14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Pecuniary Limits: Which Consumer Commission Hears Your Claim

Under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, the forum is decided by the value of the goods or services paid as consideration. The District Commission hears claims up to fifty lakh rupees, the State Commission hears claims above that and up to two crore rupees, and the National Commission hears anything above two crore. Filing in the wrong forum costs time, not the claim, but the time can be a year.

The three tiers

The District Commission has jurisdiction where the value of the goods or services paid as consideration does not exceed fifty lakh rupees. The State Commission has jurisdiction where that value exceeds fifty lakh but does not exceed two crore. The National Commission has jurisdiction where it exceeds two crore.

Filing is ordinarily before the District Commission for the place where the opposite party resides or carries on business, or where the cause of action arises. For a company with branches, the branch that dealt with the consumer is the relevant place. For an e-commerce transaction, the Act allows the complaint at the place of the consumer's residence or the place of delivery, which is a practical improvement over the older rule.

The State Commission for West Bengal sits at Kolkata, and the District Commission for Kolkata sits in the city as well. A complaint against a builder with a project in Rajarhat and a registered office in Mumbai can be filed in Kolkata if the cause of action arose there, which for a flat purchase it usually does.

What "value of the consideration" means

The value is what the consumer paid, or agreed to pay, for the goods or services. It is not the compensation claimed, and it is not the value of the loss. A flat bought for forty lakh with a claim for ten lakh damages is a District Commission case, because the consideration is forty lakh. A flat bought for eighty lakh is a State Commission case, even if the claim is only five lakh.

This is the point most often missed. Complainants calculate the forum by the relief they want, and defendants object. The objection is usually decided at the admission stage, and a complaint filed in the wrong forum is returned, not dismissed, with liberty to file elsewhere.

For services that are provided without a single price, the value is the consideration for the service in question. For a continuous service such as an insurance policy, the value is the premium paid, unless the Act or the rules provide otherwise for a particular class of claim. For a loan, it is the amount borrowed or the charges paid, depending on the grievance.

No splitting, and no disguising

A consumer cannot split a single claim into several complaints to fit within the District Commission's limit. The Act requires the value of the goods or services, not the value of each head of relief. Where a family has several claims arising from the same transaction, they are heard together.

Nor can a consumer bring a claim that is really a commercial dispute within the consumer forum by describing it as a deficiency. A purchase for resale, or a service availed for a business purpose, is excluded from the definition of consumer, though the exclusion is applied with care where the buyer is a small trader using the goods for a livelihood.

What happens if you file in the wrong forum

The commission returns the complaint with an endorsement. The complainant then files in the correct forum, and the time spent in the first forum may be excluded in computing limitation if the mistake was bona fide. The commission may also transfer a complaint to the correct forum rather than return it, and the Act gives the National Commission and the State Commission power to transfer proceedings between commissions.

The practical lesson is to compute the value before drafting. The invoice, the agreement to sell, the policy schedule and the loan sanction letter give the figure. A complaint that states the value and the basis for it in the first paragraph avoids the objection altogether.

Pecuniary limit and the relief

The limit applies to the value of the consideration, but the relief can exceed it in one respect: the commission may award compensation for loss and injury, and costs, in addition. It cannot award an amount that takes the claim outside its jurisdiction as a device, but a District Commission hearing a forty-lakh flat dispute can award compensation on top of the refund.

Where the claim includes a direction to do something, such as complete the construction or restore a service, the value is still the consideration paid, not the cost of the work. That is why many builder complaints stay in the District Commission even though the relief would cost crores to implement.

Appeals and their own limits

An appeal from the District Commission goes to the State Commission, and from the State Commission to the National Commission, without a separate pecuniary threshold for the appeal. The appellate commission hears the appeal because the order under appeal was passed by the commission below it, not because of the value.

Where the National Commission passes an order, an appeal lies to the Supreme Court. A writ petition before the Calcutta High Court is available against an order that is without jurisdiction, but it is not a substitute for the statutory appeal, and the High Court will usually say so.

Getting it right in Kolkata

Check the consideration, check where the opposite party carries on business, and check where the cause of action arose. Those three questions decide the forum. Then file through e-Daakhil with the fee that corresponds to the value, and state the value in the complaint.

If the opposite party objects to jurisdiction, the objection is decided on the plaint and the documents, not on oral evidence. A complaint that attaches the invoice and the agreement answers it before it is raised. Our consumer protection practice files in the correct forum from the start, and the RERA practice covers the parallel remedy for a delayed flat, where the choice of forum is itself a strategic question.

Common questions

Is the limit based on the claim or the purchase price?

The purchase price, meaning the value of the goods or services paid as consideration. The compensation claimed does not decide the forum.

Can I choose the National Commission for a small claim?

No. Jurisdiction is fixed by the value, and a commission cannot hear a complaint below or above its limit. Filing higher does not make the case important; it makes it returnable.

What if the price was paid in instalments?

The total consideration for the goods or services is the value, not each instalment. A flat bought on a payment plan is valued at the full price.

Does the builder's registered office decide the forum?

Not alone. The place where the cause of action arose, which for a flat is usually where the project is, is a valid forum. A company cannot insist on being sued only at its registered office.

Compute the value first, and the forum follows. If you are unsure whether your claim belongs in the District or the State Commission, send the papers; the fee schedule is published.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422