14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Pedestrian and child accident claims: how they are proved

A pedestrian struck at a crossing, or a child hit while walking to school, starts from a stronger position than most claimants realise. The law does not ask the injured person to prove that the driver was generally careless; it asks what a reasonable driver would have done in that place, at that hour, with that sight line. A pedestrian has no metal around him and a child has no judgement about speed, and both facts shape how a tribunal reads the evidence.

Duty of care is not the hard part of these cases

Every driver owes a duty to other road users, and the standard is that of a reasonably careful driver, not a perfect one. Where the victim is a pedestrian, the question is almost never whether a duty existed. It is whether the driver kept a proper look-out, matched speed to the conditions, and gave way where the law or the road layout required it. Where the victim is a child, courts hold drivers to a higher expectation of caution, because a child's behaviour on a road is unpredictable by nature and a driver approaching a school, a bus stop, a market or a residential lane is expected to anticipate it.

The defence usually runs on contributory negligence. The insurance company will say the pedestrian crossed mid-block, stepped off a footpath, or ran into the road. That argument reduces compensation rather than defeating the claim, and a tribunal apportions responsibility by percentage. A child below the age of criminal responsibility cannot be said to be contributorily negligent at all, and for older children the apportionment is usually modest because the law expects the adult driver to be the one carrying the risk.

The evidence that decides the case, and where it comes from

These claims are won or lost on the record built in the first fortnight. The first document is the police papers: the First Information Report, the charge-sheet if a prosecution followed, and the site sketch that the investigating officer prepares. That sketch is often the single most useful piece of evidence, because it fixes the position of the vehicle, the point of impact and the width of the road. Ask for it early, before the file moves to the court and becomes harder to trace.

Then comes medical evidence: the injury report from the hospital where the victim was first taken, the discharge summary, operation notes, and the treating doctor's assessment of permanent disability. For a child, a paediatric orthopaedic or neurology opinion about growth, limb-length discrepancy and future surgery carries real weight. Finally, photographic and video evidence. Most junctions in Kolkata now have traffic cameras, and many shops and residences have CCTV covering the footpath. A written application to the investigating officer, or to the tribunal once the claim is filed, to preserve and produce that footage should be made within days, because footage is overwritten on a short cycle.

Claims for a child: who files, and how the money is protected

A minor cannot file a suit or an application in his own name. The claim is brought by a guardian, usually a parent, described as the next friend, and the tribunal records that capacity at the outset. If the child has lost a parent in the same accident, the claim for loss of dependency is worked out on the parent's income and the child's status as a dependant; if the child himself is injured, the claim is for his own pain, suffering, treatment and loss of future prospects.

Awards to a minor are not paid out in cash to the guardian. Tribunals routinely direct that the amount be held in a fixed deposit in the child's name with a bank, released in stages, with the corpus available on attaining majority. Where the guardian is not the natural parent, or where there is a dispute between parents, the tribunal may require a guardianship order. Our page on guardianship of a minor sets out how that order is obtained, since the money and the custody question often arrive together.

Computing the award when the victim is a child

For a child who is injured, the tribunal assesses medical expenses actually incurred, future treatment, pain and suffering, and loss of earning capacity once the disability is quantified. Where the child has lost a parent, the multiplier is chosen from the age of the deceased parent, not the age of the child, and the child's dependency is treated as total until majority and often beyond it if education was ongoing.

For a very young child who dies, the tribunal cannot compute income, so it works from a notional figure and the settled heads of loss of estate, funeral expenses and loss of consortium for the parents, adding a sum for loss of the child's companionship. These figures are modest and there is no honest way to make them large. It is worth telling a grieving family that plainly rather than promising otherwise.

Whatever the age, the heads that a tribunal will allow are now fairly settled: medical expenses, loss of earnings during treatment, pain and suffering, loss of amenities, loss of future income where disability is proved, and, in fatal cases, dependency, loss of estate, funeral expenses and consortium. Bills matter here more than argument. Our note on motor accident claims explains how the file is assembled from the hospital record.

Where the claim is filed in Kolkata

An application under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 goes to a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, and the tribunal has jurisdiction where the accident occurred, where the claimant resides, or where the owner of the vehicle resides. In Kolkata, claims are heard by the tribunal attached to the City Civil Court. Accidents on the fringes of the city go to the district court at Barasat for North 24 Parganas or at Alipore for South 24 Parganas, and each of those districts has its own tribunal. For claims arising in the northern suburbs, our page on the lawyer at Barasat sets out the tribunal there.

Choosing the wrong tribunal is not fatal but it costs months, because the file is returned for presentation in the correct court. Where the victim lives in Behala or Garia and the accident happened on the Basanti Highway, that choice is worth thinking about before the application is drafted.

What typically goes wrong

  • The claim is filed only against the driver. The insurance company must be on the array, and so must the owner, or recovery becomes a personal hunt for a man who may have no assets.
  • No disability certificate. A claim for loss of future income on a leg injury without a medical board assessment is usually cut down to the bills and a modest conventional sum.
  • Bills discarded. Original hospital bills, pharmacy slips and ambulance receipts are the backbone of the special damages claim. Duplicates invite objection.
  • Delay in preserving footage. CCTV is gone within weeks. By the time the claim is numbered, the only version of events is the driver's.
  • Contributory negligence conceded too early. A statement in the claim that the pedestrian was crossing at a place other than a zebra crossing can be used to fix a share of responsibility that may not have been justified on the site sketch.

What the family should do in the first week

Keep the discharge summary and every bill in one envelope. Note the vehicle number, the time and the exact stretch of road. Get the contact details of any bystander who saw it, because eyewitnesses in these cases are often shopkeepers who will speak if approached early and will forget if approached after six months. File the police complaint the same day, and follow up for a copy of the FIR. Then speak to an advocate about whether the claim should be filed at the City Civil Court tribunal or in the district where the accident happened.

Common questions

Can a pedestrian be held partly at fault for crossing away from a zebra crossing?

Yes, and tribunals do apportion blame in that situation. The reduction is usually a share of the total, not a bar to the claim. What matters is whether the driver had a clear sight line and enough distance to stop. If the answer is that he did, the pedestrian's error affects the quantum, not the entitlement.

Who gets the money when the injured person is a child?

The tribunal directs the award into a fixed deposit held for the child, with the guardian drawing only what is needed for treatment and education. The guardian does not receive the capital. This is a deliberate protection, and tribunals in Kolkata apply it as a matter of course in any award to a minor.

Is a claim possible if the vehicle was never traced?

Yes, but the route is different. Where the offending vehicle is unidentified, the claim is made against the insurer of the vehicle in which the victim was travelling, or, in a hit-and-run case, the compensation scheme administered through the tribunal is the practical remedy. The evidence bar is higher because there is no driver to cross-examine.

Does a criminal case have to finish first?

No. The claim before the tribunal is independent of the prosecution. A criminal case can run for years, and the tribunal is entitled to decide negligence on its own record. Waiting for the criminal trial to end is one of the most common reasons a family loses the best years of a claim.

The claim is a documentary exercise more than a rhetorical one. A pedestrian or a child victim with a clean hospital record, a site sketch and an early-preserved CCTV clip is in a far better position than one with an eloquent petition and no papers. Build the file first, then draft.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422