14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Distribution of an estate: the shares under the Act

Where a Hindu dies without a will, the distribution of the estate among heirs follows the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, and the shares are worked out from the family tree and the class into which each claimant falls. distribution estate hindu succession questions are arithmetic, not discretion: the statute fixes who takes, and in what proportion, and the court does not adjust the shares because one heir is richer or one was closer to the deceased.

Two different rules run side by side. Coparcenary property devolves under section 6, with the survivors taking their interests by survivorship and the deceased's interest devolving on his heirs. The deceased's separate property devolves under sections 8 to 10, in the order of heirs the statute lays down.

The order of succession

Section 8 provides that the property of a male Hindu dying intestate devolves, first, on the heirs specified in Class I of the Schedule; second, if there is no Class I heir, on the heirs in Class II; third, if there is neither, on the agnates of the deceased; and fourth, if there is no agnate, on the cognates.

Class I includes the son, the daughter, the widow, the mother, the son of a predeceased son, the daughter of a predeceased son, the son of a predeceased daughter, the daughter of a predeceased daughter, the widow of a predeceased son, and the children of a predeceased son's predeceased son. Class II includes the father, the brother, the sister and the more distant relatives.

The mother is a Class I heir, and that is a change from the older law that surprises families. The father is in Class II, which means that where the deceased leaves a Class I heir, the father takes nothing under the statute.

The rules of distribution in section 10

Section 10 sets out how the Class I heirs share. First, the intestate's widow, or if there is more than one widow, all the widows together take one share. Second, the surviving sons and daughters, and the mother, take one share each. Third, the heirs in the branch of each predeceased son or predeceased daughter take between them one share, and that share is divided among them as they would have taken if the predeceased parent had died immediately after the intestate.

A worked example makes this concrete. A father dies leaving his widow, two sons and one daughter. The widow takes one share, each son takes one share, and the daughter takes one share, so there are four shares and each is a quarter. If one of the sons had died before the father, leaving two children, those two children take between them the one share their father would have taken, that is one half each of the quarter, or one eighth of the estate.

Where the estate includes a dwelling house, the heirs take it as tenants in common in their shares, and no one heir can claim exclusive possession. A partition suit, or a family settlement, is the way to convert the shares into defined portions.

Coparcenary property, and where section 6 applies

Where the deceased was a coparcener in a Hindu undivided family, his interest in the coparcenary property devolved, before the 2005 amendment, on the surviving coparceners by survivorship, with a limited right for certain heirs to claim a share. Since the amendment, section 6 provides that on the death of a coparcener, his interest devolves by testamentary or intestate succession, and not by survivorship, and the heirs who take are the Class I heirs.

For a family that still holds undivided coparcenary property, the practical result is that the deceased's share must be worked out as if a partition had taken place immediately before his death, and that share is then distributed among his heirs. The calculation requires the family tree, the dates of deaths, and the deeds by which the property was acquired.

The female heirs, and the changes

Daughters have been Class I heirs since 1956 and coparceners since 2005, and in a distribution among Class I heirs a daughter takes the same share as a son. The widow's share is a share equal to a child's, not a third or a half by customary rule.

Section 14 converts a Hindu female's limited estate into an absolute estate, so property held by a widow as a limited owner becomes hers absolutely, and on her death it devolves on her own heirs. A widow who inherited from her husband before 1956 and who held a limited estate is therefore in a different position from a widow inheriting after it.

The documents, and the revenue record

The death certificate, the legal heir certificate or the pedigree, the deeds by which the deceased acquired the property, the record of rights, and the municipal assessment. In West Bengal the legal heir certificate is issued by the local authority, and the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer records the heirs in the khatian on the strength of it and the pedigree.

Where the estate includes movable property — bank balances, shares, mutual funds — the bank or the depository may require a succession certificate, which is granted by the civil court under the Indian Succession Act. A succession certificate does not decide title to immovable property; it authorises the collection of the debts and securities.

What goes wrong

The first failure is a distribution agreed in the family that ignores a Class I heir, usually a daughter or the mother. The agreement binds only those who signed, and the omitted heir's share survives.

The second is a distribution that treats the widow's share as a life interest. It is an absolute share, and it belongs to her estate on her death.

The third is a mutation that records the sons alone, on the family's understanding that the daughters have given up their shares. A relinquishment has to be in writing, and preferably registered, to be effective.

How are the shares calculated?

By listing the Class I heirs, giving the widow or widows collectively one share, each surviving son, daughter and the mother one share each, and the branch of each predeceased child one share divided among that branch. The arithmetic follows the family tree and the dates of death.

Does the widow get a share equal to a son's?

Yes, in a distribution among Class I heirs. She takes one share, the same as each surviving child, and her share is absolute.

What about a predeceased son's children?

They take their father's share between them, by representation, and divide it equally among themselves. A predeceased daughter's children take their mother's share in the same way.

Is a succession certificate needed?

It is needed for collecting debts and securities from banks and companies where the amount is above the threshold the institution applies, and for shares held in dematerialised form. It is not needed for immovable property, which devolves by the statute and is recorded by mutation.

The distribution is a computation, and the computation starts with a family tree and the dates. Our family law practice prepares the pedigree and the succession papers, and registration handles the mutation of each heir's share. Partition of the resulting shares is dealt with by the partition practice. Begin at our contact page.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422