14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

The Two-Year Limit for a Consumer Complaint

A consumer complaint must be filed within two years from the date on which the cause of action arises. Section 69 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, says so, and adds that the commission may entertain a complaint after that period if the complainant shows sufficient cause for the delay. The whole argument in a limitation dispute is therefore about one question: on what date did the cause of action arise?

What a cause of action is

A cause of action is the set of facts that gives the complainant a right to relief. It is not the date of purchase, and it is not the date on which the complainant finally became annoyed. For a deficiency in service, it is the date on which the service was rendered in a deficient manner, or the date on which the provider refused to remedy it. For defective goods, it is the date on which the defect appeared or was discovered, whichever is later and can be proved.

The distinction matters because buyers often assume the two years runs from the invoice. A vehicle bought in 2022 and suffering a gearbox failure in 2023 has a cause of action in 2023, and the complaint filed in 2024 is within time. A buyer who waits until 2025 to complain about the same failure may be outside the period, because the cause of action arose when the defect was known.

Starting points that recur

  • Insurance: the date of repudiation, which is the date of the insurer's letter refusing the claim. A complaint filed within two years of that letter is in time, even if the policy is a decade old.
  • Builder delay: the date of the promised possession, or the date of the occupancy certificate if the promise was open-ended. Each month of delay is not a fresh cause of action for the whole claim, though continuing default can extend the period.
  • Bank charges: the date of the charge in the statement, not the date the customer noticed it, unless the charge was concealed.
  • Medical negligence: the date of the treatment, or the date the patient discovered the injury where the record was withheld. Discovery requires evidence, not assertion.
  • Defective goods: the date of delivery for a patent defect, and the date of discovery for a latent one.
  • Travel and education services: the date of the service, such as the date of the cancelled flight or the date the course was to begin.

Continuing wrong, and its limits

Where a deficiency continues, such as an unpaved approach road promised with a flat, or a service discontinued without notice while billing continues, the cause of action can be treated as recurring. The complainant may rely on the last act. But a single wrong that has continuing consequences is not a continuing wrong: an order passed once, which keeps causing loss, does not restart the clock each month.

This distinction is where most limitation arguments are lost. Complainants describe a state of affairs, "the flat has been leaking since 2021", and expect the clock to run from the latest leak. The commission asks when the leakage was first complained of and what the opposite party did. If the answer is that a complaint was made in 2021 and refused, the cause of action is in 2021.

Condonation

Section 69 permits the commission to entertain a complaint after two years if the complainant satisfies it that there was sufficient cause for the delay. The application should be a separate affidavit setting out the dates, the reason for each period of delay, and the evidence. Illness, a pending criminal case, a compromise under negotiation, and the complainant's absence from the country are all reasons that have been accepted, but only with documents.

The commission's approach has generally been liberal where the delay is explained and the opposite party is not prejudiced. It is not liberal where the delay is years long and the explanation is that the complainant was "trying to settle". Negotiation does not stop time.

What does not save time

A notice to the opposite party does not extend the period. A complaint to a consumer helpline, or a grievance posted on a portal, does not extend it either, though both are useful evidence of the demand. Filing before a commission that lacks territorial or pecuniary jurisdiction may be treated as time spent in good faith and excluded, but the commission is not obliged to do so, and a complainant should not rely on it.

Neither does the pendency of a civil suit on the same subject, unless the commission stays its own proceedings. Filing in two forums at once risks the objection that the complainant has elected a remedy.

Working out the date in practice

Take the earliest document that shows the opposite party knew of the grievance and did not act: the email, the job card, the repudiation letter, the notice. That date, not the date of the loss, is usually the cause of action. Then count two years. If the complaint is close to the line, file it with a condonation application rather than without one, because a commission that finds the complaint within time will ignore the application, while a commission that finds it late without an application has no power to help.

In Kolkata, complaints are filed before the District Commission or the State Commission through e-Daakhil, and the date of filing is the date the portal accepts the complaint with the fee. A complaint drafted in time and filed a month later can be lost on that alone.

Limitation is a defence, and the opposite party usually raises it in the written version. A complainant who has thought about the date in advance answers it in the complaint itself, with a paragraph on when the cause of action arose and why the complaint is within time. Our consumer protection practice drafts that paragraph as a matter of course, and the notice practice issues the demand that often fixes the date.

Common questions

Is the two years counted from the invoice?

Usually not. It runs from the cause of action, which for a service is the deficient act or the refusal to remedy, and for goods is the appearance of the defect. The invoice matters as evidence of the purchase, not as the starting date.

Can I file after two years if I was ill?

Yes, if you apply for condonation and support the illness with medical records covering the period of delay. A certificate issued after the fact carries less weight than the contemporaneous treatment record.

Does a legal notice stop the clock?

No. Correspondence may show that the opposite party acknowledged the claim, which has its own effect, but it does not suspend the two-year period.

What if the opposite party kept promising to repair?

Each broken promise can be a fresh deficiency, and the last refusal is a defensible starting point. Keep the promises in writing; an oral assurance is difficult to prove and easy to deny.

Fix the date first, then draft. A complaint filed on the right date in the wrong words can be amended; one filed on the wrong date cannot be saved. If you are close to the two-year mark, contact us now; the consultation fee is ₹2,000.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422