14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Joint development agreements: what must be registered

A joint development agreement gives a builder the right to construct on the owner's land in exchange for a share of the built area or the sale proceeds, and it is the commonest structure for residential development in Kolkata. Whether it must be registered depends on what it does: an agreement that confers a right in the land is registrable, and the ones that are not registered are the ones that end in a suit when the developer sells flats the owner never agreed to.

Joint development agreement registration is therefore a question of characterisation, and the characterisation has stamp duty and tax consequences that dwarf the registration fee.

What the agreement actually does

In the usual structure the owner contributes the land, the developer contributes the construction and the finance, and the built area is shared in an agreed ratio or the sale proceeds are divided. The owner remains the owner of the land until the flats are conveyed to buyers, and the developer acquires a right to develop and to sell the owner's share of the flats within the project.

Three documents usually go together: the development agreement, a power of attorney authorising the developer to deal with the property and to execute conveyances, and a supplemental agreement recording the area sharing. Where the arrangement includes a lease of the land for the construction period, a lease deed is added.

Registration and stamp duty

An agreement that creates an interest in immovable property falls within section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 and requires registration. A development agreement that gives the developer the right to construct and to sell units ordinarily creates such an interest, and West Bengal charges stamp duty on development agreements at a rate fixed in the schedule, computed on the land value or the consideration.

The duty is not nominal, and it is the reason parties sometimes draft the agreement as a bare licence or a construction contract. A document that reads as a construction contract but gives the developer the right to sell the owner's flats will be treated as what it is, and the deficiency is then a matter for the Collector.

The agreement should be registered at the sub-registrar's office having jurisdiction over the land, and the power of attorney should be registered or at least adjudicated, because it will be used to execute sale deeds in the owner's name.

The RERA overlay

Where the project is a real estate project within the meaning of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016, it must be registered with the West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority before the developer advertises or books any unit. The promoter is the person who constructs and sells, and under a joint development arrangement the developer is ordinarily the promoter, with the landowner joined as a promoter where the statute's definition catches him.

The agreement itself has to be disclosed in the registration application, and the timeline for completion, the sanctioned plan and the land title documents go on the file. A project marketed without registration exposes the developer to penalties and the buyer to a remedy before the Authority, and the landowner's name on the title does not insulate him.

Where the developer defaults, the allottees claim against the promoter, and the landowner may find his land encumbered by orders under section 18 for refund and interest. That is the reason the agreement should place the obligation to register the project on the developer, with a covenant to indemnify the owner.

The owner's protections

Reserve the owner's share in defined units, with their numbers, floors, areas and the specifications, rather than a percentage of the aggregate. A percentage is difficult to enforce when the developer sells the best units first and leaves the owner with the remainder.

Provide for a security: a bank guarantee, a charge over the developer's other assets, or the deposit of the title deeds with an escrow arrangement. Provide for the owner's right to inspect the accounts and the progress, and for the owner's consent to any change in the sanctioned plan that affects the owner's share.

Provide for termination on defined defaults, and for the consequences of termination: the developer's right to recover its cost, the owner's right to resume possession, and the treatment of the units already booked by buyers. A termination clause without those consequences produces litigation rather than a remedy.

Provide for arbitration, because a joint development dispute is a commercial dispute with documents, accounts and valuations, and it is better resolved by an arbitrator than in a civil suit.

Tax, in outline

The landowner's contribution of land to the development can attract capital gains when possession is handed over, and the timing depends on the terms of the agreement and the nature of the consideration received. The developer's receipts are subject to GST on construction services, and the treatment of the owner's share of flats, and of the development rights, has been the subject of changes in the rate and the exemptions. A current opinion on both is necessary before the agreement is signed, because the tax cost can exceed the stamp duty.

The owner's share of flats, when sold, is a separate capital gains computation with its own cost basis, which is why the agreement should record the value attributed to the land and to the construction.

Where these arrangements fail

The first failure is an unregistered agreement with a power of attorney to sell, under which the developer sells flats and the owner discovers the sales only when the buyers sue for possession.

The second is an area-sharing clause with no specification of which units, so that the dispute is about the identity of the owner's flats rather than about the ratio.

The third is a project launched without RERA registration, which exposes both parties to the Authority's orders and freezes the project at the stage when the developer most needs to sell.

Is a joint development agreement a sale of land?

No. The owner does not transfer the land at the outset; the transfer happens when the flats are conveyed to buyers and when the owner's share is allotted. But the agreement creates rights in the land, and it is treated as an instrument affecting immovable property for registration and stamp duty.

Who is the promoter under RERA in a joint development?

The developer who constructs and markets the project is ordinarily the promoter. The landowner can also be a promoter where the definition in the Act catches him, and the registration application should disclose the arrangement so that responsibility is clear.

Can the developer sell flats without the owner signing?

Only if the power of attorney authorises it, and only within its terms. A power to execute sale deeds for the owner's share, limited to the agreed units and the agreed price floor, is the usual protection. A general power without limits is how owners lose control of their own land.

What if the developer abandons the project?

The owner's remedy is termination under the agreement, resumption of possession, and a claim for damages or for the cost of completing the project. Where the project is RERA-registered, the allottees also have remedies against the promoter, and the owner's position is affected by the orders passed in their favour.

The document has to allocate risk before the first flat is sold, and that is a drafting exercise with a tax and RERA overlay. Our RERA practice handles registrations and complaints, the registration team deals with the agreement and the power of attorney, and the tax practice advises on the GST and capital gains position. Begin at our contact page.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422