14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Gift deed to a family member: duty, tax and revocation

A gift of immovable property is complete when the donor signs a registered instrument and the donee accepts it. Once that has happened, the gift cannot be revoked at will; the Transfer of Property Act allows revocation only in three narrow situations, and a donor who has changed his mind is usually without a remedy. Stamp duty in West Bengal is charged at a concessional rate for gifts between close relatives, and the income-tax law generally does not tax a gift to a relative.

Those two concessions are why gift deeds are so common in family transactions, and why they are so often set aside later by a court that finds the transaction was not a gift at all but a device.

What makes a valid gift

Section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 defines a gift as the transfer of certain existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration, by one person to another, and accepted by the donee.

Section 123 requires that a gift of immovable property be effected by a registered instrument signed by the donor and attested by at least two witnesses. For movable property, the gift is complete on delivery, or on a registered instrument where the property is of a nature that cannot be delivered.

Three elements therefore have to be proved: the donor's intention to give, the acceptance by the donee, and the registration. Acceptance can be inferred from the donee's conduct, but where the gift is challenged, an express acceptance in the deed or a separate acknowledgement is better.

A gift by a Hindu of his undivided interest in joint family property is a different transaction, and it is not permitted without the consent of the other coparceners in the ordinary case. A gift of the whole of a coparcener's interest to a stranger is void; a gift of a small portion for pious purposes is permitted within limits.

Stamp duty on a gift to a relative

The schedule to the West Bengal Stamp Act provides a concessional rate for a gift made to a relative, and the definition of "relative" in the schedule is narrower than the family's own idea of who is related. Parents, spouse, children and siblings are within it in the ordinary case; cousins, nephews and in-laws may or may not be, depending on the terms of the schedule in force.

The rate and the definition are revised by notification, so the deed should be drafted after checking the current schedule at the office. A deed that assumes a concession and does not qualify for it will be assessed at the full rate, and the deficit will be demanded before registration.

The registration fee is separate from the stamp duty, and it is computed on the value of the property, not on the concessional duty. A family that budgets for a nominal stamp duty and forgets the registration fee is short at the counter.

The income-tax position

Section 56(2)(x) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 treats the receipt of property without consideration, or for inadequate consideration, as income in the hands of the recipient, subject to exceptions. A gift from a "relative" as defined in the Explanation to that clause is outside the charge, and so is a gift received on the occasion of a marriage, or under a will or by inheritance.

The definition of relative for this purpose includes the spouse, the siblings, the siblings of the parents, the lineal ascendants and descendants, and their spouses. A gift to a person outside that list, exceeding the statutory threshold in value, is taxable in the recipient's hands as income from other sources.

There is no capital gain on the gift itself, because a transfer by way of gift is excluded from the definition of transfer for capital gains. The donee takes the donor's cost of acquisition and the donor's period of holding, so the gain is deferred rather than eliminated: when the donee sells, the tax is computed from what the donor paid.

That last point is often missed in family planning. A gift to a daughter saves nothing in capital gains if she sells the flat within a year; the holding period carries over, and the cost is the original cost.

Revocation: the three exceptions

Section 126 of the Transfer of Property Act allows a gift to be revoked in three cases: where there is an agreement between the donor and the donee that the gift shall be revocable on the happening of a specified event, where the gift is conditional and the condition fails, and where the gift was obtained by fraud, misrepresentation, undue influence or coercion, in which case the donor may rescind it within a reasonable time.

A gift "revocable at the donor's will" is void, because a gift must be voluntary and complete. A gift with a condition that the donee will maintain the donor is valid, and if the donee fails to maintain, the donor can sue to revoke or for maintenance.

A deed of cancellation signed by both parties is effective as a fresh transaction, but it attracts stamp duty again. A unilateral cancellation deed registered by the donor is of doubtful validity, and the courts have generally held that a completed gift cannot be cancelled unilaterally.

Where a gift is attacked

The commonest attack is by the other children, on the ground that the donor was elderly, dependent on the donee, and not of sound mind. Where the donor was living with the donee and the donee managed his affairs, the court treats the transaction as one in which the beneficiary must prove fairness, and the burden shifts.

The second attack is by creditors, under section 53 of the Transfer of Property Act, on the ground that the gift was made to defeat them. A gift made after a decree, or while a suit is pending, is vulnerable.

The third is by a spouse, on the ground that the gift defeated the right to maintenance or to a share on partition. A gift of the whole property to one child, leaving the widow with nothing, is the classic case.

The Kolkata process

The deed is drafted, stamped through the electronic system, and presented at the sub-registrar's office with both parties and two witnesses. The registration is completed, the certified copy is issued, and the mutation is then applied for at the BL&LRO so that the record shows the donee.

Our gift deed practice drafts and registers the instrument, and the registration practice handles the stamping and the presentation. Where the gift is being challenged, the title disputes practice deals with the suit to set it aside.

Can a gift be cancelled later?

Only in the three situations section 126 allows: by agreement recorded in the deed, on the failure of a condition, or where the gift was obtained by fraud or undue influence and the donor acts within a reasonable time. A donor who simply regrets the gift has no remedy, and a unilateral cancellation deed has little legal effect.

Is a gift to my daughter tax-free?

For income tax, a gift to a daughter is a gift to a relative and is outside section 56(2)(x), so it is not taxed as income in her hands. For stamp duty, the concessional rate for relatives applies if the schedule covers the relationship. For capital gains, the gift is not a transfer, and the cost and holding period carry over to her.

Does the donee have to pay the stamp duty?

The duty is payable on the instrument, and by practice the donee bears it, though the deed can provide otherwise. The registration will not be completed until the duty and the registration fee are paid, so the question of who pays is settled before the presentation rather than after.

On gift deed family stamp duty, the arithmetic is simple and the consequences are serious. It transfers ownership permanently, it fixes the tax base for the next generation, and it is difficult to undo. It should be drafted with the same care as a sale, and with more attention to who will object to it afterwards.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422