14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Insurance claim deficiency: the complaint and the interest

A repudiation without a lawful basis is a deficiency in service, and a consumer commission can order the insurer to pay the claim with interest from the date of repudiation, plus compensation and costs. The interest is the part that changes the arithmetic: a claim left unpaid for two years while the insurer deliberates is worth materially more once the commission has fixed a rate and a start date.

What makes a repudiation a deficiency

An insurer is entitled to reject a claim on a ground found in the policy. What it is not entitled to do is reject on a ground it invents, or reject and then defend the rejection with a new reason discovered later, or simply not decide at all.

The commissions look at four things:

  • Whether the ground of rejection is one that appears in the policy wording and was communicated to the insured.
  • Whether the insurer applied the exclusion consistently with its own earlier conduct — an insurer that accepted premiums for years on a particular basis cannot disown it when a claim arrives.
  • Whether the investigation was fair: were documents sought that were irrelevant, was the insured given a chance to explain, was a surveyor appointed and his report shared.
  • Whether the decision was taken within the period the regulator's protection-of-policyholders regulations prescribe, which is generally a month from the last document, extendable with reasons.

Delay alone can amount to deficiency even where the eventual rejection was justified. An insurer that sits on a claim for a year and then rejects it has still rendered a deficient service.

The complaint

File before the District Commission for the district where the insurer's office is situated or where the insured resides, subject to the current pecuniary limits, or before the State Commission where the amount exceeds the District limit. Filing is through the e-Daakhil portal, and the complaint must be accompanied by the policy, the proposal form, the claim form, the rejection letter and the correspondence.

Name the insurer as the opposite party, and name the TPA as well where the claim was administered through one. A TPA that rejected the claim on its own authority is a party to the deficiency, and an insurer that hides behind the TPA's decision is answerable for it.

Before filing, send a written representation to the insurer's grievance redressal officer and give it the period the regulations allow. That representation is useful for two reasons: it may produce payment, and it establishes the date from which interest can be claimed.

Interest: the rate and the start date

There is no single statutory rate. The commissions award interest, commonly in the range the courts have used for such claims, from a date they consider just. The argument at the hearing is about the start date, and the claimant's case is strongest when the interest is claimed from the date of repudiation or from the expiry of the period the insurer had to decide.

The claimant should plead a specific date and a specific basis rather than asking the commission to fix whatever it thinks fit. Where the insurer has held the money, the claimant has been deprived of it, and the compensation for that deprivation is interest. Adding a claim for interest for the litigation period is not double counting; it is the price of the delay.

Compensation for mental agony is a separate head and is awarded where the deficiency is established, particularly in health and death claims where the delay caused hardship to the family.

The medical cases

Health claims are the largest category and the most contested. The insurer's usual grounds are non-disclosure of a pre-existing condition at proposal, a waiting period, an exclusion for a particular treatment, or the claim being for a procedure the policy does not cover.

Non-disclosure is the strongest defence and the most fact-dependent. A condition the insured knew of and did not mention, which is material to the risk, justifies repudiation. A condition the insured did not know of, or which the insurer's own agent filled in wrongly, does not. The proposal form matters: if the agent completed it and the insured signed without reading, the commissions have taken differing views, and the evidence about who filled it in decides the case.

Where the insurer has paid part of the claim and rejected the rest, the complaint should challenge the deduction specifically — the room rent cap, the sub-limit, the non-payable items list. Those are contractual and a challenge succeeds only if the clause was not disclosed or was applied inconsistently.

What can be recovered

The heads are: the sum assured or the admissible claim, interest, compensation for mental agony and hardship, and costs. In a life claim, the death benefit plus interest. In a health claim, the admitted amount less any deductible, plus interest.

The commission cannot rewrite the policy. Where the exclusion is clear and was disclosed, the complaint fails, and the claimant's only route is to show that the exclusion does not apply to the facts. That is a construction argument, and it is worth making where the wording is ambiguous, because ambiguity in a policy drafted by the insurer is read against the insurer.

An insurer's rejection letter usually tells you the whole case. Read the ground it gives, and prepare the answer to that ground — not to the ground you expected.

Alternatives and their order

Three routes exist: the insurer's grievance machinery, the Insurance Ombudsman, and the consumer commission. The Ombudsman is free and quick but has a monetary ceiling and cannot award much beyond the claim. The commission can award interest, compensation and costs but takes longer and charges a fee. A civil suit is the route for claims above the commission's limit or where the dispute needs full evidence.

Choose one and do not run two at once on the same repudiation without advice. The insurer will raise the parallel proceeding at the first hearing.

Common questions

Can the insurer reject a claim after months of silence?

It can, and the rejection will be examined on its merits. The delay is itself a deficiency and supports a claim for interest and compensation even where the rejection is ultimately upheld.

Is the surveyor's report binding?

No. It is evidence, and the commission can depart from it, particularly where the surveyor was not given the full papers or where his reasoning is not explained. A one-line report is easily displaced.

What if the policy was taken by my employer?

A group policy taken by an employer is generally treated as a commercial arrangement, and the Ombudsman may decline it. The employee can still complain as a beneficiary in an appropriate case, and the commission will examine who the consumer is.

Read the rejection letter, fix the date from which interest should run, and file with the complete policy file. Our consumer protection practice handles insurance deficiencies before the West Bengal commissions, banking and finance covers the larger policy disputes, and motor accident claims covers the tribunal route where the claim is against another driver.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422