A lease of immovable property for a year or more must be registered, and it should also be recorded in the record of rights. Registration proves the instrument; the record of rights proves the right. A lessee who has only the first is exposed to a purchaser who buys the land without notice of the lease, to a mortgagee who lends against it, and to a revenue office that continues to treat the lessor as the sole holder.
Two documents, two offices. The lease deed goes to the sub-registrar, who registers it and returns a certified copy. The application to record the lease goes to the Block Land and Land Reforms Officer, who enters the lease in the khatian so that anyone searching the record sees it.
What the statutes require
Section 107 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 requires a lease of immovable property for a term exceeding one year to be made by a registered instrument. A lease for a shorter term may be made orally, or by an unregistered writing, but even then the terms must be provable. Section 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 makes registration compulsory for a lease of immovable property for a term exceeding one year, and section 49 makes an unregistered document inadmissible to prove the lease.
Recording in the record of rights is a separate obligation, and it arises under the land reforms law and the rules that govern the maintenance of the record. It is not automatic. The sub-registrar does not inform the block office, and the block office does not update the khatian because a deed was registered somewhere else.
Why the gap matters
A lease is a right in the land, and a right that is not on the record is a right that the next buyer will not see. The buyer's advocate searches the registration office for the deeds of the last thirty years and the revenue record for the current holder. If the lease is registered, the search finds it. If it is registered but not recorded, the search finds it in the registration index but the khatian still shows the lessor in possession, and the buyer may assume the land is free.
The consequences are practical and expensive.
- A purchaser without notice of the lease may take the land free of it in the circumstances the law allows, and the lessee is left to sue for damages rather than to remain in possession.
- A bank asked to lend against the land will not accept a lease that is not on the record, because its security is uncertain.
- Compensation for acquisition is assessed with reference to the recorded interests, and an unrecorded lessee may not receive the notice that the recorded holder receives.
- The lessee cannot obtain a trade licence, an electricity connection or a municipal mutation of the premises without a document that the authority treats as proof of the tenancy.
The eleven-month device, and why it often fails
Leases are frequently drawn for eleven months, to avoid registration and stamp duty. The device works only if the arrangement is genuinely a short lease. Where the deed contains a renewal clause, an option to extend, or a rent that is stated annually, the courts have treated the document as a lease for a longer term, and the registration requirement revives.
Even an eleven-month lease should be recorded. The term is short, but the consequences of a dispute are not, and a tenant who has paid a deposit and invested in fittings needs a document that a court will accept.
How to record the lease
- The lease deed is executed on the stamp paper of the value required by the schedule in force, and presented for registration at the sub-registrar's office within the period allowed by the Registration Act.
- The sub-registrar registers the deed, and the parties receive the certified copy with the endorsement. In West Bengal this is handled through the e-Nathikaran system and the appointment at the office.
- An application is filed with the BL&LRO of the block where the land lies, asking for the lease to be recorded in the khatian, with the certified copy of the deed, the current record of rights and the proof of possession.
- Notice issues to the recorded holder, and the amin verifies the plot and the possession.
- An order is passed recording the lease, and the khatian is updated. Where the lease covers part of a plot, a separate khatian or a sub-division may be required.
- The certified copy of the updated record is obtained, and it becomes the document the lessee produces thereafter.
Stamp duty on a lease
Stamp duty on a lease is computed on the rent and the premium, under the schedule to the state stamp law. A lease with a premium and an annual rent attracts duty on both, and a lease for a long term may attract duty computed on the total rent for the term, subject to the cap in the schedule. The rates are revised by notification, and the current schedule should be checked at the time of execution rather than taken from an earlier deed.
The same applies to the registration fee, which is separate from the stamp duty and is computed on the value of the instrument. An under-stamped deed is not a nullity, but it is inadmissible until the deficit and the penalty are paid, and the sub-registrar will refer it to the collector for adjudication.
Agricultural leases and barga rights
For agricultural land the position is different, and more protective of the cultivator. A bargadar recorded under the land reforms law has a right that is not extinguished by a transfer of the land, and the recording is made by the block office on the application of the bargadar or on the officer's own enquiry.
A lease of agricultural land for a term exceeding one year must be registered like any other lease, and it should be recorded so that the lessee's possession is protected. A buyer who ignores the barga register buys a dispute, and the dispute is not resolved by the sale deed.
What the record does not do
Recording a lease does not validate it. If the lease is void — because the lessor had no title, or because the land is vested in the State, or because the term exceeds what the law allows for the class of land — the entry does not cure the defect. The record is evidence of the right claimed, not a guarantee of it.
Nor does the record protect a lessee against the lessor's own obligations. A lessee who has not paid rent can be evicted under the lease and under the tenancy law, and the entry in the khatian is not a defence to that.
The Kolkata offices
For land in Kolkata and the adjoining districts, the sub-registrar's offices handle registration, and the BL&LRO of the block handles the record. For urban premises, the tenancy is also regulated by the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, which governs eviction and the rights of the tenant in a municipal area, and a lease of such premises has to satisfy both the transfer of property law and that Act.
Our property registration practice handles the deed and the registration, and the landlord and tenant practice deals with the disputes that follow. Where the premises are commercial and the tenant has made a substantial investment, the property law practice advises on how the lease should be drafted so that the recorded right matches the commercial bargain.
Is an eleven-month lease valid without registration?
Yes, a lease for eleven months does not require registration, and an unregistered writing can be used to prove the terms in a limited way. The risk is that the document cannot be used to establish the lease if the other side objects, and the tenant is then thrown back on oral evidence and conduct. Record it in the khatian anyway, and keep the rent receipts.
What happens if the landlord sells the land?
A registered lease binds the purchaser, because the purchaser is fixed with notice through the registration. An unregistered lease for a term of more than a year does not, and the tenant's remedy is against the former landlord for breach, not against the buyer for possession. That is the single strongest reason to register and record.
Can a lease be recorded years after it was signed?
Yes, the recording can be applied for at any time while the lease subsists, and the delay does not by itself defeat the application. What the delay affects is the position against a purchaser who bought in the meantime without notice, and the office may require evidence of continuous possession to satisfy itself that the lease is genuine.
The rule is simple and often ignored: register the deed, then record the right. The first protects the terms, the second protects the possession, and a lease that has only one of the two is a lease that will be tested at the worst possible moment.