14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Recovery & Cheque Bounce

Stop Payment Instructions and the Dishonour That Follows

A drawer who telephones his bank and stops payment on a cheque he has already issued has not escaped the cheque. The cheque will be returned with the remark "payment stopped by drawer", and that return is treated as a dishonour within Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881, provided the underlying debt existed and the stop payment was not justified. The instruction is a right against the bank; it is not a defence to the payee.

The drawer's right, and its limits

A cheque is a mandate to the bank to pay. The customer may revoke the mandate before the cheque is paid, and the bank must then refuse payment. This is an ordinary contractual right, and a bank that pays after a valid stop payment instruction does so at its own risk as against the customer.

The right is against the bank, not against the holder. Stopping payment does not cancel the debt, and it does not cancel the cheque as an instrument. The payee's remedy under Section 138 remains, because the cheque was returned unpaid and the drawer's own act caused it.

Courts have taken the view that a stop payment without reasonable cause is a dishonour within the section, since the drawer cannot be allowed to defeat the statute by his own instruction. Where the drawer had a genuine and subsisting dispute about the transaction, the position is different: the stop payment is evidence of the dispute, and the case may fail for want of a legally enforceable debt rather than for want of a dishonour.

The reason code on the memo

The return memo will show "payment stopped by drawer" or a corresponding code. That is the document to preserve. It establishes both the dishonour and its cause, and it is more useful than a return for insufficient funds because it identifies the drawer's own act rather than his bank balance.

Ask the bank for a certificate under the Bankers' Books Evidence Act recording the stop payment instruction, its date and the person who gave it. The instruction itself, if the bank will disclose it, shows whether it came from the drawer or from someone purporting to act for him. That matters where the drawer denies having stopped payment.

When the defence holds

The defence holds where the drawer can show a real reason to countermand. The commonest is that the goods were never supplied, or were rejected, or that the work was not done. Another is that the cheque was given as an advance against a contract that the payee then abandoned. A third is that the cheque was issued by mistake, or under a misapprehension about the amount.

In each case the drawer must produce something beyond his own statement. The correspondence about the defective goods, the inspection report, the email in which the payee agreed to hold the cheque, the return of the material: these are what make a probable defence. A drawer who says only that he stopped payment because the deal went sour, without a document, is unlikely to displace the presumption under Section 139.

There is a further point of timing. If the drawer stopped payment before the payee presented the cheque, and told the payee why, the payee's decision to present it anyway is not itself wrongful, but it weakens any suggestion of surprise. If the drawer stopped payment silently and let the payee present it, the conduct looks like an attempt to create a defence after the fact.

The payee's sequence after a stop payment

  1. Collect the returned cheque and the memo showing the reason.
  2. Obtain the bank certificate recording the return and the stop payment.
  3. Serve the demand notice within thirty days of the return, stating the debt and giving fifteen days to pay.
  4. If payment does not come, file the complaint within one month after the fifteen-day period.
  5. In the complaint, plead the stop payment specifically and attach the memo and the certificate.

Where the drawer has also closed the account, or where the stop payment was followed by a transfer of assets, the civil suit for recovery should be filed at the same time. A criminal court can order compensation, but a decree is the instrument for attaching property.

Consequences for the drawer beyond the criminal case

A wrongful stop payment is a breach of the drawer's obligation on the instrument. The payee can sue on the debt, and in an appropriate case on the cheque itself as a negotiable instrument. Interest and costs follow the decree.

The drawer may also face consequences with his bank. Stopping payment repeatedly, or issuing cheques without funds, can lead the bank to close the account or to report the conduct. Those are commercial consequences rather than legal ones, but they are real, and they affect a business that depends on cheque collection.

For a company drawer, Section 141 brings the persons in charge into the case. A director who authorised the stop payment is in a weaker position than one who knew nothing of it, and the complaint should say which is which.

Where a genuine dispute belongs

If the real complaint is that the goods were defective or the work incomplete, Section 138 is the wrong forum for that dispute. The drawer should raise it in the reply to the notice and in the defence, and if he has a claim of his own he should file it rather than wait to be sued. A counterclaim in the payee's recovery suit, or a separate suit for damages for breach of contract, is the orderly route.

The criminal court will not decide the quality of the goods. It will decide whether the cheque was issued for a debt and whether the dishonour was without justification. A drawer whose dispute is genuine but undocumented often loses the criminal case and wins nothing in the civil one, because he never filed.

Running it from Kolkata

The complaint is filed where the payee's bank branch is located, which for most Kolkata payees means the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate's court at Bankshall. The civil suit goes to the City Civil Court at Kolkata or to the Calcutta High Court's original side, depending on value. Both can proceed together, and any compensation received in the criminal case is adjusted against the decree.

A stop payment case is often stronger than an insufficiency case at the threshold, because the drawer's own act is documented. It is weaker at the trial stage if the drawer has a real dispute. The payee's advocate should read the drawer's reply to the notice carefully before deciding how much of the case to rest on the memo. Our cheque bounce practice handles both the criminal and the civil side, and the breach of contract notice route is the alternative where the dispute is really about performance.

Common questions

Is stopping payment a criminal offence by itself?

No. It is a contractual right. The offence, if any, arises when the cheque is returned unpaid and the other elements of Section 138 are satisfied despite the stop payment.

Can the bank be sued for paying despite a stop payment?

The drawer may have a claim against the bank for breach of mandate, but the payee receives the money and the debt is discharged. The drawer's remedy against the bank does not undo the payment.

What if the stop payment was given by an employee without authority?

Then the drawer's defence is that he never authorised it. The bank's record of who gave the instruction becomes the deciding document, and the payee should obtain it early.

Does the fifteen-day notice period still apply?

Yes. The notice, the fifteen days and the one-month filing period apply to every dishonour, whatever the reason recorded on the memo.

Stop payment is a manoeuvre, not a defence. Document the return, serve the notice on time, and decide early whether the case is a cheque case or a contract case. If you are on either side, contact our office; the consultation fees are published.

Looking for a Kolkata law firm? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422