14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Sale of parking spaces: what RERA and the courts settled

Open parking is part of the common areas and the common facilities, and it cannot be sold as a separate unit in addition to the flat. Covered parking, in a defined bay with a boundary, may be allotted and charged for, but only where the sanctioned plan and the RERA disclosure provide for it and the agreement for sale records the allotment. A developer who charges separately for an open space in the compound, or for parking that is not on the sanctioned plan, is charging for something he does not own.

The distinction is not a technicality. It decides whether the buyer has paid for a right or for nothing, and it decides whether the society can allot the same bay to someone else after the sale.

Where parking sits in the statutory scheme

The Act defines carpet area as the net usable area of the apartment, and it defines common areas to include the land, the common portions of the building, the lobbies, the staircases, the lifts, the common areas of the basement and the service areas. Parking that falls within those common areas is common property, and common property belongs to all the allottees together.

The application for registration under section 4 must disclose the number of parking spaces, the plan showing them, and the manner in which they are to be allotted. The agreement for sale under section 13 must record what the allottee is getting, including any parking allotted, and the price attributable to it.

Those two disclosures are the buyer's protection. If the parking is not in the plan, it is not authorised; if it is not in the agreement, it has not been sold.

What the courts and the authorities have held

The settled position is that a developer cannot charge separately for open parking, because it forms part of the common area and its cost is already reflected in the price of the flat. The buyer has paid for the common areas through the price, and a separate charge is a double charge.

Covered parking stands differently. Where the plan shows a defined bay, where the bay is an independent space with a boundary, and where the agreement records the allotment, the developer may allot and charge for it. The charge must be disclosed and agreed, not imposed at the time of possession.

The middle category is the basement. A basement that is part of the common areas is common property; a basement parking bay that the plan identifies as a separate unit and the agreement allots is not. The plan and the agreement decide, not the developer's description.

The disputes that actually arise

  • Charged for open parking. The buyer paid a lakh or more for a space in the compound that is common area. The claim is for a refund of the charge, with interest.
  • Sold twice. The developer allotted the same bay to two buyers, or the society re-allotted it after the sale. The claim is against the developer for the allotment and against the society for the record.
  • Not on the plan. The parking exists physically but not on the sanctioned plan, and the municipal authority can require it to be removed. The buyer's remedy is against the developer.
  • Stack parking. Mechanical stack parking is installed and charged for without disclosure. The safety and the sanction for the structure are separate questions from the charge.
  • No allotment at all. The buyer paid for parking and the developer never identified a bay. The claim is for the specific bay or for the refund.

What the buyer should check before paying

The sanctioned plan, first. It shows the parking, the number of bays, and whether the basement is a parking level. A plan without parking, and a brochure with parking, is a contradiction the buyer should resolve before the booking.

The RERA registration, second. The project's disclosures include the number of parking spaces and the manner of allotment. A project that discloses fewer spaces than it is selling is a project in breach of the disclosure obligation.

The agreement, third. The clause should identify the bay, state whether it is covered or open, state the price, and record that the allotment is exclusive. A clause that says "parking as available" is not an allotment.

The municipal record, fourth. For a completed building, the occupancy certificate and the completion certificate show what was sanctioned and built. Parking outside the sanction is unauthorised.

The remedies

  1. A written objection to the developer, demanding the allotment or a refund of the parking charge, with the payment record.
  2. A complaint before the West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority, on the ground of a contravention of the disclosure and agreement obligations, with a claim for refund and interest.
  3. A complaint before the consumer commission, on the ground of a deficiency in service and an unfair trade practice.
  4. A civil suit for a declaration and a refund, where the amounts justify it and the other forums are unavailable.
  5. A complaint to the municipal authority where the parking is unauthorised, which puts pressure on the developer independently of the money claim.

The claim is usually modest in value, and the forum should be chosen for speed. The RERA complaint is cheaper than a suit, and the authority has the power to direct a refund.

The society's role

Once the society is formed and the conveyance is done, the common areas vest in the society. The society allots the parking in accordance with its bye-laws and the allotments recorded at the time of sale, and it cannot re-allot a bay that was sold to a particular flat.

The society's register of parking allotments is the record that matters after conveyance, and a buyer should ask for it before purchasing a resale flat. A flat sold with "one covered parking" is a flat whose parking should appear in the society's register, not merely in the seller's assurance.

Kolkata: the practice and the forums

In Kolkata and its peripheral projects, basement parking is commonly sold at a separate price, and the disclosure in the RERA registration is often incomplete. The West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority hears the complaints, and the consumer commissions hear the parallel claims.

Our RERA practice handles the disclosure complaints, and the consumer practice deals with the unfair trade practice claims. Where the dispute is about the title to the common areas, the property law practice advises on the conveyance and the society's rights.

Can the builder charge separately for open parking?

No. Open parking is part of the common areas, and its cost is included in the price of the flat. A separate charge for an open space in the compound is a charge for common property, and it can be recovered with interest. The position is different for a covered bay that the sanctioned plan shows and the agreement allots.

Is basement parking part of my flat?

Not automatically. A basement bay that the plan identifies as a separate unit and the agreement allots is a separate right, and it must be paid for and recorded. A basement that forms part of the common areas is common property, and no individual allottee owns it. The plan and the agreement decide which it is.

What if the society allots my parking space to someone else?

If the bay was allotted to your flat at the time of sale and recorded in the society's register, the re-allotment is a breach, and you can challenge it before the society's managing committee and, if necessary, in the civil court. If the bay was never recorded, the society will treat it as common parking, and the claim is against the developer who took the money.

A rera parking sale dispute is small in money and large in irritation, and it is decided almost entirely by three documents: the sanctioned plan, the RERA disclosure and the agreement. A buyer who checks all three before paying does not have the dispute at all.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422