14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Civil Procedure

Review versus revision: two powers, two courts

A review asks the same court that passed the order to look at it again, and it lies only on the grounds the Code allows. A revision asks the High Court to examine whether a subordinate court has exercised a jurisdiction it does not have, failed to exercise one it has, or acted illegally or with material irregularity. The two are different remedies, in different courts, on different grounds, and choosing the wrong one wastes the limitation period.

Review: the ground and the court

The Code of Civil Procedure permits a court to review its own judgement or order on three grounds: the discovery of new and important matter or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence, was not within the applicant's knowledge or could not be produced at the time; some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; or any other sufficient reason.

An error apparent on the face of the record is not the same as an error of law that requires argument to establish. If the point requires a long-drawn process of reasoning, it is a ground for appeal, not for review. That distinction is where most review applications fail.

The application is made to the same court, ordinarily by the same judge who passed the order, and it must be filed within the time the statute allows, with the delay condoned only on a proper explanation. The applicant must also show that he has not already appealed; where an appeal has been filed and dismissed on the merits, a review is not ordinarily available.

The court that reviews may affirm, vary or reverse its order. A review is a substantial power and is exercised with care, because it is not an opportunity to reargue the case.

Revision: the ground and the court

A revision lies to the High Court against an order of a subordinate court, where the subordinate court has exercised a jurisdiction not vested in it, has failed to exercise a jurisdiction so vested, or has acted in the exercise of its jurisdiction illegally or with material irregularity. That is the statutory formulation, and it is narrower than an appeal.

The High Court does not re-appreciate evidence in revision, and it does not interfere with an order merely because it would have decided the matter differently. It interferes where the subordinate court has gone wrong on jurisdiction or has committed an error that goes to the root of the matter.

There is also a bar: a revision is not entertained where the applicant has a right of appeal, or where an appeal lies to another court and has not been decided. So a party who could have appealed but chose to file a revision will usually find the petition dismissed at the threshold. Where the revision is against an order in a small-value case in which no appeal lies, the bar does not apply, and the revision is the only route.

Limitation for a revision is fixed by the Limitation Act and is short. The petition is filed in the Calcutta High Court on the appellate side for orders of the City Civil Court and the district courts, with a certified copy of the order and of the judgement, and the High Court may call for the records of the lower court.

How to choose

Ask four questions in order:

  1. Is there an error apparent on the face of the record, discoverable without argument? If yes, a review is available to the same court.
  2. Does an appeal lie against the order? If yes, the remedy is the appeal, and a revision will be dismissed on the bar.
  3. If no appeal lies, has the subordinate court gone wrong on jurisdiction or in a manner amounting to an illegal exercise of it? If yes, a revision.
  4. Is the order altogether outside the court's power, and is there no other remedy? A writ petition under the constitutional jurisdiction may be considered, though it is not a substitute for the statutory remedy.

Where both a review and an appeal could be pursued, the practice is to file the appeal and, if the appeal fails, to consider a review on a ground that was not and could not have been argued. Running a review and an appeal simultaneously invites an objection.

The other remedies in the same family

A restoration application asks the court that dismissed a suit or an application for default to restore it. An appeal goes to the higher court on the merits and on law. A writ petition invokes the High Court's constitutional jurisdiction against a court or an authority, and it is available where another remedy is inadequate, though the courts insist that the statutory remedies be exhausted first.

An application under the Code's review provision, an appeal under the Code's provisions on first appeal and second appeal, and a revision — these are the three statutory routes in the Code, and each has its own limitation and its own forum.

The limitation period does not wait while you work out the right remedy. In an urgent matter, file the one that is most clearly available and explain the choice in the application.

Practical points in the Kolkata courts

A review application in the City Civil Court is filed before the same court that passed the order, and the registry will place it before that judge. A revision against an order of the City Civil Court or a district court in Alipore or Barasat goes to the Calcutta High Court on the appellate side, where the certified copy, the grounds and the synopsis are filed and the matter is listed.

Both remedies require the certified copy of the order and the judgement. Obtaining it takes time, and the applicant should apply for it immediately on the order, because the limitation runs from the date of the order and not from the date the copy is delivered in every case.

Common questions

Can a review be filed after an appeal is dismissed?

Ordinarily no, where the appeal was decided on the merits. A review after an appeal on the merits is barred by the rule that merger in the appellate decision forecloses it, though a review of a point not decided in the appeal is a different question.

Can a revision be filed against an interim order?

Yes, where the conditions are met and no appeal lies. Revisions against interlocutory orders are entertained sparingly, because interlocutory correction can be sought in the appeal that finally follows.

Does a revision stay the lower court's order?

Filing a revision does not automatically stay the order. A separate application for stay is needed, and the High Court may grant it on such terms as it thinks fit.

Read the order first and see whether the error is on the face of it or requires argument to establish. Our civil litigation practice handles reviews and revisions in the Kolkata courts, and writ petitions covers the constitutional remedy where it is the only route. If the underlying claim is a money demand, the enforcement route is set out under recovery of money.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Civil Procedure

The Stages of a Civil Suit in Kolkata

From the plaint and summons through issues, evidence and judgement to execution, the stages of a civil suit in a Kolkata court and what each costs in time.

Read
Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422