14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Filing a consumer complaint in Kolkata: the procedure

A consumer complaint in Kolkata is filed before the District Commission for the district where the opposite party's office is situated, or before the West Bengal State Commission where the value crosses the district limit. The procedure runs from admission to notice to a written version to evidence, and each stage has a deadline that a complainant ignores at his cost.

Which commission, and why it matters

The Consumer Protection Act, 2019 fixes pecuniary jurisdiction by the value of the consideration paid. Up to fifty lakh rupees, the District Commission; between fifty lakh and two crore rupees, the State Commission; above two crore, the National Commission. For a Kolkata purchase, this means that a dispute over a washing machine and a dispute over a flat usually go to different commissions.

Territorial jurisdiction lies where the opposite party actually and voluntarily resides or carries on business, where the cause of action arose, or where the complainant resides, in a case where the opposite party has a branch there. For a seller with an office in Kolkata, the complaint is filed in Kolkata. For a dealer in Salt Lake or New Town, the district may be North 24 Parganas, and the complaint then goes to the commission at Barasat rather than the one in the city. A written demand before the complaint is often the quicker remedy, and our legal notice drafting page sets out the form. For those areas see our New Town page.

Filing in the wrong commission is the most common jurisdictional error, and it costs the complainant the filing fee and several months. The question should be settled before drafting.

The complaint and the affidavit

The complaint sets out the parties, the facts in numbered paragraphs, the deficiency in service or the defect in goods or the unfair trade practice, the relief claimed, and the value. It must be accompanied by an affidavit sworn by the complainant verifying the facts, and by an index of documents.

What the commission looks for at admission is simple. Does the complaint disclose a consumer relationship? Is the opposite party identified with an address? Is there a cause of action within two years? Is the fee correct? A complaint that answers those four questions is admitted quickly.

The relief paragraph deserves care. The commission can order the replacement of goods, the removal of a defect, a refund, compensation for loss or injury, and costs. It can also order punitive damages where the trade practice is clearly unfair. Each relief should be claimed in a figure, and the figures should add up to the value stated for the fee. The remedies the commission can grant, and how they are claimed, are described under consumer protection.

Notice and the written version

After admission, notice goes to the opposite party, with a copy of the complaint and the documents. The opposite party files a written version within thirty days, and the commission may allow a further fifteen days on reasons recorded in writing. Beyond that, the version is not taken on record.

The written version is not a plaint; it is a reply, and it must deal with each allegation. Where the opposite party denies everything in general terms, the commission will treat the specific allegations as uncontroverted. Where it raises a preliminary objection on jurisdiction or limitation, that is decided first.

The complainant then files a rejoinder if the commission permits, and the case moves to evidence.

Evidence, and how it is given

Evidence in these cases is by affidavit, with documents annexed. The complainant files an affidavit of evidence and exhibits the documents relied on. The opposite party does the same. Cross-examination is permitted where a party applies for it, and the commission may examine a deponent on specified points rather than allowing a general cross-examination.

Expert evidence is used where the defect requires a technical assessment: an engineering report on a vehicle, a medical opinion in a negligence case, a valuation in an insurance dispute. The commission can also direct a laboratory test or appoint a commissioner, and it has powers of a civil court for summoning witnesses and requiring documents.

Hearings in Kolkata commissions are listed before a bench of a president and members. Adjournments are granted but the Act and the rules require the commission to dispose of complaints within a stated period, and commissions do take note of repeated adjournments by a party.

The order, and what it can contain

The commission decides on the basis of the pleadings and the evidence, and its order is reasoned. It can direct the opposite party to do a thing within a stated period, pay a sum, replace goods, or refund. It can award interest. It can order compensation for the complainant's loss and for mental agony, which commissions in West Bengal award as a conventional figure rather than a large one.

Where the opposite party does not comply, the complainant applies for execution. The commission can enforce its order as a decree of a civil court, and can attach property. The Act also provides a penalty for non-compliance with an order, which is a separate route for a promoter or a seller who simply ignores it.

Appeal and the deadlines

An appeal from a District Commission order lies to the State Commission, and from the State Commission to the National Commission. The appeal must be filed within forty-five days of the order, with a possible extension on sufficient cause. A deposit of the awarded amount is a condition in some cases, and the appellant should check the requirement before filing.

The first appeal is not a rehearing on new evidence; it is decided on the record. That is why the evidence stage matters so much, and why a complainant who did not file a document at that stage cannot usually produce it in appeal.

Mediation and settlement

The Act encourages settlement through mediation, and a commission may refer the parties at any stage with their consent. A mediated settlement recorded by the commission has the status of its order and is enforceable. For a dispute with a builder or a large retailer, mediation often produces a payment schedule that a contested order would not.

The advantage is speed and the absence of an appeal. The disadvantage is that a mediated figure is usually lower than what a contested order might have given. The complainant should have an assessment of the case before entering mediation, so that the settlement is a decision rather than a surrender.

Common questions

Can a complaint be filed against a company that has its head office outside Kolkata?

Yes, if it carries on business in Kolkata through a branch or an office, or if the cause of action arose here. The complaint should name the company with its registered office and describe the Kolkata branch where the transaction took place.

Does the complainant have to appear at every hearing?

The complainant or an authorised representative must appear. An advocate or a person holding authority can appear on the complainant's behalf. Absence at a hearing can lead to dismissal, and a dismissed complaint is restored only on an application with reasons.

What is the limitation for a consumer complaint?

Two years from the date the cause of action arose, which is usually the date of the defective service or the refusal to remedy it. Delay can be condoned on an application with reasons, but the application must be filed with the complaint.

Can a consumer complaint be withdrawn and filed again?

A complaint can be withdrawn, and a fresh complaint on the same cause of action is possible while limitation subsists. Withdrawal after evidence has begun is treated with more caution, and the commission may impose costs.

The procedure is not complicated, and that is why small errors are so expensive in it. A complainant who settles the forum, prepares the affidavit, quantifies the relief and files the documents on the first day will usually have an order within a year. The ones who linger in the list are those who filed a complaint that had to be amended three times.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422