A decree passed against a defendant who did not appear is an ex parte decree, and the defendant's first remedy is an application under Order 9 Rule 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, to have it set aside. The application must be made within thirty days of the decree, or, where the summons was never duly served, within thirty days of the defendant's knowledge of the decree. If the defendant learns of the decree only when execution reaches his bank account, the knowledge rule is what saves him.
The two grounds
Order 9 Rule 13 allows the court to set aside the decree if it is satisfied that the summons was not duly served, or that the defendant was prevented by sufficient cause from appearing when the suit was called on for hearing. The first ground is almost mandatory: if the defendant establishes that the summons was never served, the court should set aside the decree and hear the suit.
The second ground is discretionary. Sufficient cause means a reason that a reasonable person would accept, supported by evidence. Hospitalisation with records, absence from the country, a wrong address on the record, a change of residence, a vakalatnama filed but no appearance, or the death of the advocate without the defendant's knowledge have all been accepted in appropriate cases. A defendant who simply did not bother to appear, or who assumed the matter would settle, has no sufficient cause.
The court does not ordinarily require the defendant to show a good defence on the merits before setting aside an ex parte decree. It looks at whether the explanation is genuine. Where the explanation is weak and the defence is also weak, however, the court is entitled to weigh both, and a defendant who applies only to delay will not necessarily succeed.
Limitation and the knowledge question
The thirty-day period runs from the date of the decree where the defendant had notice of the suit but did not appear. Where the summons was not duly served, the period runs from the date the defendant came to know of the decree. The distinction is important, because a defendant who has been ex parte for years can still apply within thirty days of discovering the decree, and the case law on the point is settled.
Where the application is filed beyond thirty days, an application for condonation of delay accompanies it, under the Limitation Act. The explanation must cover the whole period of delay, and a statement that the applicant was unaware of the case is not the same as a statement that he was unaware of the decree.
The procedure
- Obtain a certified copy of the decree and the judgement, and inspect the record to see what the process server reported about service.
- Draft the application stating the ground, the facts, the date of knowledge and the defence in outline.
- Support it with an affidavit, and with documents: the medical records, the passport, the rent receipts, the postal record, the death certificate of the advocate if that is the point.
- File before the court that passed the decree, with the prescribed court fee and the process fee for serving the opposite party.
- Move for stay of execution, or for an order that execution not proceed until the application is decided. Without a stay, the decree-holder can proceed to attach and sell while the application is pending.
- Attend the hearing and be ready to examine the defendant and, if necessary, the process server.
The court can set aside the decree on terms, and it usually imposes costs. Condition precedents, such as a deposit of the decretal amount, are imposed only where the facts warrant them; an unconditional deposit is not the ordinary price of setting aside an ex parte decree, though in a money case the court may require security.
The other routes
An ex parte decree can also be challenged by appeal, where a ground of appeal exists. It can be challenged in revision in an appropriate case. It can be challenged by a separate suit on the ground that it was obtained by fraud or collusion, because a decree obtained by fraud is a nullity in the eyes of the law and a suit to set it aside is not barred by the rule against re-litigation.
Section 151 of the Code, which preserves the court's inherent power to make orders necessary for the ends of justice, is a residual route where Order 9 Rule 13 is unavailable for a technical reason, such as the decree being one under a different provision. It is used sparingly, and it is not a substitute for the specific remedy.
The order disposing of an Order 9 Rule 13 application is itself appealable in some circumstances, and an order refusing to set aside the decree is appealable as an order. A defendant who loses the application should consider whether the refusal is appealable rather than filing the same application again.
What defendants get wrong
The first mistake is to file the application without seeking a stay of execution. By the time the application is heard, the bank account has been attached or the property has been put to sale, and setting aside the decree does not automatically undo the sale.
The second is to attack the decree rather than explain the absence. An Order 9 Rule 13 application is about why the defendant was not there, not about why the judgement is wrong. The defence on the merits is dealt with after the decree is set aside, in the written statement.
The third is the address. Many ex parte decrees rest on service at an old address, or service on a person who was not a member of the household. The application should put the process server's report and the postal record on the record, and if necessary examine the process server, because a defendant who establishes defective service wins regardless of the merits.
Kolkata practice
An application to set aside a decree of the City Civil Court at Kolkata is filed in that court. For a decree on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, the application is filed in the same jurisdiction and follows the original side rules. For a district court decree, the application goes to the district court at Alipore or Barasat, as the case may be. An appeal from the order lies to the Calcutta High Court or as the statute provides.
The papers to collect are the same in every forum: the certified copy of the judgement and decree, the process server's report, the proof of the defendant's whereabouts, and the evidence of the reason for the absence. A defendant who assembles those before the hearing usually succeeds; one who relies on an affidavit alone often does not. Our civil litigation practice handles setting aside applications along with the defence, and the recovery notice practice is relevant where the matter can still be settled.
Common questions
Is there a time limit to set aside an ex parte decree?
Yes, thirty days, from the decree or from the date of knowledge where the summons was not duly served. Delay can be condoned on sufficient cause, but the application should be filed within the period if possible.
Do I have to deposit the decretal amount?
Usually not. The court may impose terms, and it looks at the facts. A deposit is more likely where the decree is for money and the defendant's conduct suggests a risk of non-payment.
Can I appeal instead of applying under Order 9 Rule 13?
Yes, and the remedies are alternative. An appeal on the ground that the court should have adjourned or that service was bad is available. Many defendants apply first because it is quicker and cheaper.
What if the decree was obtained by fraud?
A separate suit to set it aside lies, because fraud vitiates a decree. The suit must plead the fraud specifically, with particulars, and it is not defeated merely because an Order 9 Rule 13 application was not filed.
Act on the knowledge of the decree, not on the assumption that it will go away. If you have received notice of an execution or learnt of an ex parte decree, contact the office; the consultation fee is published.