14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

An executor's liability for a wrong distribution

An executor occupies a fiduciary position, and he is personally liable if he distributes the estate to a person who was not entitled, or pays legacies before the debts, or deals with the property without authority. The liability is not limited to the assets in his hands where the breach is his own. That is why the executor's first duty is to establish who is entitled, and why the prudent executor advertises for creditors and obtains the court's directions where the position is unclear.

The office is unpaid and burdensome, and most executors are family members who do not realise that the duties are those of a trustee. The realisation comes when a creditor or an omitted heir sues them personally.

The duties, in order

The executor must prove the will, collect the assets, pay the funeral expenses and the debts, pay the legacies, and distribute the residue to the persons entitled. He must keep accounts, file the inventory that the court directs, and be ready to account to the beneficiaries.

The order matters. Debts come before legacies, and legacies come before the residue. An executor who pays a legacy to a beneficiary and then finds that the estate cannot pay its debts has paid out of his own pocket, and the beneficiary may be required to refund.

The executor must also pay the taxes of the estate, and he is responsible for the returns for the period of administration. A failure there produces a demand against the estate and, in defined cases, against the executor.

Distribution to the wrong person

The commonest breach is a distribution to a person who appeared entitled but was not. A person who claimed as an heir and was later shown not to be one, a legatee under an earlier will that was superseded, a nominee who was not the beneficial owner.

The executor must make reasonable inquiry. A grant of probate protects him as to the will, but it does not protect him as to the identity of the persons entitled to the residue. Where he acts on a document that a reasonable person would have questioned, the protection is lost.

The remedy against him is a suit by the rightful beneficiary for the amount wrongly paid, with interest. The executor's right to recover from the person who received the money is a separate claim, and it is often worthless.

Payment before debts

A creditor who is unpaid because the executor distributed the estate can sue the executor personally, and the executor's own assets are exposed. The executor's right of retainer allows him to keep assets to meet the debts, and it is a right he should exercise before any distribution.

The protection is an advertisement for creditors, in the manner the court's rules provide, inviting claims within a stated period. An executor who advertises and distributes after the period, in good faith, is in a much stronger position than one who distributes without notice.

Self-dealing and the executor's own interest

An executor who is also a beneficiary must not use his position to obtain an advantage over the other beneficiaries. A sale of estate property to himself, at a price he fixes, is a self-dealing transaction that the court will examine strictly.

Where the will confers a power of sale on the executor, the power must be exercised for the benefit of the estate, at a proper price, and in good faith. The court can set aside a sale that is below value or made to a connected person without disclosure.

The executor's protections

  • Obtaining probate, which establishes the will and his authority.
  • Advertising for creditors before distribution.
  • Applying to the court for directions where the entitlement is doubtful.
  • Keeping full accounts, with vouchers, from the first receipt.
  • Distributing only against a written acknowledgement and an indemnity from the recipient.
  • Obtaining a discharge from the beneficiaries, where they are competent to give one.

The court's directions are the strongest protection. An executor who applies for directions on a doubtful question, and acts on the order, is protected from a later claim that he chose wrongly.

Removal, and the accounts

The court can remove an executor for misconduct, for failure to administer, for insolvency, or for a conflict of interest, and it can appoint an administrator in his place. The application is made in the probate proceeding or by a suit, and the court examines the accounts and the conduct.

A beneficiary can also apply for an account of the administration, and the executor must produce the accounts and the vouchers. The refusal to account is itself a ground for removal.

Limitation

A suit against an executor for a legacy or for a share of the estate is governed by the limitation law, and the period depends on the nature of the claim. A claim founded on a trust, or on the executor's breach of trust, has a longer period than a simple money claim, and the characterisation of the claim is therefore worth attention.

A beneficiary who delays for years may find that the claim is barred, or that the executor has distributed the estate and has nothing left. The account application is the step that preserves the position, and it should be made early.

The Kolkata courts

The probate is granted on the original side of the Calcutta High Court where the will falls within its jurisdiction, and the administration is supervised by that court. A suit against an executor for a wrong distribution is filed in the court with jurisdiction over the estate or the defendant, and the accounts are taken in that proceeding.

Our succession practice advises executors on the administration and the accounts, and the civil litigation practice deals with the claims against them. Where the dispute is about the land in the estate, the partition practice handles the division among the beneficiaries.

Is the executor personally liable?

Yes, where the breach is his own: a distribution to a person not entitled, a payment of legacies before debts, a sale at an undervalue, or a failure to account. He is not liable for a loss that is not his fault, or for a distribution made in good faith on a grant of probate, provided he made reasonable inquiry.

Can an executor be removed?

Yes, by the court, for misconduct, for failure to administer, for a conflict of interest, or for insolvency. The application is made in the probate proceeding, and the court can appoint an administrator in his place. The threat of removal is also the pressure that produces the accounts.

What if the executor is also a beneficiary?

He can act, but his dealings with the estate are scrutinised, and a sale to himself or to a connected person requires disclosure and a proper price. Where the conflict is serious, the court can direct an independent administrator to deal with that part of the estate.

For executor liability wrong distribution, the exposure is the price of the office, and it is manageable with three habits: keep accounts from the first day, advertise before distributing, and ask the court when the answer is not clear.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422