14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Medical negligence as a consumer claim: the proof

A patient who suffers a bad outcome after treatment has not, by that fact alone, a claim for medical negligence. The test is whether the doctor fell below the standard of an ordinarily competent practitioner in his field. A consumer commission applies that test, and it applies it on expert evidence, not on the sympathy the facts may invite.

The standard the law sets

The settled rule is that a medical practitioner is not negligent if he acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical opinion in his field. It is not enough that another doctor would have done it differently. The question is whether the course adopted was a reasonable one, and whether the practitioner brought to the case the ordinary skill and care that his profession expects.

Three consequences follow. A difference of opinion on treatment is not negligence. An error of judgement in a difficult case is not negligence, unless the error is one no competent practitioner would have made. And a failure in the basics, such as leaving a swab inside a patient, operating on the wrong limb, or discharging a patient in a condition that any doctor would have admitted, is negligence without much need for expert argument.

In an appropriate case, the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur applies: the thing speaks for itself, and the burden shifts to the doctor to explain how the injury happened if the injury could not have occurred without negligence. Courts use it sparingly in medical cases, and usually where the patient was unconscious or the injury was wholly outside the procedure.

What the complainant must prove

Four things, in sequence. That the doctor owed a duty of care, which is established by the fact of the consultation or admission. That the duty was breached, which is the expert question. That the breach caused the injury, which is the causation question. And that the injury has a measurable consequence, whether in further treatment costs, lost income, disability or death.

The second and third are where these cases fail. A complainant who proves that a dose was wrong but cannot show that the wrong dose caused the damage has proved negligence and no loss. Causation in medicine is often contested, and it needs a doctor to say that on a balance of probabilities the breach made the difference, not merely that it might have.

The expert evidence, and where it comes from

The complainant should obtain an independent opinion from a practitioner in the same speciality, on the case record, before filing. That opinion should address the standard practice, what was done, what should have been done, and whether the departure caused the injury. A one-page letter saying "there was negligence" is of little use.

Where an opinion cannot be obtained, institutions help. A medical college in Kolkata can be asked for an opinion through its head of department, and a government hospital's view carries weight with a commission. In a case where a medical board has already examined the patient for disability, the board's report is a useful foundation.

The commission can also summon the hospital record, examine the treating doctor, and appoint an independent expert. It does not usually appoint an expert on its own motion in the first instance; the parties are expected to bring their own evidence.

The hospital's separate liability

A hospital is liable for its own deficiencies as well as for the negligence of those it employs. A failure to keep records, a shortage of staff in the emergency room, a delay in arranging a specialist, an infection traceable to poor sterilisation: each is a hospital failure, and each can be pursued even where the treating doctor is not shown to be negligent.

A hospital that engages a consultant on a fee-sharing arrangement may argue that the consultant is independent. Commissions look at the reality of the arrangement, and a hospital that holds itself out as providing the treatment will usually be answerable for it.

The proof problems that sink these cases

  • No case record. Without the admission notes, the operation note and the nurse's chart, the complainant is arguing in the air. The record must be obtained in writing from the hospital, and a refusal should be documented.
  • Consent forms signed without reading. A consent form that describes the risks in general terms protects the doctor against a claim that he failed to warn, but not against a claim that he was careless. The distinction is often lost in the pleadings.
  • A bad outcome presented as negligence. The commission will not infer negligence from a death after surgery. It will ask what the accepted practice was and whether the doctor followed it.
  • No causation evidence. Expert opinions that address the standard but not the consequence leave the claim half-proved.
  • Delay. Records are weeded, doctors retire, and the two-year limitation passes while the family is still grieving.

The forum and the limitation

A claim for compensation for medical negligence can be brought before the District Commission, the State Commission or the National Commission according to the value of the consideration paid for the treatment, which is usually the hospital bill. A claim that includes compensation for death or disability is valued accordingly, and a large claim goes to the State Commission at Kolkata.

The limitation is two years from the date of the cause of action, which is generally the date of the negligent act or the date the patient discovered it. A family that learns of a retained surgical item years later has a later starting point, but it will have to explain the delay.

The civil suit route is also open, before the City Civil Court or the original side of the Calcutta High Court, and it carries a three-year limitation. The consumer route is cheaper and faster for most families, and it allows evidence by affidavit. Our page on consumer protection sets out the procedure. It is pleaded in the manner set out under civil litigation.

The criminal route, and why it is different

A criminal complaint for negligence causing death requires a much higher degree of fault. The standard is gross negligence, of a kind that shows a disregard for human life, and courts have repeatedly declined to convert a civil claim into a prosecution. A doctor can be acquitted in the criminal case and still be held liable in compensation, because the standards differ. The offence and the standard of proof in a prosecution are dealt with under criminal law.

Families often want the prosecution more than the money. It is worth being honest with them: the criminal route is slow, the conviction rate in these cases is low, and the evidence that wins compensation does not necessarily win a prosecution.

Common questions

Is a doctor liable if the patient did not improve?

No. Liability requires a departure from accepted practice, not an unsatisfactory result. A chronic condition that does not improve despite correct treatment gives no claim.

Can I claim if the doctor did not explain the risks?

Yes, in principle. A failure to obtain informed consent is a recognised ground, but it requires evidence of what a reasonable doctor would have disclosed in that situation, and evidence that the patient would have refused the treatment had he known.

Does the hospital have to give me the records before I file?

A patient is entitled to a copy of his record, and a written request should be made with an acknowledgement. Where the hospital refuses, the commission can summon the record once the complaint is filed, and the refusal is itself worth pleading.

How long does a medical negligence complaint take?

Longer than most consumer matters, because expert evidence and cross-examination of doctors take time. A contested case commonly runs a few years, and a case that settles after the expert report is much quicker.

The claim is provable, but only with a record and an expert. A family that obtains the file, gets an honest opinion on whether the practice was accepted or aberrant, and quantifies the loss will know within a month whether it has a case. That is a better position than filing on grief and discovering the answer three years later.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422