14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Easement rights over a neighbouring plot

Easement rights neighbour disputes turn on one of two foundations: a grant, or twenty years of enjoyment. The Indian Easements Act, 1882 defines an easement as a right which the owner of one property has, for its beneficial enjoyment, over another property not his own. A right of way across a neighbour's passage, a right to drain water through his land, a right to light and air through his windows, a right of support from his wall: each can exist as an easement, and each can be lost by obstruction, by abandonment, or by the neighbour's successful denial of the right for the statutory period.

Easements of necessity and the implied grant

Section 13 of the Act deals with easements of necessity and with what are called quasi-easements. Where a property is divided and one part becomes landlocked, or where a drain or a passage was used for the common enjoyment of the whole before the division, the purchaser of the part gets an easement over the other part by implication. The right arises from the severance, not from a written grant, and it is the reason a plot carved out of a larger holding can still reach the road.

An easement of necessity is limited to what is necessary. If the owner later acquires alternative access, the necessity may end, although a right already acquired by grant or by prescription survives. The court examines the layout at the time of the division, the plans, and the use that the common owner made of the passage or the drain.

Prescription: twenty years, as of right

Section 15 allows an easement to be acquired by prescription where the right has been peaceably enjoyed, without interruption, for twenty years, and the enjoyment has been as of right and without agreement. Each word matters:

  • Peaceably means without force or dispute. A right exercised over a neighbour's protest is not peaceable.
  • Without interruption means continuous enjoyment, not occasional use. A right of way used daily for twenty years qualifies; one used twice a year may not.
  • As of right means the user acted as though he had a right, not as a favour. A passage used with the neighbour's permission, or under an agreement, does not become a prescriptive right.
  • Without agreement excludes enjoyment under a lease or licence that defines the terms.

The twenty years are counted back from the date of the suit, and the plaintiff must plead the period with particulars: when the use began, how it was exercised, and the persons through whom it continued.

The rights that are usually claimed in Kolkata

A right of way over a common passage is the commonest, particularly in older Kolkata blocks where several houses share an access lane from the main road. A right to light and air is claimed where a neighbour's new construction blocks the windows of an old house; the right exists only if it has been enjoyed for twenty years without interruption, and the Municipal building rules and the sanctioned plan are separate defences that the neighbour may raise.

A right to drainage and to the discharge of water is claimed where a neighbour blocks a channel, and a right of support is claimed where excavation weakens a boundary wall or a foundation. In each case the court looks at the physical layout, the old plans, the municipal records and the testimony of long-standing residents.

Twenty years of use is not enough if the use was a favour. The neighbour's permission, written or spoken, defeats the prescription, which is why a letter asking for permission is the cheapest way to protect a boundary.

Remedies and defences

A suit for declaration of the easement and for a permanent injunction restraining obstruction is filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata or the district court, according to the value. An interim injunction is sought where the obstruction is in progress, and the court will weigh the plaintiff's long enjoyment against the neighbour's right to build on his own land.

The neighbour's defences are that the use was permissive, that the right was abandoned by non-use for twenty years, that the obstruction is on his own property and does not substantially interfere, and that the plaintiff has an alternative route. An easement is extinguished by release, by abandonment, and by non-enjoyment for the statutory period, and each of those has to be proved by the person asserting it.

The court can also award damages for the obstruction during the period it continued, and where the obstruction is a construction that has already been completed, the decree may require its removal or the payment of compensation in lieu.

Evidence that decides the case

The strongest evidence is documentary and old: the sale deeds that describe the passage as common, the site plans that show the access, the municipal records that show the drain, and the photographs with dates. Old utility bills, the location of meters, and the assessment records help to show the layout as it existed.

Oral evidence from the residents who have used the passage for decades is admissible and often decisive, but it is stronger when it is supported by the documents. A statutory declaration from a long-standing neighbour, signed and notarised, is worth obtaining before the dispute becomes hostile.

Common questions

Can I claim a right of way if the neighbour has always allowed it?

Only if the use was as of right, not as a licence. If the neighbour gave permission, and the permission can be shown, the right does not ripen into an easement. Where the use began without any permission and continued openly for twenty years, the right can be claimed.

Does the right survive if the property is sold?

Yes. An easement runs with the land, and a purchaser of the dominant property acquires the benefit of the easement that was annexed to it. A purchaser of the servient property takes it subject to the easement, which is why a buyer of land should ask about the passages and the drains.

What if the neighbour's building blocks my light and air?

You can sue for an injunction if the right has been acquired by twenty years of enjoyment, and you can also challenge the construction under the municipal building rules and the sanctioned plan. The two remedies are different, and the municipal challenge may be quicker than the civil suit.

Can the easement be lost by not using it?

Yes, by non-enjoyment for twenty years, and by abandonment. An easement of necessity is treated differently and may revive if the necessity returns. The burden of proving abandonment lies on the person who asserts it.

Record the use before the dispute starts: photographs, old plans, the deeds that describe the passage, and a declaration from the neighbours who remember. Our title and easement practice files the declaration and injunction suits in the City Civil Court and the district courts, and the property team reads the deeds and the plans before the plaint is drafted. Where the obstruction is a municipal issue, the civil litigation team coordinates the two proceedings.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422