A company cheque bounces, the director who signed it is in Dubai or Toronto, and the payee is told nothing can be done. That is wrong. The company is liable, and so are the directors in India who were in charge of its business. The signatory abroad can also be prosecuted, but the value of doing so depends on what you want to achieve: a conviction you cannot execute, or money you can actually recover.
The offence does not need the signatory in the dock
Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, speaks of a cheque drawn by a person on an account maintained by him. Where the drawer is a company, the person who signs is an authorised signatory, and Section 141 extends liability to the company and to every person in charge of and responsible for the conduct of its business at the time of the offence.
That structure matters here. The complaint can proceed against the company and the directors who are in India even if the signatory is not, because the offence by the company is established independently, and the liability of those in charge does not depend on the signatory being tried first. The signature and the authority can be proved through the bank's records and the company's board resolution.
Where the signatory himself is to be prosecuted, he is a person who drew the cheque and is liable under Section 138 directly. The court may proceed against him separately. That is a strategic choice, not a legal necessity.
Service of notice on a person abroad
The statutory notice must be sent within thirty days of the return memo, to the drawer. Where the drawer is a company, notice goes to the company at its registered office and to the persons to be prosecuted at their addresses. For a person abroad, the notice is served by registered post with acknowledgement due, international courier, and email, and the address must be the one shown in the company's filings or the correspondence.
The proviso to Section 138 treats the notice as served when it is sent to the correct address by registered post, and a refusal or non-acknowledgement does not defeat the complaint, provided the despatch is proved. Courts have applied this to addresses outside India, with the additional care that the posting be documented and the tracking record preserved.
Where the signatory's address is genuinely unknown, the complainant should say so and serve the company, because a complaint that fails on service of notice fails entirely. That is the single most common reason a Section 138 complaint against a company is dismissed, and it is worth avoiding by keeping the postal record in a separate file.
Process against a person who will not appear
Once the magistrate takes cognisance and issues summons, the summons must be served at the address abroad. Where the accused does not appear despite service, the court may issue a warrant, and thereafter declare him a proclaimed offender and order attachment of his property in India. The property of a person who owns a flat in Kolkata or a share in a family business is reachable even if he does not travel here.
The case against the other accused does not stall. Courts separate the trial of an accused who is absconding from the trial of those who appear, so that the company and the resident directors can be tried and, if convicted, ordered to pay compensation. A complainant who waits for the absent director is waiting for a date that may never come.
What the court cannot do is secure an easy extradition. Offences under Section 138 are summons cases tried summarily, and a request for extradition for such an offence is not a realistic route. The practical substitutes are the Look Out Circular, which the court can recommend so that the accused is detained on arrival, and the attachment of Indian assets.
Where the civil suit is stronger
For a claimant whose real object is recovery, the civil suit is usually the better instrument against an absent director. A money decree can be executed against property in India, and the defendant's absence does not prevent the suit from proceeding once service is effected in the manner the court directs, which may include substituted service by publication.
Execution against a person abroad is harder than execution against his assets here. A decree can be transferred for enforcement in a reciprocating territory, but the list of reciprocating territories is limited and the procedure is slow. The realistic target is the property, the bank account and the shareholding in India.
A decree also binds the company if it was a party, and a company with assets in Kolkata can be wound up or subjected to insolvency proceedings on an unpaid decree, though that is a heavy step and rarely the first choice.
The documents that decide the file
- The cheque, the return memo and the bank's statement showing the account and the shortfall.
- The board resolution authorising the signatory, and the company's master data from the Ministry of Corporate Affairs showing who the directors were on the date of the dishonour.
- The invoice, ledger or agreement that establishes the debt.
- The demand notice, the postal receipts, the tracking record and the email delivery evidence.
- Any acknowledgement by the company of the liability, especially an email from the signatory after the return.
The email trail often proves decisive. A signatory abroad who writes to say the payment will be made next month has acknowledged the debt, and that email, printed and proved, does more than a dozen assertions in the complaint.
Running the case from Kolkata
The complaint is filed where the payee's bank branch is situated, which for a Kolkata payee usually means the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall, or the appropriate magistrate in the district. The civil suit goes to the City Civil Court at Kolkata or to the Calcutta High Court's original side depending on value. The two can run together, with the amount received in one adjusted against the other.
The practical sequence for most payees is: notice to the company and every director including the one abroad, a Section 138 complaint against the company and the resident officers, and a recovery suit for the debt. The absent director is named in both and dealt with by attachment rather than by arrest. Our cheque bounce team and the recovery notice practice handle this sequence, and recovery suits take over where the criminal route cannot produce the money.
Common questions
Can the case be filed if the signatory never set foot in India?
The offence is committed where the cheque is presented and returned, so a Kolkata court has jurisdiction where the payee's bank branch is in Kolkata. The accused's residence abroad does not defeat jurisdiction, though it complicates service and enforcement.
Will the trial be stayed until the signatory appears?
It should not be. The court can split the case and try the company and the resident accused, leaving the absent accused's file separate. If a court adjourns indefinitely for an accused abroad, that is a matter to be raised.
Can the company be prosecuted if the signatory's authority is disputed?
Yes. The authority is proved from the board resolution, the bank's mandate card and the course of dealing. The company cannot escape by denying the signature of its own officer where it has held him out as authorised.
Is a Look Out Circular available in a cheque case?
It can be recommended by the court in appropriate cases, particularly where the accused has left and shown no intention of returning. It is not granted as a matter of course in a summons case.
The absent director is a problem of enforcement, not of liability. Fix the liability first and pursue the assets. If your file has a company cheque and a signatory overseas, contact the office; the fees for consultation and for a court appearance are published.