Where the document that decides the suit is in the other side's possession, the Code of Civil Procedure gives two routes to get it: an application for discovery and production, and a summons to a third party to produce. Both are steps that must be taken early, because a party that waits until the trial has begun will be told that the stage for the application has passed.
The power, and where it sits in the Code
Order XI of the Code deals with discovery and inspection. It allows a party to apply for an order requiring the other party to make discovery of the documents in his possession or power which relate to the matters in question in the suit. There is also the power to deliver interrogatories, and the power to inspect documents that are referred to in the pleadings or the affidavits.
The court's power to order discovery is supplemented by its inherent jurisdiction to do what is necessary for a fair trial. Alongside Order XI sits Order XII, which deals with admissions, and Order XVI, which deals with the summoning of witnesses and the production of documents by a person who is not a party.
How the application is framed
A discovery application is not a fishing expedition, and it should not read like one. It has to describe the documents, or the classes of document, with enough precision that the other side knows what to produce, and it has to say why each is relevant to a matter in issue.
- Describe the document. "The ledger for the financial year in respect of the account between the parties" is good. "All documents relating to the transaction" is not.
- Tie it to a pleading. Each document should be connected to an issue raised or denied in the plaint or the written statement.
- State why you believe it exists and where it is. An application that shows the deponent saw the document, or that the other side referred to it in correspondence, is granted.
- Be specific about custody. A document with a bank or a statutory authority is not in the party's possession, and the application should be directed at the right holder.
The usual order requires the other party to file an affidavit of documents, listing what he has and what he claims to be privileged, and then to produce the listed documents for inspection. Where he does not comply, the Code permits the court to strike out his defence or dismiss his suit, which is a remedy that concentrates the mind. The form of that affidavit is on our affidavit drafting page.
What can be resisted
Three objections are regularly raised. The first is privilege, in particular legal professional privilege over communications between a party and his advocate for the purpose of the litigation. The second is that the document is irrelevant because the issue it is said to address is not in dispute. The third is that the request is a roving inquiry and that its real purpose is to discover the case rather than to prove it.
The court examines the documents where an objection is taken, and it can look at the document itself to decide the claim of privilege. The court does not lightly allow a party to keep back a document that goes to the heart of the issue.
Documents held by third parties
Where the document is with a bank, a registrar, a company, or a government office, Order XVI allows the court to summon the person having custody to produce it. This is used most often for bank records, which no bank will release to a private party without a court order or the account holder's consent.
For public records, there is a shorter route. Certified copies of documents that are registered or recorded in a public office can be obtained by applying to that office, and the registering authority's certified copy of a sale deed, a mutation order or a court record is admissible without further proof. For government files that are not public documents, a right to information application can produce the file, though the department may invoke the exemptions. Where the record is a company's, the filings described under corporate compliance are the starting point.
Where the third party is outside the court's jurisdiction, the court can issue a commission for the examination of the witness or the production of the document, and the commission is executed by the court where the witness resides.
Electronic records
Emails, WhatsApp messages, call records and server logs are documents for the purposes of the Code, and they can be sought in the same way. The practical difficulty is proof rather than discovery. An electronic record needs a certificate in the form the law requires for its admissibility, and the party producing a printout or a download should have the certificate ready. Where the record is held by a service provider, the court order must be directed at the provider, and the provider will ask for a specific and limited description of what is sought.
Call detail records are held by the telecom operator and are released only on an order of a court, with the period and the number specified. Preservation is the problem: operators retain data for limited periods, so an application that takes a year to be heard may produce nothing at the end of it.
Inspection and the consequence of non-disclosure
Once the affidavit of documents is filed, the other side is entitled to inspect the documents it discloses, and to take copies on payment. A party who fails to disclose a document cannot put it in evidence later without the court's leave, which is the sanction that makes the obligation real.
In a commercial suit the obligation is broader than in an ordinary suit, because the amended provisions require a list of all documents in the party's power, possession, control or custody that relate to the suit, filed at the outset and updated. A document that appears for the first time at the evidence stage in a commercial suit invites an application to exclude it and, in a strong case, a costs order.
Where these applications are heard
An application in a suit before the City Civil Court at Kolkata is heard by that court, and an application in a suit on the original side of the Calcutta High Court is heard by the judge in whose list the suit is pending. Discovery applications are interlocutory and are usually disposed of without a long hearing, on affidavits and a short argument.
Our page on civil litigation sets out the sequence of interlocutory applications in a contested suit and the stage at which each should be filed.
Common questions
Can discovery be sought before the suit is filed?
There is a limited right to apply for discovery to preserve evidence before a suit, in the circumstances the Code recognises. In practice, the application is made after the plaint and the written statement, when the issues are clear.
Does the other side have to produce its accounts?
Where the accounts are relevant to an issue, yes, and the court can order production of the relevant extracts. A demand for the entire books of account over many years is usually cut down to the relevant period and the relevant accounts.
What if the other side says the document has been lost?
The affidavit of documents must deal with the document specifically, and the court can require an explanation and test its truth. A conveniently lost document that was referred to in correspondence is treated as strong evidence against the party who lost it.
Is an interrogatory still used in practice?
Rarely. Interrogatories are used where a single fact can be pinned down, and the risk is that the answers become a substitute for evidence, which the court does not permit. A notice to admit facts under Order XII is often the more effective device.
Discovery is a step that a well-prepared litigant uses in the first six months and a poorly prepared one remembers at the evidence stage. Deciding, before the plaint is drafted, which documents are held by the other side and which by a third party will decide how the suit is proved, and how quickly.