A plaint is filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata where the suit's value falls within its jurisdiction, with the court fee computed ad valorem on the value of the claim under the West Bengal court-fees law. The plaint is presented at the filing counter, scrutinised by the office, and either registered and numbered or returned for defects. Most delays at the start of a suit are caused by defects in valuation, in the verification, or in the documents.
Which court: valuation decides
Two courts have original civil jurisdiction in Kolkata. The City Civil Court at Kolkata hears suits within the pecuniary limit fixed by statute, and the original side of the Calcutta High Court hears suits above that limit. The threshold has been revised from time to time, so the current figure should be confirmed before the plaint is drafted rather than taken from an old form.
Territorial jurisdiction is a separate question, governed by the Code's provisions on where a suit may be filed: the place where the defendant resides or carries on business, the place where the cause of action arose, and, in a suit about immovable property, the place where the property is situate. A suit about title to a Kolkata plot belongs in Kolkata whatever the defendant's address. A suit on a contract performed in Kolkata may be filed in Kolkata even if the defendant lives elsewhere.
Where the suit is against a company, the registered office is the place of business for jurisdiction, and where the defendant is the government, the rules require notice before the suit.
What the plaint contains
The Code prescribes the essentials. A well-drafted plaint has:
- A heading with the court, the parties, and the valuation.
- The description of the parties with their addresses, so that service is possible.
- A statement of the facts constituting the cause of action, in chronological order and with dates.
- A statement of the value of the subject matter for jurisdiction and for court fees.
- The relief claimed, set out in separate paragraphs, including interest and costs.
- The jurisdiction paragraph, stating why the court has jurisdiction.
- The verification, signed by the plaintiff or the person authorised, stating that the contents are true to the knowledge, information and belief of the signatory.
The plaint is signed by the party and by the advocate, and a plaint that is not properly signed or verified is returned. Where the plaintiff is a company, the plaint is signed by an authorised officer and the authority should be on the file.
Valuation and court fee
Valuation is done twice. First, for the purpose of jurisdiction, which decides the court. Second, for the purpose of the court fee, which decides the amount payable. On a money claim the value is the sum claimed. On a declaratory claim it is the value the plaintiff states, subject to the rules for the particular relief. On a suit for possession with mesne profits, the value is fixed on the basis the rules provide.
The court fee is ad valorem under the West Bengal court-fees statute, computed on the value of the relief. A declaratory relief, a possession suit and a suit for specific performance each have their own treatment, and an under-valuation is a defect the court can address at any stage.
The fee is paid by way of a court fee stamp or an electronic payment as the court directs. The receipt goes with the plaint, and a fresh valuation may be needed if the plaint is amended to increase the claim, with the additional fee paid at that time.
The documents to file
File the plaint with the fee and the annexures, which usually include:
- The documents relied on, original or certified, with a list of documents.
- The list of witnesses, where the court requires it at filing.
- The authority of the signatory where the plaintiff is a company or a trust.
- The power of attorney or the vakalatnama in favour of the advocate.
- The application for any interim relief, with the affidavit and the undertaking.
Documents not filed with the plaint are produced later with the leave of the court, and a party who sits on a document and produces it at the evidence stage invites an objection and, often, an order for costs.
The defects that cause a return
Scrutiny by the filing office is mechanical but thorough. The common defects:
- The valuation does not match the relief claimed, or the court fee is underpaid.
- The jurisdiction paragraph is missing or asserts jurisdiction without any basis.
- The verification is unsigned, or signed by a person who does not state his authority.
- The addresses of the defendants are incomplete, so service is not possible.
- The plaint contains argument, abuse, or allegations that are scandalous and liable to be struck out.
- The relief is claimed in a lump without separate paragraphs, so that the court cannot grant part.
A return is not fatal. The plaint is re-presented after correction, and the suit date is the date of re-presentation. Where the limitation period is about to expire, the plaint should be presented before it does, and the defects cured afterwards, because a plaint presented in time and returned for correction keeps its date if it is re-presented promptly.
The plaint decides what the suit is about. Every fact you may later want to prove must be pleaded, because evidence outside the pleadings is refused.
After filing
Once registered, the suit is numbered, notice is issued to the defendants, and the case is listed. The defendant files a written statement within the time allowed, and the pleadings close. Then the issues are framed, the documents are admitted and marked, and the evidence begins. Interim applications for an injunction, for attachment, or for a receiver are heard in the same suit and do not require a separate proceeding.
Reliefs not claimed in the plaint cannot be granted, and a claim for interest should be pleaded specifically — a court will not award interest that was never asked for.
Common questions
Can a plaint be amended after filing?
Yes, with the court's leave, and the amendment follows the rule that all amendments necessary for determining the real question should be allowed, subject to the law of limitation and to the avoidance of prejudice. An amendment that changes the nature of the suit is refused.
Is a suit needed where a legal notice has been ignored?
A notice is not a precondition for every suit, though particular statutes require one. Where a notice has been sent and ignored, the plaint should refer to it and to the reply or the absence of one, because the notice is often the beginning of the cause of action.
Can two plaintiffs file one plaint?
Yes, where they have a common cause of action or the reliefs arise from the same transaction. The Code also allows a suit by or against one person on behalf of many with the same interest, with the court's permission.
Get the valuation, the verification and the jurisdiction paragraph right before presenting. Our civil litigation practice files and conducts suits in the City Civil Court at Kolkata and on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and recovery suits covers the money claims. For a suit that turns on a title question, see property title disputes.