14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Injunction against a co-owner selling the whole property

An injunction coowner sale application is granted where a co-owner is about to sell the whole property as if he were the sole owner, and the other co-owners can show that the record and the deeds give them a share. The relief is temporary and it does not decide the title, but it stops the transaction until the court can. The application has to be prepared like a small trial: the family tree, the record of rights, the deed under which the seller claims, and evidence of the proposed sale or the purchaser's activity on the property.

The legal basis for the relief

Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure allow a court to grant a temporary injunction where the property in dispute is threatened with waste, damage or alienation, or where the defendant is about to remove or dispose of his property with a view to obstructing a decree. A co-owner who is selling the whole property is disposing of property that does not belong to him, and the threatened sale is precisely the situation the rule addresses.

The substantive basis is Section 44 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882, which limits what a co-owner can transfer to his own share, and Section 52, which makes a transfer during the pendency of a suit binding on the transferee. An injunction restrains the sale; the substantive suit asks for a declaration that the sale beyond the seller's share is not binding on the plaintiffs, and for partition.

The three ingredients the court examines

  • A prima facie case. The plaintiffs must show a share, and the strongest evidence is the record of rights and the deed of the common ancestor, not an assertion of family relationship. A khatian showing joint names, a deed in the father's name with the plaintiffs as heirs, and the municipal records are the usual exhibits.
  • Balance of convenience. The court weighs the loss to the plaintiffs from a completed sale against the loss to the seller from a short delay. Where the seller is about to execute a deed, the balance almost always favours the plaintiffs.
  • Irreparable injury. A sale to a bona fide purchaser for value without notice creates third-party rights that are difficult and expensive to unwind, and that difficulty is itself the irreparable injury the court recognises.

An application that annexes a draft sale deed, a token payment receipt, a newspaper advertisement, or the purchaser's surveyor's visit establishes the immediacy that the court needs. An application based only on a belief that a sale may happen is usually refused.

Filing the application

  1. File the suit for declaration that the proposed sale is void beyond the seller's share, for partition, and for consequential relief, in the City Civil Court at Kolkata or the district court with jurisdiction.
  2. File the injunction application with an affidavit, the documents, and a draft of the order sought, on the same day as the plaint.
  3. Ask for an ex parte ad interim order where the sale is imminent, and be ready to justify the urgency at the first hearing. Courts grant short orders where the documents are clear and the injury would be irreversible.
  4. Serve the defendants and the intended purchaser, and press for confirmation of the order after service.
  5. Comply with the undertaking as to damages that the court may require, and do not act in breach of the status quo that the order preserves.

When the sale is already registered

An injunction cannot stop a deed that has been registered. The remedies then change: a suit for the declaration that the deed does not bind the plaintiffs' shares, an application to the sub-registrar for a certified copy and the index, a mutation objection with the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer, and a prayer for partition in the same suit.

A purchaser who bought with notice of the co-owners' shares, or after the suit was filed, is bound by the decree. A purchaser without notice who paid value and registered first may have a defence under the general law, and the plaintiffs then have to show that the seller's recitals were false and that the purchaser had constructive notice from the record, which is public.

The criminal and registration angles

Where a deed has been executed with a forged signature, or a power of attorney has been fabricated, the co-owner should file a police complaint and a complaint before the Magistrate, in addition to the civil suit. In Kolkata, the cyber crime cell at Lalbazar deals with offences involving forged digital documents, and the local police station registers the forgery complaint. The civil and criminal proceedings run in parallel, and the civil court can be told about the criminal case.

Registration itself cannot be stopped by a letter to the sub-registrar, because the office does not adjudicate title. What a co-owner can do is give the sub-registrar a written intimation of the dispute and the suit number, publish a public notice of the dispute in a newspaper circulating in the area, and obtain the injunction order and serve it on the sub-registrar so that the office is on notice.

Common questions

Can I get an injunction before filing the suit?

An order before the plaint is filed is possible only in a narrow situation, and the court will ordinarily require a suit to be instituted. The practical course is to file the plaint and the application together and to seek an urgent hearing on the same day. A caveat filed by the purchaser does not prevent the order; it only ensures that the purchaser is heard.

What if the buyer is a bona fide purchaser without notice?

The buyer's position depends on notice and on the record. The khatian and the registered deeds are public, and a purchaser who did not search them cannot easily claim ignorance. A purchaser who searched and was shown a false record by the seller has a claim against the seller, but the co-owners' shares are still protected.

Does the injunction stop construction on the property?

It can, if the construction threatens the plaintiffs' share or the value of the property. The application should ask for restraint on alienation, demolition and construction, and the court can order status quo on the structure. A separate application is often needed where construction begins after the first order.

How long does the injunction last?

A temporary injunction lasts until the suit is decided or the court varies it. An ad interim order granted ex parte lasts until the next hearing, and then the court decides whether to continue it. The plaintiffs should be ready with the documents at the first returnable date.

Speed decides these applications. Keep the khatian, the family deed and the municipal record together, watch the property for a surveyor or a broker, and file the moment a sale is threatened. Our title practice prepares the injunction application and the declaration suit, and the civil litigation team appears in the City Civil Court and the district courts at Alipore and Barasat. A legal notice to the seller and the purchaser before the suit often stops the transaction at no cost.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422