14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Property in a minor's name: the guardian's limits

A minor can own property, and a sale deed in a minor's name is valid and registrable. What a minor cannot do is contract, and what a guardian cannot do is sell that property without the court's permission. Property in minor name transactions therefore involve two separate legal persons in one document: the minor as owner, and the guardian as the person who signs and who must answer to the court for what he does with it.

The purchase side is straightforward. The sale side is where the problems are, and the problems appear years later, when the child has grown up and finds that the plot was sold when he was nine.

Buying in a minor's name

The deed is executed in the minor's name, with the guardian signing on his behalf and reciting the guardianship. The sub-registrar will want the minor's date of birth proof — the birth certificate, or the school record where the certificate is not available — the guardian's identity documents, and the relationship. Where the guardian is the mother, the deed should recite the father's position: dead, or absent from the care of the minor's person and property, which is the ground on which the mother acts as natural guardian.

The consideration should be paid from the minor's own funds where the property is genuinely the minor's, and from the guardian's funds where the guardian is making a gift. A purchase in the minor's name with the guardian's money is a settlement, and it invites the argument that the property is held benami for the guardian. That argument has become sharper since the benami legislation was amended, and the position on transactions of different dates should be checked rather than assumed.

Selling a minor's property

Section 8 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 bars the natural guardian from selling, mortgaging, exchanging or leasing the minor's immovable property without the previous permission of the District Court, and section 29 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 imposes the same requirement on a court-appointed guardian. In Kolkata the District Court for the city is the City Civil Court, and the application is made there; in the districts it goes to the court at Alipore or Barasat.

The application must show necessity: the minor's education, medical treatment, the discharge of a debt secured on the property that threatens it, or the minor's contribution to a partition. It must be supported by the title documents, the valuation, the proposed deed, the minor's other assets, and the no-objection of the other heirs where the property is joint.

Where permission is granted, the order usually fixes a minimum price and directs the investment of the minor's share in a fixed deposit or in property for the minor. The guardian must then file an account. A sale at a price below the sanctioned figure, or proceeds spent on the guardian's business, is a breach of the order and a ground for removal.

The contract problem

Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 makes a contract by a minor void. An agreement to sell signed by a guardian on the minor's behalf does not bind the minor, and the buyer cannot sue for specific performance against the minor on the strength of it. What the buyer can do is sue the guardian personally if the guardian warranted his authority, which is a poor substitute for the land.

The practical consequence is that a buyer should not pay a substantial advance against an agreement signed for a minor. The money should follow the court's permission, and the deed should be executed after the order is on the file.

Mutation, taxation and the record

The record of rights should show the minor as the owner, with the guardian named as the person competent to act. An entry that shows only the father's name creates a title defect when the property is later sold, because the record does not disclose the minor's interest at all.

For income tax, section 64(1A) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 clumps the income of a minor with that of the parent who has the greater income, with exceptions for income from the minor's own skill, talent or manual work and for a minor with a disability. Rental income from a flat held in the minor's name is therefore usually taxed in the parent's hands, and the parent should not treat the minor as a separate assessee without checking the provision.

The minor's own PAN is required for the registration and for the bank account into which the consideration is paid, and a minor can hold a PAN and a bank account through the guardian.

Attaining majority

On attaining eighteen the minor becomes competent to deal with the property, and the guardian's authority ends. Under the Guardians and Wards Act the minority may continue beyond eighteen where a guardian of the property has been appointed by the court, and the order should be read for the exact date.

The newly major owner is entitled to an account from the guardian, and to the documents. A guardian who cannot produce the account, or who has sold without permission, faces a suit for rendition of accounts and for setting aside the transfer.

A sale executed shortly before the minor attains majority, at a price that looks low, is examined closely in such a suit, and the purchaser's position is weaker where he was connected to the guardian.

What goes wrong

The first failure is a deed that recites the father as guardian when the father has died and no one has recorded the mother's guardianship. The registration is accepted, but the title is questioned at the next sale.

The second is a sale by the mother after the father's death, without the court's permission, on the understanding that as natural guardian she may act. She may not, and the transfer is voidable by the child.

The third is the money. The consideration is paid into the guardian's account and spent, and the child's remedy is against the guardian, who may have nothing left.

Can parents buy property in a minor's name?

Yes. The deed is executed in the minor's name and the guardian signs for the minor. The purchase is valid, and the property belongs to the minor, not to the parents, from the date of registration.

Can the parents sell it later?

Only with the permission of the District Court, and only for the minor's benefit or necessity. A sale without permission is voidable at the minor's instance, and the purchaser's money is at risk.

Is the minor's rental income taxed separately?

Usually not. Section 64(1A) clumps the minor's income with the parent's, subject to the statutory exceptions. The computation should be made with the parent's return rather than on a separate assessment.

What happens when the minor turns eighteen?

The minor becomes competent to deal with the property and to demand an account from the guardian. Where the court appointed a guardian of the property, the minority may continue beyond eighteen under the Guardians and Wards Act, and the appointment order should be checked.

The court permission is the pivot of every minor's property sale, and it should be obtained before any money moves. Our guardianship practice prepares the application and the account, the registration team handles the deed and the mutation, and the property law team advises on the title. Begin at our contact page.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422