The seller is the primary party, but the marketplace is not always a neutral noticeboard. Under the Consumer Protection (E-Commerce) Rules, 2020 a marketplace entity has duties of disclosure, grievance redress, and — where a seller on its platform fails to deliver or to refund — a fall-back liability. Which of the two you sue depends on whether the platform was a marketplace or an inventory seller, and on what it actually did.
Marketplace and inventory models
The rules draw a distinction that decides who is the seller. In a marketplace model, the platform provides the interface and the seller owns the stock and the contract. In an inventory model, the platform itself owns the goods and sells them, and it is the seller in its own right.
Look at the invoice. If the invoice is issued by the platform, the platform is the seller. If it is issued by a third party with the platform named only as a facilitator, the seller is that third party. The name on the invoice and the name on the payment gateway are the two facts to check first.
Even in the marketplace model, the platform's obligations are real. It must display the seller's identity, address and contact details, must display the country of origin, must provide the grievance officer's name and contact, must acknowledge a complaint within forty-eight hours, and must redress it within a month of receipt. It must also allow the consumer to cancel an order before dispatch, and must not refuse to take back defective goods or withdraw deficient services — that refusal is itself an unfair trade practice.
The fall-back liability
The rules place a fall-back liability on a marketplace entity where a seller on its platform fails to deliver the goods or services, or fails to refund a payment made, after the seller's failure is established. The consumer does not have to chase an unknown seller in another state and discover that he has no assets; the platform can be required to make good.
That liability is what makes a consumer complaint worthwhile against a large platform. Where a seller has disappeared, the complaint should name both the seller and the marketplace, and plead the fall-back liability expressly. A complaint that names only the vanished seller leaves the complainant with an award that cannot be executed.
The grievance route before filing
Write to the platform's grievance officer, using the details the platform is required to publish. Keep the ticket number. If the officer does not resolve the complaint within the month, the platform has breached the rules, and that breach is a separate deficiency on which the complaint can rely.
Also use the National Consumer Helpline, which is a mediation route and often produces a result without litigation. It is not a substitute for the Commission, but it costs nothing and creates a dated record of the attempt.
Where the payment was made through a card or a unified payment interface, the card network's chargeback mechanism is a parallel remedy. It runs on its own timelines — commonly within a hundred and twenty days of the transaction — and may produce a refund faster than any complaint.
Evidence in an online purchase dispute
The whole case can sit in a phone. Preserve it properly:
- The order confirmation, the invoice, and the payment record.
- Screenshots of the product page as it was at the time of purchase, including the price, the description, the warranty terms and the seller's details.
- The delivery record and the courier's tracking page.
- Photographs of the goods as received, taken on the day of delivery.
- The complete chat or email thread with the seller and with the platform.
Screenshots need a date. A screenshot without a visible timestamp is easy to challenge. Where the platform has deleted or changed the listing, a notarised capture of the page, or an archived copy, is stronger.
For a defective product, obtain a technician's report or a service centre's job card. That document converts a complaint about quality into evidence of a defect.
What the Commission can order
The remedies are the standard ones: replacement of the goods, refund of the price with interest, compensation for loss, injury or mental agony, removal of the defect, and discontinuation of the unfair practice. For a small-value dispute the compensation is modest, and the cost of the complaint may exceed the loss. That is a reason to use the platform's grievance route first and the Commission for cases where the amount justifies it.
The Commission can also order the platform to withdraw the listing, or to discontinue a practice, which matters where the wrong is systemic rather than individual.
Preserve the product page on the day you buy. The seller's representation is the contract, and it disappears when the listing is edited.
Jurisdiction and filing
A consumer complaint may be filed where the complainant resides or personally works for gain, among other places. That is a favourable rule for online disputes, because the buyer is no longer forced to travel to the seller's state. For a Kolkata buyer, the complaint can be filed before the District Commission for Kolkata, subject to the pecuniary limits fixed by the current rules, and the filing is through the e-Daakhil portal.
Name the seller, the platform and, where relevant, the payment aggregator. Serve each of them. A party who is not served cannot be bound, and platforms are quick to say they were never served.
Common questions
Can a marketplace be sued when the seller is a separate company?
Yes, on the fall-back liability and on its own rule-based obligations. The platform is not liable for every seller default, but where the seller has failed and the platform has not discharged its duty, the complaint lies against both.
What if the product was bought from a social media page?
The same consumer law applies, but the evidence problem is bigger: there may be no invoice, no registered entity and no address. Pay by a traceable method, keep the chat, and ask for the seller's GST details before paying.
Can I return goods without a reason?
That depends on the platform's return policy, which is part of the contract. A policy that promises a return within a stated period is enforceable. A platform that refuses a return it promised is in deficiency.
Keep the record, use the grievance officer, and sue both parties where the seller has vanished. Where the grievance officer has not replied at all, that silence is itself a breach of the rules and should be pleaded in the complaint. Our consumer protection page covers the Commission procedure, cyber fraud covers the case where the "seller" was never a seller at all, and breach of contract covers the contractual claim.