A cheque presented before the date it bears will be returned by the bank, and that return is not a dishonour on which a Section 138 complaint can be built. The statutory offence arises only when a cheque is returned unpaid for insufficiency of funds or because it exceeds the arrangement. A return for "post-dated" or "not yet valid" is a different thing altogether.
Three dates that govern every cheque
The date on the cheque, the date of presentation and the date of the bank's return memo are the three dates that decide whether a remedy exists. Under the Reserve Bank's clearing rules, a cheque is valid for presentment for three months from the date it bears. Present it before the date and the bank returns it as post-dated. Present it after three months and the bank returns it as stale or out of date. Neither return engages Section 138.
Between those two, the cheque is live. That window is the only period in which a presentation can produce a dishonour capable of supporting a notice and a complaint.
Why a post-dated cheque is given at all
A post-dated cheque is a promise with a date attached. It is given where the payer wants time: a balance payment on a property purchase, an instalment on a loan between private parties, a security for a supply arrangement. The payee accepts the cheque because it carries the drawer's signature and the threat of prosecution, which is stronger than a promissory note.
What the payee must understand is that the threat only exists if the cheque is presented correctly. Presenting it a week early, getting a return memo that says the instrument is post-dated, and then sending a notice, is a sequence that ends in a dismissal and sometimes in costs.
What the bank's return reason tells you
Read the memo before drafting anything. The return reason is printed in a code and an expression, and the code decides the legal consequence.
- Insufficient funds, or funds insufficient. This is the statutory ground, and the case is live.
- Exceeds arrangement. Also a statutory ground.
- Post-dated. No offence. The cheque is still valid and may be presented again on or after its date.
- Stale or out of date. No offence on this presentation. The instrument has lapsed and the remedy is civil.
- Stop payment. The drawer has instructed the bank not to pay. Courts treat this as within the section, because the drawer has prevented payment, and the notice should say so.
- Account closed. Also treated as within the section, because closing the account to defeat a cheque is the clearest case of the drawer's intent.
- Signature mismatch or alteration. Usually outside the section, because the bank has not refused for want of funds. The remedy is a civil claim or, where forgery is alleged, a criminal complaint of a different kind.
Where the return reason is one of the last three, the file needs a different strategy. Presenting again on the same cheque will produce the same memo.
The premature presentment problem in practice
The mistake usually happens because the payee's office presents all cheques in a monthly batch, or because a clerk reads the date wrongly. The damage is done when the payee, seeing a return memo, sends a notice reciting that the cheque was dishonoured for insufficiency. The drawer replies, correctly, that the cheque was not due. The complaint that follows is dismissed, and the payee has also given the drawer a warning to keep the account empty.
There is a further problem. Where the premature presentment was made to create a cause of action, courts have taken a dim view, because the payee manufactured the dishonour. That is a finding that damages credibility on everything else in the case.
Presenting correctly, and what to do if the date falls badly
Present the cheque on or after the date it bears, and within the three-month window. Where the date on the cheque is a Sunday or a bank holiday, present on the next working day. Where the payee wants to preserve the criminal remedy and the drawer asks for more time, the better course is a fresh cheque with the later date rather than an oral extension of the old one.
Where the drawer has asked the payee to hold the cheque, that request should be recorded in writing. Courts have accepted that a cheque delivered as security may be presented when the obligation it secures is not met, even if the date on the cheque has passed, provided the cheque is still within its three-month validity when presented. Beyond three months, the instrument is dead and only a civil claim survives. A written record of that arrangement is best made through a notice drafted for the purpose, as our legal notice drafting page explains.
The civil claim that runs alongside
Even where the criminal route is lost, the debt remains. A suit for recovery on the underlying transaction has a three-year limitation from the date the amount became due, and the cheque is evidence of the acknowledgement of liability. Where the cheque itself is time-barred, the payee should look at whether any later acknowledgement or part payment extends the limitation on the debt.
A summary suit under Order XXXVII of the Code of Civil Procedure is available where the claim is based on a written contract or a cheque, and it shifts the burden onto the defendant to seek leave to defend. Our page on recovery suits explains that route, which is often faster than a cheque prosecution in any event.
The notice after a valid presentment
Once the cheque is properly dishonoured, the thirty-day window for the notice opens from receipt of the return memo. The notice must demand the cheque amount and give fifteen days. Where the cheque was post-dated and presented on its date, the notice should recite the date of the cheque, the date of presentment and the memo, so that the sequence is beyond argument.
The complaint is then filed within one month of the cause of action, at the court where the payee's bank branch is situated. For a payee banking in Kolkata, that is the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall or the appropriate district court. The trial that follows is described under cheque bounce.
Common questions
Can a post-dated cheque be presented early with the drawer's consent?
Consent does not change the bank's clearing rules. The bank will return it as post-dated, and the return will not support a Section 138 complaint. Consent is not a substitute for presentment on the date.
What if the cheque is dated three months ahead?
Then it must be held until that date, and presented within three months of it. A cheque dated far in the future is a poor instrument, because the drawer has a long time in which to close the account, and the payee has no remedy in the meantime.
Does a "stop payment" instruction by the drawer amount to dishonour?
Yes. Courts treat a drawer who stops payment as having prevented the cheque from being honoured, and the offence is made out. The notice should state the fact of the stop-payment instruction, which the payee can learn from the return memo.
Is a cheque without a date valid?
An undated cheque is incomplete, and the person who fills in the date must have authority to do so. Where the payee inserts a date without authority, the drawer has a defence that the instrument was materially altered. The safe practice is to insist on a date at the time of issue.
Post-dated cheques are a legitimate instrument and a poor substitute for security. A payee who diaries the date, presents within the window, keeps the memo and reads the return code before sending a notice will find that the cheque does the work it was meant to do.