A commercial dispute above the specified value is heard by a specialised court with a statutory timetable, and that is the whole point of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. In Kolkata the route depends on the value: a suit within the ordinary original jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court and above the specified value goes to the Commercial Division on the original side, while a lower-valued claim goes to the Commercial Court in the City Civil Court.
What counts as a commercial dispute
The Act defines a commercial dispute as one arising out of the ordinary transactions of merchants, bankers, financiers and traders. The definition then lists the categories that fall within it, and a dispute of one of those kinds is commercial even if the parties are individuals rather than companies.
- Disputes relating to the carriage of goods, export or import of merchandise, and the storage or supply of goods.
- Construction and infrastructure contracts, including tenders and sub-contracts.
- Agreements relating to immovable property used exclusively in trade or commerce.
- Franchising, distribution and licensing agreements, and joint ventures and shareholder agreements.
- Mercantile agency, management and consultancy services.
- Intellectual property rights, and agreements relating to them.
Three exclusions matter. A dispute arising out of a real estate project regulated by the RERA is outside the commercial courts, as are tenancy disputes relating to immovable property and consumer complaints. A suit on a loan between two individuals for a house is not a commercial dispute merely because money is involved.
The specified value
The specified value is the value of the subject matter in dispute, assessed in the manner the Act prescribes, and it was reduced by an amendment in 2018 to three lakh rupees. Every dispute of the listed kinds whose specified value is at or above that figure is a commercial dispute for the purposes of the Act, and the ordinary civil courts do not hear it.
Where the High Court has ordinary original civil jurisdiction, as the Calcutta High Court does for Kolkata, the Act creates a Commercial Division of that High Court and a Commercial Appellate Division. Where the High Court has no such jurisdiction, Commercial Courts are constituted at the district level, presided over by a District Judge or by an officer of equivalent rank. In West Bengal, both structures exist: the Commercial Division of the Calcutta High Court for suits of the specified value filed within its original jurisdiction, and Commercial Courts at the district level for the rest.
The timetable that makes it faster
The Act inserts a case management regime into the Code of Civil Procedure. After the written statement is filed, the court holds a case management hearing within the period the Act specifies, and at that hearing it frames a timeline for the trial, fixes the dates for the examination of witnesses, and directs the parties to file the documents and the affidavits they intend to rely on.
The trial is to be completed within six months of the first case management hearing, and the court may extend it on reasons recorded in writing. In practice extensions are common, but the framework changes the culture of the suit: dates are fixed at the outset and adjournments require a reason, which is not the ordinary experience in a civil court.
The Act also amends the provisions on disclosure, so that a party must file a list of all documents in its power, possession, control or custody that relate to the suit, and the obligation continues through the trial. A party that fails to disclose a document cannot rely on it later without the court's permission.
Summary judgment and the pre-institution mediation
Two features of the commercial regime are less well known and very useful. The first is summary judgment, which allows the court to decide a claim or a part of it without a full trial where the plaintiff has a strong case and the defendant has no real prospect of success. A defendant who files a vague written statement in a commercial suit now faces the prospect of judgment on the papers.
The second is pre-institution mediation. Except where the plaintiff seeks urgent interim relief, a suit that does not contemplate such relief must be preceded by an application for mediation under the Legal Services Authorities Act. The mediation is conducted by the authorities' mediation centres, usually within a short statutory period, and a settlement reached there is enforceable as an award. A commercial suit filed without the mediation application is liable to be rejected at the filing stage, and this is the commonest reason a commercial plaint comes back. Where the claim is a money claim, the pleading follows the pattern on our recovery suits page.
Arbitration applications in a commercial dispute
Where the parties have an arbitration agreement and the dispute is commercial, the applications that arise out of the arbitration go to the Commercial Court or the Commercial Division rather than to the ordinary court. That includes applications for interim measures under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, and applications to set aside an award. This routes the ancillary litigation to the same specialised bench as the underlying dispute, which is a real advantage in a contested arbitration.
The appeal from a Commercial Court at the district level lies to the Commercial Appellate Division of the High Court, and from the Commercial Division of the High Court to the Commercial Appellate Division of the same court, in each case within sixty days. Our page on arbitration deals with the drafting of the clause and the conduct of the reference.
Where a commercial suit is filed in Kolkata
For a commercial dispute arising within the ordinary original jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court and above the specified value, the plaint is filed on the original side and is allocated to the Commercial Division. For a lower-valued claim, the plaint goes to the Commercial Court, which in Kolkata sits within the City Civil Court. For a dispute arising in North or South 24 Parganas, the Commercial Court is at the district court in Barasat or Alipore. The general conduct of such a suit is described under civil litigation.
Filing on the original side and claiming a higher value than the subject matter warrants is a common mistake. The court will return the plaint or transfer it, and the delay can be substantial. The value should be assessed from the transaction documents, not from the ambition of the claim.
Common questions
Is every suit between two companies a commercial suit?
No. The dispute must be of one of the listed kinds. A suit for defamation between two companies, or a dispute over the partition of property held by a company, may fall outside the definition unless it fits a listed category.
Does the Act apply to an arbitration outside India?
The Act's amendments to the arbitration law apply to the applications arising out of arbitrations seated in India in commercial disputes. An international commercial arbitration has its own provisions on the court's supervisory role, and the route should be checked for the particular clause.
Can a commercial suit be transferred to the ordinary civil court?
Where the court finds that the dispute is not commercial, the suit is transferred to the court that has jurisdiction. That is a wasted filing and months lost, which is why the definition should be read against the facts before the plaint is drafted.
What happens if the pre-institution mediation fails?
The mediation authority issues a report of failure, and the suit is then filed with that report annexed. The period spent in mediation is excluded from the limitation for the suit, which removes the risk of the process consuming the limitation period.
The commercial regime rewards preparation. A plaint with the mediation report, a correct valuation, a complete list of documents and a summary judgment application ready in reserve will move faster than any civil suit in the city. A plaint filed in a hurry on the wrong side of the threshold starts with a defect and rarely recovers the time.