14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Civil Procedure

Second Appeal Under Section 100 CPC

A first appeal is a rehearing, and the appellate court can re-examine the facts. A second appeal is not. Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, allows a second appeal to the High Court only where the case involves a substantial question of law, and the appellant must state the question in the memorandum and satisfy the court at the admission stage that it arises. Most second appeals are dismissed because the appellant's real complaint is about the appreciation of evidence, which is not a ground.

What Section 100 requires

An appeal lies to the High Court from a decree passed in appeal by a court subordinate to it, if the High Court is satisfied that the case involves a substantial question of law. The memorandum of appeal must state the substantial question of law involved. Where the High Court is satisfied that such a question arises, it formulates the question and decides the appeal on it, and it may decide the appeal on any other substantial question of law if it is satisfied that the appellant had a sufficient opportunity to address it.

The section also allows the respondent to argue at the threshold that no substantial question of law arises, in which case the appeal fails at the admission stage without a full hearing. That is why the memorandum matters more in a second appeal than in any other pleading: a vague ground that the judgement is against the weight of evidence invites precisely that objection.

The Code separately bars a second appeal in certain small causes cases where the value of the subject matter does not exceed the amount prescribed, and it restricts second appeals in other specified circumstances. Where the bar applies, the only remedy is the revisional or supervisory jurisdiction of the High Court, which is narrower still.

What counts as a substantial question of law

A substantial question of law is one that affects the rights of the parties in a material way, and the applicant must identify it. The following are the recognised categories.

  • A question on which there is a conflict of decisions of the courts, or which the law has not settled.
  • A question of law arising from the pleadings and the record, which does not require any fresh facts to be determined.
  • A finding of fact that is perverse, that is to say one arrived at by ignoring material evidence or on no evidence at all, or which is based on inadmissible evidence.
  • A misconstruction of a document, which the courts treat as a question of law.
  • A question whether a provision of law was applied to a situation to which it does not apply, or whether the burden of proof was placed on the wrong party.
  • A breach of a mandatory rule of procedure that has caused prejudice.

What is not included is a concurrent finding of fact based on evidence, however much the appellant disagrees with the weight given to it. Nor is a question that was never pleaded or argued below, unless it is a pure question of law arising from the record and no new evidence would be needed to decide it.

The concurrent finding problem

Where both the trial court and the first appellate court have recorded the same finding of fact, the second appeal is decided on that finding unless the appellant can bring the case into one of the exceptions. The standard line of argument is that the finding is perverse because the courts ignored a document that was on the record, or relied on a witness who contradicted himself, or failed to consider an admission. The argument must be supported by the page of the record, not by a general assertion.

An appellant who wins on the perversity point does not automatically win the appeal. The High Court then has to decide the case on the material available, and it may remand the matter to the first appellate court rather than substitute its own finding.

Procedure and interim protection

  1. Obtain the certified copies of the judgement and decree of the first appellate court and of the trial court, and of the pleadings and the material evidence.
  2. Draft the memorandum of appeal with the substantial questions of law stated separately and precisely.
  3. File before the Calcutta High Court on its appellate side, with the court fee prescribed by the state law.
  4. Apply for stay of execution under Order 41 Rule 5. A second appeal does not operate as a stay of the decree automatically, and the court may require security or a deposit as a condition.
  5. Attend the admission hearing with the paper book, and be ready to argue both that a substantial question arises and, if the court is not satisfied, that the appeal can be disposed of on the material without a remand.

The stay question deserves attention. A decree-holder can execute while the appeal is pending unless a stay is granted, and an appellant who obtains a stay on condition of deposition should comply with the condition on time, since a conditional stay lapses if the condition is not met.

Alternatives and the wider appellate map

Where a second appeal is barred or unlikely to succeed, the options are narrower. An application for review under Section 114 and Order 47 lies to the court that passed the order, on the ground of a mistake apparent on the face of the record or the discovery of new and important matter. A petition under Article 227 of the Constitution allows the High Court to supervise subordinate courts but is not a substitute for an appeal, and the High Court will not use it to re-appreciate evidence.

A special leave petition to the Supreme Court is a discretionary remedy, and it does not become available merely because the second appeal failed.

An order passed in a first appeal can also be challenged by a cross-objection by the respondent under Order 41 Rule 22, which is often the cleaner route where both parties are aggrieved by different parts of the judgement. The cross-objection is filed in the appeal itself and does not require a separate appeal.

Practical notes for a Kolkata second appeal

First appeals from decrees of the City Civil Court at Kolkata, the presidency small causes court and the district courts at Alipore and Barasat come to the Calcutta High Court on the appellate side, and the second appeal lies there as well. The paper book is the case. In practice the appeal is decided on the judgement, the pleadings and the key exhibits, so the appellant should prepare a short note identifying the three or four documents that show the perversity, and the respondent a note showing that the finding rested on evidence.

The most common reason a second appeal is lost is that the appellant pleads the whole case again. The court is not conducting a third trial, and the memorandum should read as a legal argument, not as a narrative. Our civil litigation practice drafts second appeals, and recovery suits often end at this stage, which is where the drafting of the original pleadings pays off.

Common questions

Can I file a second appeal on a question of fact?

No, unless the finding is perverse, founded on no evidence or on inadmissible evidence, or based on a misreading of a document. The appellant must show which evidence was ignored.

Who frames the substantial question of law?

The High Court frames it, but the appellant must state it in the memorandum. A memorandum that states no question is normally returned or dismissed at the admission stage.

Does a second appeal stay the decree?

No. A separate application for stay is required, and the court may impose conditions such as security or deposit of the decretal amount.

Can new evidence be produced in a second appeal?

Only in the narrow circumstances allowed by Order 41 Rule 27, such as where the evidence was not within the party's knowledge or could not be produced despite due diligence. The appellate court must record its reasons for admitting it.

Identify the question before drafting the grounds, and the appeal has a hearing. If you have a first appellate judgement on hand, contact the office; our fees for an assessment and for court appearances are published.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422