In a cheque case the complainant's evidence is given on affidavit, and the accused has a right to summon him for cross-examination. Those two rules sit together, and a trial that ignores the second is a trial that will be sent back. What both sides need to know is when the application for cross-examination should be made and what the affidavit must contain to survive it.
The statutory scheme
Section 145 of the Negotiable Instruments Act allows the evidence of the complainant to be given on affidavit, and provides that it may be read in any enquiry, trial or proceeding. The same section, in its second sub-section, preserves the right of the accused to apply to the court to summon and examine any person whose evidence has been given on affidavit.
Section 143 provides for a summary trial of cheque offences, and the magistrate may try them summarily. Together the two sections produce a procedure that is documentary in form: the complainant files an affidavit with exhibits, the accused pleads, and the case moves to the question of cross-examination and defence evidence. Kolkata magistrates deal with these cases in high volume, and the affidavit is what makes that volume manageable.
What the affidavit must contain
An affidavit that says only "the cheque was dishonoured and the accused did not pay" will not carry the burden. It has to set out the transaction, because the presumption under Section 139 arises only when the cheque is shown to have been drawn for a debt or liability. The affidavit should therefore state who the parties are, what the transaction was, when the amount became due, how the cheque came to be issued, and what the cheque was for.
Then the statutory sequence: the date of presentation, the bank's return memo with its reason, the notice with its date and mode of despatch, proof of service, and the failure to pay within fifteen days. Each of those facts must be supported by an exhibit, and the affidavit should identify the exhibit by its mark.
- The original cheque, or a certified copy where the original is with the bank.
- The bank's return memo or the bank's letter.
- A copy of the statutory notice, the postal receipt and the acknowledgement.
- The complainant's bank statement or books showing that the amount was not received.
- Where the complainant is a company, the board resolution or authority letter for the person deponing.
The affidavit must be confined to facts the deponent knows or can verify from the records, and it should say which is which. An affidavit that asserts everything as personal knowledge, in a case where the deponent joined the company last year, gives the cross-examiner an easy opening. The general form of an affidavit is set out on our notice and affidavit page.
The application for cross-examination
The accused's right is exercised by an application asking the court to summon the deponent. It is usually filed after the plea is recorded and before the case is posted for defence evidence, and the court will ordinarily allow it, because the right to test the complainant's evidence is part of a fair trial.
What the court controls is the scope and length. Magistrates in Kolkata fix a date and sometimes a time limit, and counsel are expected to come prepared with the documents. A request for adjournment on the day of cross-examination, without a grounded application, is treated unsympathetically.
The purposes of cross-examination in these cases are narrow and practical. To establish that the cheque was not issued for a debt but as security or by way of a loan of the cheque itself. To show that the signature is not the drawer's. To show that the amount was paid in cash later. To show that the notice was never received. To show that the complainant's books do not reflect the transaction.
What happens if the complainant does not appear
Where the complainant is summoned and does not appear, the court may close the complainant's evidence or take other steps, and the case can be dismissed. That is a serious outcome for a payee who has already spent on fees and notice. The affidavit is not a substitute for presence when the court has ordered it.
The converse is also worth noting. Where an accused applies repeatedly for cross-examination and then does not attend, the court may refuse a further opportunity, and the case proceeds on the affidavit. Delay is a weapon that both sides use, and courts have become stricter about it.
The accused's evidence
After the complainant's evidence closes, the accused is examined under Section 313 of the Code on the circumstances appearing against him, and may lead defence evidence. In cheque cases defence evidence is usually short: the accused's own statement about the transaction, a receipt for repayment, a bank statement, or a witness to the arrangement.
The burden at this stage matters. Section 139 raises a presumption that the cheque was issued for a debt, and Section 118 raises presumptions about consideration. The accused does not have to prove his defence beyond reasonable doubt, but he has to raise a probable case, and the evidence has to be more than a bare denial in the statement under Section 313.
The problems that show up in appeal
Two grounds recur in revisions before the Calcutta High Court. The first is that the magistrate refused cross-examination altogether, or refused it after the accused had made a timely application. That is treated as a denial of an opportunity and often results in the matter going back. The second is that the affidavit was read without the exhibits being formally proved, so the conviction rests on documents that were never marked.
The cure for both is procedural care at the trial. Exhibits should be marked when the affidavit is taken on record. Applications under Section 145(2) should be made in writing and the order noted. Where the court declines, a request for a reasoned order should be made on the same day.
Company complaints add a third ground: the person who swore the affidavit had no authority, or deposed to matters outside his knowledge. A board resolution annexed to the affidavit ends that argument. Our page on cheque bounce covers the authority question in company cases.
Where this happens in Kolkata
Cheque complaints are tried by the magistrate having jurisdiction over the place where the payee's bank branch is situated. For a payee banking in the central business district, that is the court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall, and the complaint is heard by the metropolitan magistrate assigned to it. Complaints from the suburbs go to the appropriate court in the district. The trial is summary, the record is thin, and the affidavit does most of the work. The offence itself and the statutory sequence are explained under criminal law.
Common questions
Can the accused insist on cross-examining the complainant?
The accused can apply, and the court will usually allow it. The right is not automatic in the sense that the accused can demand it as a matter of course without an application, but a refusal without reason is vulnerable. In practice the application is granted and a date is fixed.
Is a notarised affidavit enough, or does it need to be sworn before a magistrate?
An affidavit sworn before a notary or an oath commissioner is the usual form, and the court accepts it. What matters is that it is properly sworn, signed on each page and accompanied by the exhibits.
What if the complainant lives abroad?
The affidavit can be sworn abroad and accepted, and the court may permit cross-examination by video conference on an application. Where the complainant does not appear and the court insists on physical presence, the complaint can be pursued through an authorised representative who can depose to the records.
Does the accused have to file an affidavit in reply?
No. The accused's defence comes through the statement under Section 313 and through defence evidence, if any. A written reply to the notice is useful as an exhibit but it is not evidence unless proved.
The affidavit is not a shortcut around proof; it is proof in a compressed form. A complainant who exhibits every link in the chain, and an accused who prepares his cross-examination from those exhibits, both get a decision that survives an appeal. A complainant who files two pages of assertion and hopes the presumption will do the rest usually gets an order to file a better affidavit, and the delay that follows is his own.