14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Medical bills in a MACT claim: what a tribunal reimburses

A tribunal reimburses medical expenses that were actually incurred and can be proved with a document. It does not reimburse an estimate, a rounded figure or a bundle of bills with no prescriptions behind them. The difference between a claim that recovers the full hospital bill and one that recovers half is almost always the quality of the treatment record, not the seriousness of the injury.

The heads that sit under medical expenses

The statute allows compensation for expenses reasonably incurred, and tribunals break that into recognisable heads. First, hospital charges: admission, bed, operation theatre, surgeon's fee, anaesthetist, medicines administered in hospital, and investigations. Second, pre-hospital and post-hospital expenses: the ambulance, the first aid at a nursing home, follow-up consultations, physiotherapy, and medicines bought on prescription after discharge. Third, appliances and aids: implants, plates and screws, a wheelchair, crutches, a prosthesis, and in spinal cases a catheter and pressure-relief equipment. Fourth, attendant charges and the cost of a nurse at home where the doctor certifies that nursing care was needed.

Above these sits future medical expense. Where the doctor states that further surgery, implant removal, or revision is required, the tribunal allows a sum for it. The estimate must come from the treating doctor or a hospital estimate, not from the claimant's own arithmetic.

The rule about private treatment and cost

There is no rule that a victim must be treated in a government hospital. A tribunal does not reduce an award because the family chose a private nursing home in Salt Lake or a corporate hospital on the E M Bypass, provided the treatment was reasonable and related to the accident. What it will examine is whether the treatment was necessary and whether the charges were fair.

Where the bill appears inflated, the tribunal can ask the hospital for its tariff and compare. It can also ask why a particular investigation was ordered. Treatment for a condition that predates the accident, or an elective procedure unconnected to the injuries, is removed. So is treatment taken months later at a different hospital with no referral in the record.

The documents that carry the claim

  • The discharge summary from every admission, showing the dates, the diagnosis, the procedure and the advice on discharge.
  • The original bills, itemised. A consolidated receipt for a lump sum is weak evidence and invites objection.
  • Pharmacy bills with the prescriptions, dated to match. A prescription for a medicine that does not appear on the bill, or a bill with no prescription, is the easiest thing for an insurer to attack.
  • Payment proof: card slips, UPI records, bank statements, or the hospital's receipt. Cash payments with no receipt are the hardest to prove.
  • Investigation reports: X-rays, CT and MRI films with reports, blood reports, and the operation note.
  • The treating doctor's certificate on the continuing need for treatment, physiotherapy or nursing, and on any disability.
  • Transport and attendant records: ambulance receipts, and a short affidavit from the family member who stayed in hospital.

Originals matter. Tribunals mark documents in the original where possible, and a claimant who produces only photocopies is often asked to file an affidavit explaining why. Where the original bill was submitted to a mediclaim insurer, the insurer's settlement letter and a certified copy serve the purpose, and the tribunal will want to know that the same expense is not being claimed twice. Where a bill has to be proved through an affidavit, the form is on our affidavit drafting page.

Mediclaim money and the collateral benefit question

Where a health policy paid part of the hospital bill, the insurer of the offending vehicle will argue that the claimant has already been reimbursed and cannot claim again. The settled position is that the compensation is not reduced by a payment the victim received under a contract of insurance he paid for. The tribunal may, however, want the mediclaim record so that the figures are reconciled and the same bill is not counted twice.

This is a place where careless drafting costs money. If the hospital bill shows a total of a larger figure and the mediclaim paid part of it, the claim should state both, with the settlement letter, and ask for the balance as special damages. Leaving the mediclaim out and claiming the full bill invites an objection that damages the claimant's credibility on everything else.

Future treatment and the doctor's evidence

A claim for future medical expense succeeds on the treating doctor's evidence. The doctor should be asked to state, in the certificate and if necessary in evidence, what further treatment is required, at what interval, and an approximate cost. In implant cases, the cost of removal and the possibility of revision surgery are routinely allowed. In head injury cases, the cost of long-term physiotherapy and occupational therapy is allowed where the doctor supports it.

Where the victim is a child and the injury affects growth, the tribunal may allow a lump sum for future corrective surgery rather than a precise estimate, because the exact cost cannot be known. Our note on motor accident claims sets out how that is pleaded.

The hospital's duty to give you the record

A patient is entitled to a copy of his own medical record, and hospitals are expected to supply it on a written request by the patient or a person authorised by him. The practical difficulty is timing: records move to storage, and a file from three years ago may take weeks to retrieve. Make the request in writing, keep the acknowledgement, and specify the documents you want rather than asking for the file generally.

Where the hospital refuses, the tribunal can summon the record once the claim is filed, and a doctor can be examined on it. In a serious case, an application for the record should be made early rather than at the stage of evidence, because the doctor's recollection is fresher and the documents are still together. The patient's right to records is dealt with in more detail on our page on medical and digital records.

What the tribunal will not allow

Three categories of claim are regularly cut. Bills for treatment that the discharge summary does not mention. Bills from a hospital with no reference from the first treating hospital and no explanation for the change. And bills supported only by an affidavit of the claimant with no third-party document at all.

Diet and conveyance are allowed as conventional sums rather than as reimbursement of every receipt, and the tribunal usually fixes a modest figure. The same is true of the attendant's loss of wages: it is allowed as a conventional head, not at the rate the attendant actually earned, unless the evidence supports it.

Where the claim is filed

The application goes to the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal at the City Civil Court in Kolkata, or to the district court at Barasat or Alipore depending on where the accident happened. The medical record is filed with the application as an annexure and marked through the hospital's witness or by a certified copy. Where the hospital is outside West Bengal, the tribunal can issue a commission or accept a certified copy with an affidavit.

Common questions

Are bills in the name of a family member acceptable?

Usually yes, if the bill relates to the injured person and the family member paid. The tribunal may ask for a short affidavit linking the payment to the patient. Bills in a completely different name need an explanation, or they will be excluded.

Can physiotherapy taken at home be claimed?

Yes, with the doctor's certificate that it was necessary and receipts from the physiotherapist for each visit. A lump-sum figure with no receipts is treated as a conventional expense and allowed at a much smaller amount.

What if the hospital has lost the records?

Then the claim is built from what survives: the discharge card issued to the patient, the pharmacy bills, the investigation films, and the doctor's own file. A written request to the hospital and its reply, even a refusal, should be placed on record, because it explains the gap.

Does the tribunal award interest on medical expenses?

Interest is awarded on the compensation as a whole from the date of the application, and sometimes from the date of the accident. The tribunal does not usually split interest head by head, so the effect is the same.

Medical expenses are the least arguable part of a motor accident claim and the part most often lost through carelessness. A family that keeps every bill, every prescription and every discharge summary in one envelope from the first day will recover what it spent. A family that reconstructs the file two years later will recover what it can prove, which is usually less.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422