An instrument that is not duly stamped cannot be used in evidence, and that is the whole of the sanction. Deficient stamp duty impounding works because the document is useless until the defect is cured: a court will refuse to look at an under-stamped sale deed, a sub-registrar will not register it, and the party holding it discovers the problem at the moment he needs the document most.
The cure exists. The instrument can be impounded and sent to the Collector, the deficit can be paid with a penalty, and the document then becomes admissible. The question in most files is not whether it can be cured but who pays and how long it takes.
What "duly stamped" means
Stamp duty in West Bengal is charged under the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 as amended in its application to the state, on the instrument, at the rate in the schedule, on the consideration or the market value of the property, whichever is higher. The market value is ordinarily taken from the circle rate notified for the area, with an adjustment for the nature of the property and the period.
An instrument is duly stamped when the correct duty for its description has been paid. Under-valuation is the usual problem: the deed recites a consideration below the circle rate, the registering officer notices it, and the reference follows. A wrong description is the second problem: a deed headed as an agreement to sell when it is in substance a sale, or as a partition when it is a settlement in favour of a stranger, pays the wrong rate.
The mechanism
Section 33 of the Indian Stamp Act allows any person who has authority to receive evidence, and any public officer before whom an instrument is produced, to impound it if it appears not to be duly stamped. The impounded instrument is sent to the Collector, who determines the duty payable and the penalty.
Section 35 is the bar: an instrument not duly stamped is inadmissible in evidence, and cannot be acted upon, recorded or registered. Its proviso allows the court, on payment of the duty and the penalty, to admit the instrument in evidence. Section 40 deals with the Collector's power to adjudicate the amount, and section 42 with the endorsement and the return of the instrument once the amount is paid.
Penalties are prescribed in the Act and the current scale should be read from the text; in practice a deficiency that is explained as a mistake attracts a lower penalty than one that appears deliberate, and an intentional under-valuation to defraud the revenue attracts a separate penalty under section 64.
The situations that produce a deficiency
A sale deed at a consideration below the circle rate, executed years ago when the circle rate was lower and now challenged. A gift deed to a person who is not a relative, on which duty at the sale rate is payable rather than the concessional rate for relatives. A partition deed where the shares are unequal and the difference is treated as a settlement. A lease for a long term, where the duty is computed on the rent capitalised over the term. A power of attorney authorising a sale, which attracts duty in West Bengal in certain forms.
Each of these is a description question before it is a value question, and the correction is made by reading the schedule rather than by negotiating with the sub-registrar.
Registration, and the reference on under-valuation
Where the registering officer suspects that the consideration does not reflect the market value, he does not refuse registration outright. He registers the document and refers the question of value to the Collector under the state's provision for under-stamped instruments, and the Collector then issues a notice to the parties and determines the deficit. The deed is registered, but the parties face a demand, and until it is satisfied the record shows the position.
The parties can contest the valuation before the Collector with comparable sale instances and a valuer's report. The circle rate is a floor, not an irrebuttable figure, and a property with a defect, an encumbrance or an unauthorised structure can be shown to be worth less than the rate, just as a property on a developed road can be shown to be worth more.
Where the impounding happens: the courts and the offices
In a civil suit before the City Civil Court at Kolkata or the district court at Alipore or Barasat, the document is produced at the marking stage, the objection is taken, and the court impounds it and sends it to the Collector. In a criminal trial before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall, the same happens where a document is produced as evidence.
Before the sub-registrar, the deficiency is dealt with at the presentation stage, and the document is either registered with a reference or held until the duty is paid. Before the Collector, the adjudication is a revenue proceeding with a notice, a hearing and an order.
An order of the Collector is revisable, and the revision lies to the state government or the Board of Revenue as the Act provides, with a writ petition to the Calcutta High Court where the order is without jurisdiction. The period for revision is short and should be confirmed from the order itself.
Who bears the deficiency
The Act places the obligation on the parties to the instrument, and in a sale the practice is that the buyer pays the duty. Where the deficiency is discovered after the sale, the buyer who has paid the price carries the loss unless the agreement provides for it, which is why the indemnity clause in the sale deed matters.
As between the parties, a seller who executed a deed reciting a false consideration can be made to bear the penalty in a suit for damages, but the buyer's immediate problem is that his document is inadmissible until he pays, and the Collector will pursue the person who produced it.
What goes wrong
The first failure is executing a deed on a valuation the parties know is low, on the advice that the sub-registrar will not notice. Where the reference is made, the deficit is the least of the costs, because the penalty and the delay come with it.
The second is producing the document in a suit without checking the stamp. The objection is taken by the other side, the document goes to the Collector, and the trial is adjourned for months over a sum that could have been paid at the outset.
The third is curing the deficit on the original and not on the certified copy, which leaves the court record without an admissible copy, and the fourth is paying the duty without obtaining the Collector's endorsement, which means the document is still not marked as duly stamped.
Can an under-stamped sale deed be registered?
Registration requires the duty to be paid, and the registering officer will ordinarily require the deficit to be paid before the document is admitted. Where the question is one of valuation rather than of a short payment, the document may be registered with a reference to the Collector, and the demand follows.
Does a deficiency make the sale void?
No. The transfer is not void for want of stamp; the document is inadmissible in evidence until the defect is cured. The sale can still be established by other evidence, but the deed itself is unusable until it is stamped.
Who pays the penalty?
The Collector demands the duty and the penalty from the person who produces the instrument, and in a sale that is the buyer in practice. The recovery can be followed against the party who executed the instrument, and the apportionment is a matter between the parties.
Is there a time limit for impounding?
The power to impound is exercisable whenever the instrument is produced before a person with authority, so there is no separate limitation for the stamp defect. The limitation that matters is the one for the suit in which the document is produced.
The practical discipline is to compute the duty from the schedule and the circle rate before the deed is engrossed, and to keep the valuation working paper with the file. Our registration practice handles the adjudication and the Collector proceedings, and the litigation team deals with impounding objections in a pending suit. The property law practice advises on the correct description and rate. Begin at our contact page.