14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Family Law

Daughters and widows after the 2005 succession amendment

The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 made a daughter of a coparcener a coparcener by birth, with the same rights and liabilities as a son, and it removed two provisions that had restricted women: the daughter's limited right of residence in the family dwelling, and the widow's disability on remarriage. The Supreme Court has since held that the daughter's right is by birth, so it applies even where the father died before the amendment came into force, provided the daughter was alive on the date of commencement.

Those two changes reorganised the arithmetic of every Hindu family partition in the state. The shares that were computed in 2000 are no longer the shares that are computed today.

What the position was before 2005

A daughter was an heir in her father's separate property, but she was not a coparcener in the joint family property. On a partition among the sons, she took nothing from the coparcenary, though she had a right of maintenance and a restricted right of residence in the family dwelling.

The widow was a Class I heir in her husband's separate property, and on a partition among the coparceners she was entitled to a share equal to a son's under the traditional rule. Her rights were real, but they were understood as rights derived from her husband rather than as rights of her own.

What section 6 now says

Section 6(1) provides that in a joint family governed by the Mitakshara law, the daughter of a coparcener is a coparcener by birth, in her own right, in the same manner as a son, and has the same rights and liabilities as a son, including the right to claim partition and the right to dispose of her share by will.

Section 6(3) contains the proviso that protects certain dispositions: a partition or a disposition by will, or a transfer for consideration, made before the twentieth day of December 2004, is not affected by the amendment. Section 6(4) provides that no court shall recognise any right to proceed against a daughter, or to dispose of her share, on the ground that she was not a coparcener.

The proviso is the point of most litigation. A partition deed executed in 2003, with the daughters excluded, is protected if it was registered and acted upon. A will made in 2003 that disinherits a daughter is more complicated, because the father's power to dispose of his own interest by will is recognised, but the coparcenary interest is not his to give away entirely.

The Vineeta Sharma principle

The Supreme Court's decision in Vineeta Sharma v Rakesh Sharma settled the question that had divided the courts: whether the daughter's right depends on the father being alive on the date of the amendment. The Court held that the right is by birth, and that the father's death before the amendment does not defeat it, provided the daughter was alive on the date of commencement.

The Court also addressed the computation. The daughter's share is worked out by a notional partition of the coparcenary as on the date of the father's death, and the daughter takes the share she would have taken if the partition had taken place then. That method has consequences for the shares of the widow and the sons, and it is the method that the revenue offices and the courts now apply.

The widow's position

The widow remains a Class I heir in her husband's property, and on a partition among the coparceners she is entitled to a share equal to a son's. The amendment did not reduce that right; it increased the number of shares by making the daughters coparceners, and it removed the provision that had curtailed her rights on remarriage.

Section 14 gives her absolute ownership of property acquired as a widow, whether by inheritance, by a maintenance grant or by a partition. That property is hers to deal with, and it does not revert to the family on her death.

The repeal of the old section 23 removed the restriction on a daughter's right to reside in the family dwelling, and the repeal of the old section 24 removed the widow's disqualification on remarriage. Both repeals apply to the devolution of property after the amendment, and the position for earlier devolutions is governed by the law as it stood.

The practical consequences

  • Every mutation that records only the sons is defective, and can be corrected at any time by the daughter.
  • A partition deed that excludes a daughter is vulnerable unless it falls within the 2004 saving.
  • A sale by the sons of the whole property without the daughter joining conveys only their shares.
  • A daughter can claim partition of the ancestral property in her own right, and can dispose of her share by will.
  • The widow's share is equal to a son's, and it is her absolute property.

The traps

The first is the old partition. Families rely on a deed from before 2004 that divided the property among the sons. Whether it is protected depends on the date, the registration and whether it was acted upon, and the saving is construed strictly.

The second is the will. A father who made a will in the 1990s leaving everything to his sons may have exercised a power that the amendment later restricted, and the will's effect on the coparcenary interest is a question of some difficulty.

The third is the mutation record. A khatian that has recorded the sons for twenty years is not evidence that the daughter has no right; it is evidence that the mutation was done without her, and the correction is available.

How the claim is made

  1. A partition suit joining all the coparceners, with a prayer for the shares to be determined under the amended section 6.
  2. A suit for declaration where the property has already been sold or mutated, with consequential relief against the purchasers.
  3. A mutation application to correct the record, which is useful but does not decide the share.
  4. An injunction where a sale is threatened, to preserve the property while the share is determined.

The Kolkata courts

The partition suit goes to the City Civil Court at Kolkata or the district court at Alipore or Barasat, and the mutation application to the BL&LRO. The probate of the father's will goes to the Calcutta High Court's original side where it falls within that jurisdiction.

Our partition practice works out the shares under the amended section, and the property law practice handles the mutation correction. Where the dispute turns on a will, the succession practice deals with the probate.

Does a daughter inherit equally with her brother?

In her father's separate property, yes, as a Class I heir, and each takes one share along with the widow. In the coparcenary property, she is a coparcener by birth and takes the same share as a son. The two rights are different in origin but they now produce broadly the same result in most families.

What if the father died before 2005?

The daughter's right survives, provided she was alive on the date of the amendment. The Supreme Court has held that the right is by birth and does not depend on the father being alive at the commencement. The share is worked out by a notional partition as on the date of the father's death.

Can a widow remarry and keep her share?

Yes. The provision that disqualified a widow on remarriage was repealed in 2005, and the position for devolutions after the amendment is that remarriage does not deprive her of the property she has inherited or taken on partition. For earlier devolutions, the law as it then stood applies.

The daughter widow succession 2005 amendment is twenty years old and still produces surprises, because the records were made before it and the families have never revisited them. The share a daughter is entitled to is not a matter of family goodwill; it is a matter of the record, and the record can be corrected.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422