14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Civil Procedure

Court Fees in West Bengal: Computation on a Money Suit

Court fee in West Bengal is charged under the West Bengal Court-fees and Suits Valuation Act, 1970, and on a money suit it is ad valorem: a percentage of the amount claimed, on a scale fixed by the state law. The fee is payable when the plaint is presented. A shortfall does not destroy the suit straight away, because the court has power to allow the deficiency to be made up, but it does delay the matter and can end it if it is not cured.

Two valuations, not one

A plaint carries two values, and they do different work. The value for the purposes of court fee is fixed by the state court-fees law. The value for the purposes of jurisdiction is fixed by the statute that confers jurisdiction on the court, such as the City Civil Court Act for Kolkata. The two can differ, and the appropriate forum is decided by the jurisdictional value.

In a money suit the two usually coincide, because the claim is a sum of money. In other suits they diverge. A suit for declaration with a consequential relief is valued for court fee on the value of the relief claimed, and for jurisdiction on the value stated. A partition suit is valued on the plaintiff's share of the property. A suit for specific performance is valued under the provisions that deal with it. A suit for an injunction carries a fixed fee.

The distinction matters most when a defendant objects. A plaint that undervalues the relief for the purpose of keeping the suit in a lower court invites an application for rejection under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, on the ground that the relief has not been properly valued. The objection is decided on the plaint and the documents, and the court can require the plaintiff to correct the valuation.

How a money suit is valued

The amount claimed is the sum due at the date of the plaint, including interest that has accrued up to that date. Where the claim is for a debt payable in instalments, the whole amount due is taken. Where the claim is for damages, the amount claimed in the plaint fixes the value, and the court fee is computed on it, though the court may ultimately award less.

A plaintiff who claims an unascertained sum, such as damages to be assessed, still has to state a figure for valuation and pay on it. A plaintiff who claims an account, asking the court to take accounts, pays on the value stated and then, if the account discloses a larger sum, may have to pay additional fee on the amount found due. This is the one situation in a money claim where the fee can increase during the litigation, and the plaintiff should be ready for it.

Interest after the date of the plaint is a separate question. The claim for future interest is a relief, and the practice differs between courts on whether a fresh fee is needed when it is awarded. The safe course is to plead interest up to the date of the plaint in the valuation, and to claim further interest as a relief without including it in the valuation.

What happens if the fee is short

Section 149 of the Code allows the court, in its discretion, to permit a party to make up the deficiency in court fee at any stage. The plaint is received, and time is granted. The court may impose terms, including costs. Where the plaintiff does not pay within the time allowed, the court may dismiss the suit, and a dismissal for non-payment of court fee is a dismissal on the merits for some purposes, so the plaintiff should treat the deadline as final.

There is a second consequence. A suit in which the court fee is deficient is, until the deficiency is made up, not properly instituted, and an appeal filed in the meantime may be met with the objection that the suit itself was not maintainable. It is cheaper to compute the fee correctly at the start than to argue about it later.

Court fee at later stages

  • Appeal: the memorandum of appeal carries a fee on the value of the subject matter, ordinarily on the same basis as the suit, and in some cases at a reduced scale. The fee is payable at the time of filing.
  • Cross-objection: a cross-objection by the respondent carries its own fee on the value of the relief sought, and it is not free.
  • Execution: the decree-holder pays a fee on the amount sought to be recovered in execution, computed on the amount claimed from the judgement debtor.
  • Review and miscellaneous applications: a fixed fee, as the state law prescribes for the application.

Court fee on the suit is part of the costs of the suit, and a successful plaintiff usually recovers it in the decree. Where the plaintiff settles, the question is whether any part of the fee can be recovered or refunded. The conditions in the state law are strict, and the position depends on the stage at which the settlement occurs; a party settling should ask the court's office what is recoverable rather than assume.

Where the fee goes, and why it matters to the choice of forum

The court fee is state revenue. That is why the state law, and not the Code of Civil Procedure, fixes the rate, and why the rates differ between states. For a plaintiff in Kolkata, the forum may be the Presidency Small Cause Court, which deals with small money claims and has its own procedure and fee structure; the City Civil Court at Kolkata, for claims within its pecuniary jurisdiction; or the original side of the Calcutta High Court, for claims above it. Each forum has its own rules on procedure and its own scale for some items, and the choice affects both the fee and the pace.

A plaintiff should compare not only the fee but the cost of the forum, the availability of a summary procedure, and the difficulty of execution in the place where the defendant's assets are. A slightly higher fee in a forum that grants a quicker decree is usually the better bargain.

Practical steps

  1. Compute the claim precisely, with the interest to the date of the plaint, and state the valuation in the plaint.
  2. Check the current scale in the state court-fees law before filing, because the figures are amended from time to time and old precedents quote old rates.
  3. Purchase the court fee stamp or pay it in the manner the court's office requires, and keep the receipt with the plaint papers.
  4. Where the valuation is arguable, plead the basis of the valuation in the plaint so that the objection can be answered on the pleading.
  5. If the deficiency is pointed out, apply for time under Section 149 immediately rather than after the deadline.

Our recovery suits practice computes the court fee and the jurisdictional value together with the plaint, and civil litigation covers the appellate stages where the fee recurs.

Common questions

Is the court fee a percentage of the claim?

Yes, on an ad valorem suit. The scale is in the state court-fees law, and it rises with the amount claimed. There is no single percentage that applies to every claim.

Can I file a suit with a low valuation to keep it in a lower court?

Not properly. The valuation must bear a reasonable relationship to the relief. A deliberate undervaluation invites an application for rejection of the plaint and an order to make up the fee and the valuation.

Is the court fee refundable if I settle?

Sometimes, and on strict conditions that depend on the stage. Ask the court's office, and do not plan the settlement on the assumption that the fee comes back.

Does the defendant pay court fee?

Only if the defendant files a counterclaim, a set-off or a cross-objection, each of which carries its own fee. Otherwise the fee of the suit is the plaintiff's cost, recovered in the decree if he wins.

Compute the fee with the same care as the claim itself. If you are unsure of the valuation for a particular relief, contact the office; the fees are published.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Civil Procedure

The Stages of a Civil Suit in Kolkata

From the plaint and summons through issues, evidence and judgement to execution, the stages of a civil suit in a Kolkata court and what each costs in time.

Read
Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422