Property in company name belongs to the company and not to its shareholders or directors, and that single principle decides most of the disputes that arise when a flat or a plot is held by a private limited company. The company is a separate legal person; it can buy, hold, mortgage and sell property in its own name; and its directors cannot treat the asset as their own, whatever the shareholding. A transfer out of the company requires a properly authorised decision, a validly executed deed, the correct stamp duty and a registration, and the buyer needs to see the corporate record before he pays.
Who can sign, and on what authority
A deed executed by a company must be signed by a person authorised by a resolution of the board of directors, and the resolution should be produced to the sub-registrar and kept with the deed. The articles of association usually authorise the board to deal with the company's property, and the board resolution identifies the signatory and the terms of the sale. Where the signatory is not a director, a specific power of attorney, executed under the company's seal and duly stamped and registered, is needed.
Where the property is the whole or substantially the whole of the company's undertaking, Section 180 of the Companies Act, 2013 requires the approval of the shareholders by special resolution, in addition to the board resolution. A sale of the company's only valuable asset without that approval is vulnerable, and the buyer's advocate should ask for the special resolution and the filing made with the Registrar of Companies.
The searches a buyer must run
- The certificate of incorporation, the memorandum and the articles, and the latest annual return, from the records of the Registrar of Companies on the MCA portal.
- The register of charges, to see whether the property is mortgaged or hypothecated to a bank or a lender; a charge registered against the company can bind the property even where the buyer has no notice.
- The board resolution, and the special resolution where Section 180 applies, with the corresponding filings.
- The property documents: the title deed in the company's name, the khatian, the municipal assessment, the sanctioned plan and the tax receipts.
- The sub-registrar's search for the property, and the litigation record, including any proceeding before the NCLT Kolkata bench.
A charge on the MCA portal is the item buyers most often miss. A company that has borrowed against the property will show a charge in its index of charges, and a sale without the lender's no-objection and the satisfaction of the charge leaves the buyer with a mortgaged asset.
Stamp duty on the conveyance
When the company conveys the property to a buyer, the duty is the conveyance duty computed on the market value, exactly as for an individual seller. There is no relief for a company seller, and there is no exemption because the buyer is a director or a shareholder. The deed is registered in the usual way, and the mutation follows.
A different structure is sometimes used: the buyer purchases the shares of the company instead of the property, and thereby controls the asset without a conveyance. The stamp duty on a share transfer is much lower than on a conveyance, which is why the structure is popular, but the buyer then takes the company with all its liabilities, known and unknown, including tax demands, litigation and statutory dues. The saving in duty has to be weighed against the cost of the due diligence that the structure requires.
Buying the shares is buying the company. The flat comes with the company's history, and the history is what the buyer did not price.
Related party transfers and the valuation
A transfer between a company and its director, or between two companies with common directors, is a related party transaction, and Section 188 of the Companies Act, 2013 requires the approval of the board and, in some cases, of the shareholders by ordinary resolution, with the interested party abstaining. The transaction must also be at arm's length for tax purposes, and the income tax law on transfer pricing and on the fair value of the property applies.
The registering authority will assess the duty on the market value even where the transfer is between related parties at a nominal price. A gift or a transfer at less than the market value can also attract the provisions on deemed income in the hands of the recipient, and the buyer should take tax advice before the deed is drawn.
When the company is in insolvency
If the company is in corporate insolvency resolution before the NCLT Kolkata bench, the sale of its property requires the approval of the resolution professional and the committee of creditors, and the moratorium under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 restricts any transfer. A buyer who purchases from a company in moratorium faces a transaction that can be set aside.
A company that has been struck off from the register presents a different problem: its property vests in the state on dissolution, and a sale by the former directors has no authority. The buyer must check the company's status on the MCA portal before the deed.
Common questions
Can a director sell the company's flat as if it were his own?
No. The flat belongs to the company, and the director has no title to convey. A sale by a director without a board resolution and a deed executed by the company is void, and the buyer's remedy is against the director personally.
Can I buy a company's property if the company is dormant?
Yes, provided the company is active on the MCA records, the board and, where needed, the shareholders have approved the sale, and the signatory is authorised. A dormant or struck-off company needs to be restored before it can convey property, and the buyer should not complete until the status is regular.
Is the stamp duty different for a company?
No, the conveyance duty is the same. A company buying property pays the same duty as an individual, and a company selling receives no relief. The duty is on the market value, and the registering authority will assess it.
What about the property tax and the municipal record?
The municipal assessment will be in the company's name, and the transfer must be recorded with the corporation or the municipality as well as with the revenue authority. The mutation of the land and the change of the assessment are separate steps, and both should be completed, because a buyer who leaves the assessment in the seller's name inherits the arrears.
Read the corporate record before the property record, because the company's authority to sell is the first question and the title is the second. Our corporate practice reviews the resolutions, the charges and the MCA filings, and the registration team handles the deed and the mutation. Where the company is in insolvency, the insolvency team advises on the moratorium and the approvals.