A RERA order directing a promoter to refund money or pay interest is enforced by the authority that made it, and a failure to comply is itself an offence under the Act. The buyer does not need to file a fresh civil suit, but the buyer does need to ask the authority to execute its own order. That step is the one most buyers miss: they receive the order, wait, and assume that it operates like a decree.
The enforcement machinery is real, and it works best while the promoter still has assets. Once the promoter is in insolvency, the order becomes a claim in the corporate process, and its value depends on the resolution plan.
The orders a buyer can obtain
The authority under section 31 may direct a refund of the amounts paid with interest, or interest for the period of delay, or compensation for the loss caused. The adjudicating officer appointed under the Act deals with compensation claims and quantifies them.
The order is a direction to the promoter, and it is binding. Where the promoter does not comply within the period stated, the Act provides a penalty, which can extend to imprisonment or fine, or both, and to a further penalty for every day of continuing default.
The order also attracts interest where the Act so provides, and the authority can direct payment of the interest accrued during the period of non-compliance.
The recovery route
- The buyer files a compliance application before the authority, attaching the order and stating that the direction has not been complied with.
- The authority issues notice to the promoter, and if the promoter does not show compliance, it certifies the amount due.
- The certified amount is recovered as an arrear of land revenue, which means the collector can attach and sell the promoter's property to realise it.
- The authority may also initiate proceedings for the offence of non-compliance, which puts personal pressure on the promoter's officers.
- Where the promoter is a company, the buyer may simultaneously pursue the insolvency route, and the certified amount becomes the claim.
The recovery is only as good as the assets. A certificate against a company with no property recovers nothing, and the buyer's time is better spent on the insolvency process, where the lenders and the other creditors are also present.
The appeal, and the stay
An appeal against an order of the authority lies to the Real Estate Appellate Tribunal within sixty days, with a possible extension on sufficient cause. The appeal does not automatically stay the order, and a stay has to be applied for and obtained.
A stay is usually granted on terms, including a deposit of part of the amount. A buyer who learns of an appeal should check whether a stay has been granted, because an order that is stayed cannot be executed until the appeal is decided.
Against the tribunal's order, a further appeal lies to the High Court, and the High Court's power of judicial review is also available. The grounds are narrow, and the appellate bodies do not ordinarily re-appreciate the evidence.
Personal liability of the promoter's officers
Where the promoter is a company, the Act's penal provisions can reach the persons in charge of its business, and the authority can proceed against them where the contravention was committed with their consent or connivance, or is attributable to their neglect.
That is often the only realistic pressure where the company has been emptied. A director who is personally exposed to prosecution is a director who is more likely to settle.
Interest, and how it accumulates
The interest on a refund runs from the date of the promoter's default to the date of payment, at the rate prescribed by the rules. On an order for interest for delay in possession, the interest runs month by month for the period of the delay.
Where the promoter does not pay after the order, the amount continues to attract interest, and the authority can compute it at the time of the compliance application. That accumulation is the reason a delayed enforcement is not always a loss: the order grows while it is unpaid.
Interim directions while the complaint is pending
The authority has power to pass interim orders during the pendency of a complaint, and those orders can be as valuable as the final one. In a delayed project, an interim direction restraining the promoter from alienating the unsold flats, or from transferring the project to another entity, preserves the assets against which the final order will be executed.
The same applies to the escrow account. Where the promoter has withdrawn money from the escrow in breach of the Act, an interim direction to restore it, or to freeze further withdrawals, keeps the project's funds where they can be used for construction. The application for interim relief should be made with the complaint, supported by the bank statements and the withdrawal records, rather than at the end of the case.
A promoter who ignores an interim direction is in the same position as one who ignores the final order, and the authority can proceed for the contravention. That pressure, applied early, sometimes produces a settlement before the complaint is heard.
What goes wrong
The buyer assumes the order is self-executing and waits a year. The promoter meanwhile transfers its assets, and the recovery finds nothing.
The buyer appeals against a part of the order that he did not like, and the whole order is held up. The appeal should be limited to what is genuinely wrong, and the rest should be enforced.
The buyer settles with the promoter for a fraction and signs a full and final settlement without checking whether the other allottees are affected. The settlement binds only the parties, but it can be used by the promoter to argue that the buyer accepted the project's position.
The Kolkata institutions
The West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority makes the orders and certifies the amounts. The Real Estate Appellate Tribunal hears the appeals. The collector of the district executes the recovery as an arrear of land revenue. The NCLT Kolkata bench handles the insolvency, and the Calcutta High Court hears the further appeals.
Our RERA practice handles the complaint and the compliance application, and the recovery practice deals with the execution where the amount has to be realised through the courts. Where the promoter is in insolvency, the insolvency practice files and pursues the claim.
Do I need a separate suit to enforce the order?
No, in the ordinary case. The authority enforces its own order, and the certified amount is recovered as an arrear of land revenue. A suit is needed only where the order is against a party outside the authority's jurisdiction, or where the buyer is claiming something the order did not cover.
Can the promoter's directors be held personally liable?
Where the contravention was committed with their consent or connivance, or is attributable to their neglect, the penal provisions can reach them. That is a matter for the authority's prosecution, and it is worth asking for where the company has no assets of its own.
What if the promoter appeals?
The appeal goes to the tribunal within sixty days, and the order is not stayed automatically. The buyer should check whether a stay has been granted and, if it has, whether it is conditional on a deposit. Where there is no stay, the compliance application can proceed while the appeal is pending.
For rera penalty enforcement, an order is a step, not a result. The buyer who files the compliance application within weeks of the order, and who keeps pressing it while the promoter still has something to lose, is the buyer who gets paid.