A death claim before a Motor Accident Claims Tribunal is not a single figure. It is a sum of heads: the loss of dependency to the family, the loss of consortium to the spouse and, in the case of parents, the loss of a child's company, together with fixed amounts for loss of estate and funeral expenses. The method was settled by the Constitution Bench in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Pranay Sethi in 2017, and most of the argument in a death claim now concerns the income figure and the number of dependants.
Who may claim, and how the tribunal starts
The claim is filed under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, by the legal representatives of the deceased. The tribunal's task under Section 168 is to make an award determining the compensation which appears to it to be just. That word has been given a structure over the years.
The first step is to identify the dependants. A parent, spouse, minor child or adult child who was supported by the deceased can claim. So can a sibling in the limited case where dependency is proved. The tribunal then asks what each dependant has lost in money terms, which is why evidence of the deceased's income and of the household's reliance on it matters more than the length of the petition.
The multiplicand: income, less tax, plus prospects
The multiplicand is the deceased's annual income. For a salaried person this is the gross salary shown in the salary certificate and the income tax return, less the tax actually payable. Allowances that would have continued, such as house rent allowance in some cases, and deductions that are personal to the employee, require care. For a self-employed person the income is proved from the return, the books, the bank statements and, in a shop or professional practice, the testimony of customers or patients.
Where income is not documented, the tribunal may adopt the minimum wage for a specified category of work, or make an estimate consistent with the occupation and the place. It cannot simply adopt a figure; it has to say why.
To the income so found, an addition for future prospects is made where the deceased had a stable income. The settled proportions rise with youth: a larger addition for a person under forty, a smaller one between forty and fifty, a smaller one still between fifty and sixty, and none above sixty. These figures are now treated as law rather than as discretion, and a tribunal that omits the addition is appealing successfully.
The multiplier, chosen by the age of the deceased
The annual dependency is multiplied by a figure drawn from the table in Sarla Verma v. Delhi Transport Corporation. The multiplier reflects the number of years the dependency might have continued, and it is chosen by the age of the deceased, not the age of the claimant. A common error is to apply the multiplier for the youngest dependant, which inflates the award, or for the eldest, which depresses it. Either way the award is vulnerable.
The multiplier is applied to the multiplicand after deduction of the deceased's personal and living expenses. That deduction is proportionate: a larger share is treated as personal expenditure where there are fewer dependants, and a smaller share where there are many. The logic is that a person supporting a large household spends less on himself.
Loss of consortium, estate and funeral expenses
Pranay Sethi fixed the conventional heads. Loss of consortium was set at ₹40,000, and loss of estate and funeral expenses at ₹15,000 each, with a direction that these sums be increased by ten per cent every three years. The Court also made clear that consortium is not confined to a spouse: a parent can claim loss of a child's consortium, which the judgments describe as filial consortium, and a child can claim for the loss of a parent.
These heads are not a windfall and they are not a place for invention. A tribunal that awards a round lakh under "love and affection" without naming the head, or that multiplies the conventional amounts by the number of claimants in an arbitrary way, produces an award that is corrected on appeal. The correct approach is to apply the fixed sums and then explain any additional award by reference to proved facts, such as the actual funeral expenditure supported by bills.
Conventional heads are meant to be conventional. Their value is that they are predictable, not that they are generous.
Medical expenses before death, and loss to the estate
Where the deceased was treated before death, the hospital bills are recoverable as special damages, provided they are proved and were reasonably incurred. So is the cost of transport of the body and of the funeral rites, to the extent it exceeds the conventional allowance. Claims for the loss of an expected inheritance, or for the deceased's future savings, are not separate heads: they are already inside the dependency figure and cannot be claimed twice.
What goes wrong in Kolkata files
The most frequent difficulty is the income proof. A shopkeeper with no return, a driver paid in cash, a tailor working from home: each requires a different kind of evidence, and the tribunal will not accept an affidavit of income at face value. Bank statements, GST returns, receipts, and the evidence of a regular customer do more than a claim of a monthly figure.
The second is the dependant list. Where a claimant dies during the proceedings, or a dependant is added late, the record has to be amended. Where two sets of claimants file separate petitions for the same accident, the tribunal consolidates them, but the awards must not duplicate the dependency.
The third is the insurance defence. The insurer may plead a fake licence, a breach of the policy condition, or that the deceased was a gratuitous passenger. Under Section 149 the insurer is liable to satisfy the award even where a condition is breached, with a right to recover from the insured, but the point must be met with the policy and the permit on record.
A death claim is heard by the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal attached to the civil courts in Kolkata, and an appeal from its award goes to the Calcutta High Court under Section 173. The papers are best prepared by the person who will prove them, so the family's first task is to collect the salary slips, the return, the hospital records and the death certificate before the claim is drafted. Our motor accident claims team can assess what a particular file is likely to yield before it is filed, and civil litigation support is available if the award has to be challenged.
Common questions
Is the entire salary taken, or a part of it?
The gross income less tax is the starting point, and then the deceased's own living expenses are deducted. The net figure, increased for future prospects, becomes the multiplicand. So the family does not receive the whole salary as compensation for each remaining year.
Can parents claim for an unmarried son's death?
Yes. Parents are dependants where they were supported by the son, and they can claim both the dependency and, in an appropriate case, filial consortium. The tribunal will look at the son's income, his contribution to the household and the number of dependants.
Are the conventional amounts still the same?
The sums fixed in 2017 were directed to be revised upward by ten per cent every three years. The tribunal applies the sums as revised from time to time. Rather than rely on a figure quoted online, check what the award itself records and what the current revision is.
What if the deceased had no income of his own?
A homemaker's contribution is valued, and tribunals do award compensation for the loss of household services. A student's death is compensated by reference to the family's loss and, where the evidence supports it, the likely future earnings. Neither case is dismissed merely because there was no salary slip.
If you are dealing with a death in a road accident, the file should be built backwards from the evidence: what can be proved about income, who actually depended on it, and what the family spent. That is the order in which the tribunal will ask the questions. You can contact the office for a first review, and the fee schedule sets out what that review costs.