criminal case, though the court will take the civil outcome into account when sentencing or compounding. That suit is filed in the manner set out under civil litigation.
Common questions
Can a joint account holder who did not sign be arrested?
Not on the strength of the account alone. Process issues only against a person validly arraigned, and the magistrate will not issue a warrant against someone who is not the drawer and against whom no role is pleaded. Where such a person is arraigned, the first remedy is a request for discharge or a quashing petition.
What if the cheque was signed by one holder but the debt was in the name of the other?
The drawer is still the signatory, and the complaint must be against him. The person who took the benefit can be sued civilly. A complaint against the beneficiary of the loan who did not sign will not lie under Section 138.
Does the bank's mandate matter if both signatures appear on the cheque?
Yes, and helpfully. Where both signatures appear and the mandate required both, both are drawers. Where the mandate required one and two signed, the second signature is surplus but does not by itself make the second signatory a drawer.
Can the complainant add an accused later?
An application to add an accused after the complaint is filed is possible but rarely allowed once evidence has begun, because the new person has had no notice and no chance to pay within fifteen days. The array should be settled before filing.
The lesson is unglamorous: before drafting, get the account opening form, the mandate, the signature card, and the return memo. Those four documents tell you who the drawer is. Everything else in the complaint follows from that.