The ordinary rule is that costs follow the event: the party who loses pays the costs of the party who wins. What the court awards is not what the winner actually spent, but a figure the court considers reasonable, and it is often much smaller than the legal bill. The court has full discretion to depart from the rule, and it does so where a party has made the litigation necessary by his conduct, or where the case was filed without any basis.
The statutory foundation
The award of costs is governed by the Code of Civil Procedure, whose provisions make it clear that costs are in the discretion of the court and that the court may determine by whom, out of what property, to what extent and on what account the costs are to be paid. The starting point is the unsuccessful party, but the discretion is real and it is exercised in both directions.
Where a plaintiff has claimed more than what the court considers reasonable, the court may refuse costs on the excess. Where a plaintiff has succeeded on part of the claim and failed on the rest, the court apportions. Where the defendant made a reasonable offer that the plaintiff refused, the court can take that into account.
Costs are also recoverable in execution, and the decree usually includes the costs as part of the sum for which execution is taken out.
What goes into a bill of costs
A bill of costs is prepared by the winning party at the conclusion of the suit, and it is taxed or assessed by the court's office before it is allowed. The components vary by forum but typically include:
- Court fees paid on the plaint.
- Fees paid for certified copies, translations and exhibits.
- Travel and other expenses of witnesses entitled to be paid.
- Charges for service of process and for summons.
- Advocate's fee, computed by reference to the court's scale, not the fee actually agreed.
On the original side of the Calcutta High Court, the taxing master assesses the bill, and the assessment may itself be a contested hearing in which the paying party objects to individual items. In the City Civil Court and the district courts, the bill is similarly scrutinised by the office and then approved by the court.
The gap between the bill and the bill of costs
The scale fee allowed as costs is usually a small fraction of what the advocate actually charges. This is the point that surprises clients most. A successful plaintiff who spent a substantial sum on litigation will recover a modest proportion of it as costs, and the judgment will call it costs.
That is a reason not to treat the recovery of costs as part of the financial plan of a suit. It is a contribution, not a reimbursement. Where a claim is small, the costs recovered are correspondingly small, and where the claim is large, the scale fee does not keep pace with the actual spend.
For particular categories of proceedings the position is different. In consumer proceedings, the commissions award costs more generously and sometimes on the basis of the deficiency established. In arbitration, the tribunal under the Arbitration Act has a discretion that in practice is exercised by reference to the actual cost of the arbitration, in the manner of the international practice.
When the court departs from the rule
The common departures:
- Adjournments and delay. A party who sought repeated adjournments and lost may be ordered to pay costs of the adjournments, even if he wins the rest.
- False pleas. A defendant who denied a document that he had signed, and was forced to admit it, is a candidate for costs.
- Public interest and test cases. A bona fide test case or a public interest matter may be decided without costs.
- Part-success. A plaintiff who recovered on one head and failed on the rest may be awarded a proportion of costs or none.
- Conduct in the litigation. Withholding documents, failing to comply with an order, and seeking relief that had to be abandoned at the hearing all affect the exercise of discretion.
Applications for the costs on an interlocutory order are often made and often refused, because the court prefers to deal with the costs of the suit at the end rather than in fragments.
Costs orders can be enforced
An order to pay costs is a money decree, executable like any other. Where the costs order was made on an interlocutory application, the party entitled to it can move for execution without waiting for the suit to end. In practice, courts often direct that the costs be paid into court or adjusted against a sum payable to the other side.
Where a party is unable to pay the other side's costs, the court may order the costs to be paid into court as a condition of continuing, or may stay the proceedings until they are paid. That power is used sparingly but it exists.
Costs are the court's estimate of what the litigation should have cost, not what it did cost. Budget for the difference.
Costs in the Kolkata courts
On the original side of the Calcutta High Court, the taxing master's office assesses bills of costs, and the process is documented. In the City Civil Court at Kolkata, the bill is prepared after the decree and placed before the court for approval. In the district courts at Alipore and Barasat, the same procedure applies with the local scale.
Where the suit is one to which the Commercial Courts Act applies, the costs regime is more detailed and the court is required to consider whether the party has pursued a claim that had no reasonable prospect of success. That has produced more substantial costs orders in commercial suits than the traditional scale.
Common questions
Can costs be awarded against a party who is not a litigant?
Rarely. The court can order costs against a person who has caused the litigation to be conducted in a particular way, but that power is exceptional. The ordinary rule is that costs are between the parties.
Do I have to pay costs before appealing?
An appeal does not ordinarily require the costs to be deposited, but the appellate court may direct the appellant to deposit or secure the costs as a condition of the stay. A failure to comply can lead to the stay being vacated.
Is the advocate's fee recoverable in full?
No. The costs allowed are assessed by the court's own scale, which is not the fee agreed between the advocate and the client. The difference is borne by the client.
Ask for costs in the prayer, prepare the bill promptly after the decree, and do not build a budget around recovering the legal spend. Our civil litigation practice handles suits and the taxation of costs in the Kolkata courts, and our fee schedule sets out the published charges, and recovery suits covers the money claim the costs attach to.