Winning the suit is half the work. Execution is the stage at which the decree is turned into money or possession, and it has its own procedure, its own limitation and its own set of defences. A decree that is not executed within twelve years is dead, and one that is executed carelessly recovers nothing.
Where the execution application is filed
An execution application is filed before the court that passed the decree, or before the court to which it is transferred. Where the judgement-debtor resides or holds property outside the jurisdiction of the court that passed the decree, the decree can be transferred for execution to the court having jurisdiction over that person or property, and the transferee court executes it as if it had passed it.
In Kolkata, a decree of the City Civil Court is executed by that court. A decree of the original side of the Calcutta High Court is executed on the original side, and the Sheriff of Kolkata executes the Court's warrants for the attachment and sale of movable property. A decree of a district court at Barasat or Alipore is executed by that court or transferred to the court where the assets are.
The modes of execution
The Code lists the ways in which a decree may be executed, and the decree-holder chooses according to the assets available.
- Delivery of possession, where the decree is for immovable property, with police assistance if it is resisted.
- Attachment and sale of movable property, through the court's officer or, on the original side, the Sheriff.
- Attachment and sale of immovable property, with a prohibition on transfer and a proclamation of sale.
- Attachment of money in the hands of a third party, including a bank balance or a sum owed to the judgement-debtor by a customer.
- Attachment of salary, in the case of a person employed, subject to the protection the Code gives to a part of the salary.
- Arrest and detention, in the circumstances the Code specifies, where the judgement-debtor has the means but refuses to pay.
- Appointment of a receiver, where the property needs to be managed or collected.
The first step in most money decrees is an application for the oral examination of the judgement-debtor as to his property, which the Code allows. The judgement-debtor can be required to state his assets on affidavit, and a false statement exposes him to consequences. That examination, followed by attachment, is the standard sequence.
Attachment of immovable property and the sale
Attachment of immovable property is effected by a prohibitory order served on the judgement-debtor and published at the office of the registering authority and, in the case of a village property, in the manner the Code prescribes. Once attached, the property cannot be transferred, and a sale without the court's leave is liable to be set aside.
The sale follows a proclamation that states the property, its estimated value, the amount to be recovered and the terms of the sale. The proclamation must be published in the manner the Code requires, and a sale conducted without the prescribed proclamation is open to challenge. The property is sold by public auction, and the purchaser deposits a quarter of the price at once, with the balance within the period the Code allows.
The judgement-debtor has two protections. He can apply to have the sale set aside on payment of the decretal amount and the costs, within the period the Code permits, and he can object to the sale on the ground of irregularity or fraud. Both applications must be made promptly, and delay defeats them.
What the judgement-debtor can keep
The Code exempts certain property from attachment, and the list is worth knowing on both sides. A dwelling house within the value the Code specifies is protected. Tools of a tradesman, the implements of an agriculturist, and the necessary wearing apparel are exempt. A portion of salary is protected, and the amount is calculated according to the Code. Pension is generally not attachable, though there are exceptions for the recovery of debts owed to the government.
These exemptions are not loopholes; they are the minimum a debtor needs to live and work. A decree-holder who overreaches and attaches exempt property will have the attachment lifted and will be liable for costs.
The twelve-year limit and its extension
An execution application must be made within twelve years of the date of the decree, under the Limitation Act. Within that period, the decree-holder must also take steps in aid of execution, and the law has developed the rule that an application for a step in aid keeps the execution alive, from the date of the application rather than from the earlier step. The result is that a diligent decree-holder can keep a decree alive almost indefinitely by taking one step every twelve years, while a sleeping one loses it.
Where the decree is a decree for maintenance or for periodic payments, each default has its own starting point, and the twelve years run from each instalment.
An application to execute a decree beyond twelve years requires an explanation under the Limitation Act, which in practice means showing that the earlier execution proceeding was pending or that a step in aid was pending. Courts examine these applications carefully.
Getting information about the debtor's assets
Execution succeeds or fails on information. The tools are the oral examination, the notice to the judgement-debtor to disclose assets on affidavit, and the power of the court to summon banks and registrars. A decree-holder can also search the registration records for property in the judgement-debtor's name, the records of the Registrar of Companies where the debtor is a company, and the cause lists of other courts, which often reveal that another creditor has already attached an asset.
Where the judgement-debtor is a company, the search at the Registrar of Companies shows the charges and the financial statements, and a company that has stopped filing is a signal that the money is not there. In that situation, the decree-holder should consider whether an insolvency application is commercially sensible, and our page on insolvency sets out the thresholds.
Attachment before judgment and other interim protection
Where the suit is still pending and the defendant is disposing of his assets, the Code allows attachment before judgment on an application showing that the defendant is about to remove or dispose of his property with intent to defeat the decree. The application needs specific evidence, not a general apprehension, and it is heard early and decided quickly. Our page on civil litigation deals with the interim applications that accompany a suit.
Common questions
Can a decree be executed against a person who was not a party?
Execution binds the parties and their legal representatives, and a person who claims under a party by a transfer made after the suit started may be bound in some circumstances. Execution against a stranger requires a separate suit or a specific provision, and the court will not extend the decree on its own.
Can salary be attached for the whole amount?
No. The Code protects a portion of the salary, and only the balance beyond the protected amount can be attached. The protection applies however large the decree.
What happens if the property is sold for less than the decretal amount?
The decree-holder can proceed against other assets of the judgement-debtor, because the decree is for the whole amount. A sale that realises only part leaves the balance recoverable, subject to the twelve-year limitation.
Can execution be transferred to another state?
Yes. Where the judgement-debtor or his property is outside West Bengal, the decree is transferred to the court of competent jurisdiction in that state for execution, with a certificate of transfer. Our page on recovery suits deals with the stage before execution, where the decree is obtained.
Execution is unglamorous and decisive. The decree-holder who examines the debtor on affidavit within weeks of the decree, attaches the right asset and keeps a step in aid alive will recover. The one who files the execution application and then waits for the court to find the money will wait for twelve years and lose the decree.