14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Recovery & Cheque Bounce

Cheque issued as security: the defence that sometimes works

A cheque given as security is not automatically outside Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The offence is made out when a cheque drawn for the discharge of a legally enforceable debt or liability is dishonoured. If the liability had crystallised by the time the cheque was presented, the fact that it was originally handed over as security does not save the drawer. If it had not — if the cheque was held against a contingency that never occurred — the prosecution fails, because there was no debt to discharge.

How the defence is usually framed

The drawer says the cheque was never payment. It was a blank or undated instrument lodged with the payee as a guarantee for performance of a contract, or as a security deposit, or as collateral for a loan that was never advanced. On that version, there was no debt at the date of presentation, and the presumption under Section 139 does not arise because the foundational fact — a cheque issued in discharge of a liability — is absent.

The courts have accepted that framing where the drawer can point to something outside his own assertion: a written agreement describing the cheque as security, a receipt showing it was lodged with a third party, correspondence referring to it as collateral, or the absence of any transaction that could have generated the amount. What the courts have not accepted is a bare denial in the reply to the notice, unsupported by anything, contradicted by the documents.

The Supreme Court has been clear on one branch of this. Where a cheque is issued as security for repayment of a loan or for discharge of a debt that does exist, dishonour attracts Section 138. The security character of the instrument does not immunise it. The decisive question is the existence of the liability at the relevant time, not the label the parties used when they handed the cheque over.

The presumption and who has to displace it

Section 139 provides that unless the contrary is proved, the holder of a cheque is presumed to have received it for the discharge of a debt or liability. Section 118 adds presumptions about consideration and the date of the instrument. The effect is that the complainant starts with the advantage: he produces the cheque, the return memo and the notice, and the court presumes the debt.

The accused must rebut that presumption. Rebuttal is not proof beyond reasonable doubt; it is enough to make the existence of the debt improbable. But the standard is higher than a plausible story. In practice, the accused needs documents, or a witness, or admissions by the complainant in cross-examination, or a demonstrable gap in the complainant's account of how the money moved.

What usually decides it is the complainant's own evidence about the transaction. If the complainant says he advanced a loan in cash of a round figure and there is no entry in his books, no bank withdrawal, and no acknowledgement, the security defence becomes far stronger. If the complainant produces a ledger entry, a bank transfer and an agreement recording the loan, the security defence usually collapses even if the cheque was physically handed over at the time of the agreement.

The fact patterns that succeed

Some cases are genuinely strong for the drawer:

  • A blank cheque lodged with a landlord as an advance. If the tenancy never began, or the advance was adjusted, there was no liability at presentation.
  • A cheque given to a bank or a financier as collateral for a guarantee that was never invoked, and later presented after the relationship broke down.
  • A cheque given in a property transaction as a token, where the sale fell through and the cheque was presented for a sum the parties had never agreed as payable.
  • A cheque filled in by the payee beyond the authority given — a blank signed instrument completed for a figure the drawer never authorised. Here the defence shades into forgery and the burden shifts sharply.

Notice the pattern. In each, the drawer can show a transaction structure that makes the claimed liability implausible, not merely a different version of events.

The fact patterns that fail

Equally, some defences that sound attractive fail badly:

  • The drawer admits signing the cheque and admits the amount but says it was only "for security" for a loan he did take. The liability existed; the defence fails.
  • The drawer says the cheque was stolen or lost. Without a police complaint made at the time, and an FIR, this is treated as an afterthought.
  • The drawer says the complainant was to return the cheque after a settlement, and the settlement is undocumented. The court has only the drawer's word against a signed instrument.
  • The drawer says the signature is not his. That is a defence requiring expert evidence and a comparison under Section 73 of the Evidence Act, and it rarely succeeds on assertion alone.

What the drawer should do on receiving the notice

The reply to the statutory notice is the drawer's first and best opportunity. Within the fifteen days, send a written reply that does three things: identify the cheque, state the transaction in which it was given, and produce or refer to the documents that show the security character. Do not simply deny everything. A reply that asserts facts, with documents attached, creates the record on which the defence later stands.

Do not, however, treat the reply as a substitute for paying a genuine liability. Where the debt exists and only the timing is disputed, the prudent course is to pay or to settle, because a Section 138 conviction carries a fine and, in default, imprisonment, and the civil liability survives regardless.

A security defence that rests on the drawer's own word is a gamble. A security defence that rests on an agreement, a receipt and a bank statement is a case.

The Kolkata forum

Section 138 complaints are tried by a Magistrate, and in Kolkata the complaints are filed before the court having jurisdiction over the branch where the payee's account is maintained — commonly the courts at Bankshall for a central Kolkata branch, or the Magistrate's court for the relevant area. The trial is summary, evidence is by affidavit, and the case is appealable to the Sessions Court and thereafter to the Calcutta High Court.

The civil side is separate. A suit for recovery of the underlying debt can run in the City Civil Court in Kolkata, or in the High Court on its original side where the valuation or the subject matter requires it. The civil suit does not depend on the outcome of the criminal case, and the standard of proof is different.

Common questions

Can a security cheque be presented at all?

Yes, but only when a liability has arisen that the cheque was meant to secure. Presenting it before the contingency occurs is what creates the defence. A cheque presented after the liability crystallised is presented for discharge of that liability.

Does the agreement have to say "security"?

It helps enormously. An agreement that records the cheque's purpose, its amount and the event on which it may be presented is the single most useful document for the drawer. It is equally useful for the payee, who can then show the event occurred.

What if the cheque was undated and the payee filled in a date?

Filling in a date on a cheque delivered without one is generally permissible, and does not by itself invalidate the instrument. Filling in an amount beyond authority is a different matter and is treated as material alteration.

If you handed over a cheque as security and it has been presented, the reply to the notice is where the case is won or lost. Our cheque bounce practice covers both sides of these complaints, legal notice drafting covers the reply, and a recovery suit is the parallel civil route.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422