India has no lemon law. A defective vehicle is dealt with under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, and the case is won or lost on the service history. A buyer who complains three times in writing and keeps every job card has a case; a buyer who complains at the service desk and keeps nothing has a memory. The warranty is a contractual promise, and the refusal of it is a deficiency in service if the promise was broken.
What the warranty actually promises
A manufacturer's warranty undertakes to repair or replace a defective part within a period and a mileage limit, subject to conditions. The conditions are the battleground: that the vehicle be serviced at authorised workshops at the prescribed intervals, that no unauthorised repair or modification be carried out, that the defect not arise from an accident, misuse or normal wear, and that the claim be made within the period.
A dealer that refuses a claim on these grounds must be able to point to the condition and the fact that it was breached. "Normal wear" is not a conclusion; it is an assertion that needs a reason, and for a component that failed within the warranty period and at a low mileage, the reason must be technical.
The warranty is in addition to the buyer's statutory rights. A defect that existed at the time of sale is a defect in the goods, whether or not the warranty covers it, and a manufacturer or dealer who sells a defective vehicle has not performed the contract. That is the route when the warranty period has expired but the defect is proved to have been present from the start.
The documents that decide the case
- The invoice, the registration certificate and the warranty booklet with the period and the conditions.
- Every job card, including the ones where the dealer wrote "no fault found". Those are the most valuable documents in the file, because they prove that the buyer complained and the dealer had the vehicle.
- The dealer's written replies, emails and WhatsApp messages, including the ones that promise a repair "as a goodwill gesture".
- Photographs and videos of the defect, dated.
- The diagnostic scan report, if the dealer will give it. Ask for it in writing at each visit.
- An independent opinion from a workshop that does not service the brand, or from an automotive engineer, on the cause of the failure.
The job card is the heart of the case. It shows the date, the complaint as recorded, the work done and the vehicle's odometer. A series of job cards for the same complaint, spread over months, is far stronger than an assertion that the vehicle was always in the workshop.
The refusal letters that are really admissions
Dealers write carefully, and their letters often help the complainant. A letter that says the clutch was replaced "as a gesture" admits that the clutch failed. A letter that says the engine noise is "characteristic of the model" admits the noise. A letter that offers a discount on the repair cost is a settlement offer, and it should be preserved rather than answered in anger.
What the dealer will not do is admit a manufacturing defect in writing. That is why the independent opinion matters: it supplies the word the dealer avoids. An engineer's report that identifies a casting flaw, a design fault in a known component, or a failure inconsistent with the mileage gives the commission a technical basis for a finding.
Product liability under the 2019 Act
The Act introduced a product liability chapter. A manufacturer is liable for a defective product, for a manufacturing defect, a design defect or a failure to warn; a product service provider is liable for a deficiency in the service; a product seller is liable in defined circumstances, including where it exercised substantial control over the product or made an express warranty. A claimant may proceed against any of them, and the commission decides which liability applies on the evidence.
The remedy is not automatic. The complainant must show the defect, the harm and the causal link. For a vehicle that repeatedly breaks down, the harm includes the cost of repairs, the cost of a substitute vehicle, and the loss of use, each of which needs its own evidence.
The relief a commission can give
The commission can order the removal of the defect, the replacement of the goods, the refund of the price, compensation for loss, and the cost of the proceedings. In a vehicle case, the practical orders are these: repair at the manufacturer's cost, replacement with a new vehicle of the same model, or refund of the price on return of the vehicle with an adjustment for use.
Replacement and refund are not granted lightly. The commission looks at the number of failures, the nature of the defect, whether the vehicle was unusable for substantial periods, and whether the dealer had a fair opportunity to repair. A single repair that was done properly does not justify a refund; five visits for the same fault, with the vehicle off the road for weeks, may.
How the complaint runs in Kolkata
The complaint is filed before the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission for the district where the dealer is situate, or before the West Bengal State Commission at Kolkata if the value of the vehicle exceeds the district limit. The dealer and the manufacturer should both be made parties, because the dealer sold and the manufacturer warranted, and an order against one alone may not produce the remedy.
Filing is through e-Daakhil or in person. The complaint should attach the documents in a numbered list, state the relief precisely, and give a chronology that a reader can follow in one page. The commission's process is documentary, and the complainant's evidence is by affidavit; the dealer's service manager is usually examined, and his job cards are put to him.
Interim relief is limited. The commission can direct the dealer to repair the vehicle pending the case, which is often the most useful order for a buyer who needs the vehicle. It can also direct production of the service records.
Where the defect also caused an accident, the claim may include the injury and the damage, and the file overlaps with a motor accident claim. The two should be coordinated so that the same loss is not claimed twice. Our consumer protection practice handles vehicle complaints, and the accident claims practice covers the injury side.
Common questions
Can I demand a new vehicle if the engine was replaced under warranty?
A replacement of a major component does not by itself entitle the buyer to a new vehicle. The commission looks at whether the defect persisted and whether the vehicle was substantially unusable. Repeated failures of the same component after replacement are the stronger case.
Does servicing at an independent garage void the warranty?
It can, if the warranty makes authorised servicing a condition and the independent work caused the defect. The dealer must show the causal link, not merely the fact of the outside service.
What if the vehicle was bought second-hand?
A private sale carries caveat emptor and the manufacturer's warranty may not transfer in full. A purchase from a dealer who described the vehicle as accident-free or certified carries a representation, and a false one is an unfair trade practice.
How long does a vehicle complaint take?
Longer than the buyer expects, especially where the manufacturer is a large company and the commission's docket is full. A well-documented complaint that seeks repair rather than refund is usually resolved sooner.
Start with the job cards. If the same complaint appears on three of them, you have a case worth filing. To have a file assessed, contact the office; our fees are published on the site.