14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Recovery & Cheque Bounce

Section 143A interim compensation: how much, and when

Section 143A of the Negotiable Instruments Act allows a magistrate trying a cheque case to order the drawer to pay interim compensation of up to twenty per cent of the cheque amount while the trial is still running. It is the only place in this branch of the law where a complainant gets money before proving the case, and it has changed the negotiating balance in cheque disputes.

What the section provides

The power is exercised in a summary trial or a summons case, on an application by the complainant. The court may order the drawer to pay interim compensation, and the ceiling is twenty per cent of the cheque amount. The amount is payable within sixty days of the order, and the section allows a further period on sufficient cause being shown, on payment of interest.

Two consequences follow from the section itself. Where the drawer is acquitted, the interim compensation must be refunded with interest at the bank rate. Where the drawer is convicted, the amount is adjusted against the fine or the compensation awarded.

The section is discretionary in form. The court "may" order it, and the complainant must apply. It is not automatic on filing a complaint, and magistrates in Kolkata do not grant it as a matter of course.

When the application is made

The application is filed with the complaint or shortly after the accused appears and the plea is recorded. Filing it with the complaint is the better practice, because the court has the cheque and the return memo before it and can form a prima facie view without a separate hearing.

The application should be short and should attach the documents that establish the prima facie case: the cheque, the return memo, the notice and the proof of service. It should state the cheque amount and the figure claimed, expressed as a percentage of it, and it should say why the interim order is needed, for instance that the drawer is disposing of assets or that the complainant's money has been locked up for a long period. Those documents are the same set the complaint needs, as described under cheque bounce.

How the court decides

The court looks at whether there is a prima facie case, which in a cheque matter means the statutory presumption operating in the complainant's favour and no obvious defect in the notice or the presentation. A complaint filed after the limitation had run, or on a cheque that was presented prematurely, will not attract an interim order.

The court also weighs the accused's material. A drawer who produces a receipt showing repayment, or a written agreement showing that the cheque was given as security for a future obligation that has not arisen, may defeat the application. A drawer who says only that he will prove his defence at trial rarely does.

The quantum is where discretion shows. Twenty per cent is the ceiling and not the norm, and a magistrate may order ten per cent or fifteen per cent. The size of the cheque, the age of the claim and the accused's apparent ability to pay all influence the figure.

The sixty days and what happens on default

The order fixes a date sixty days from its making. Where the drawer does not pay, the complainant can apply for steps under the Code for recovery, and the non-payment is itself a circumstance the court may take into account. Some magistrates treat default as a ground for cancelling bail or for expediting the trial, though the section does not say so in terms.

The drawer can seek an extension on sufficient cause, and the court may grant it on interest. In practice an extension is granted where the drawer shows a genuine difficulty, and refused where the application is a device to delay.

The appeal route and the deposit

A drawer who is convicted and appeals faces a second monetary requirement. The appellate court may order him to deposit a minimum of twenty per cent of the fine or compensation awarded by the trial court as a condition of hearing the appeal. The two provisions work together: one puts money in the complainant's hands during the trial, the other secures the award during the appeal.

For a drawer with a genuine defence and limited means, the combined effect can be severe. That is the point of the provisions, and it is why the defence in these cases is usually directed at the earliest stage, before either order is made.

Defending an application under Section 143A

  • Attack the prima facie case, not the hardship. A defect in the notice, a premature presentment, a return reason outside the section, or a complaint filed beyond limitation will defeat the application.
  • Show the cheque's character. Where the cheque was given as security or for a contingent obligation, produce the agreement that says so.
  • Show repayment. A bank statement or a receipt for the amount is the strongest answer, though it may also invite the court to treat the case as one for trial.
  • Ask for a reasoned order. An order that does not state why a prima facie case exists or why the percentage chosen is justified is open to challenge in revision.
  • Use the extension provision, not absence. An application for more time on stated grounds is better than default and a warrant.

A challenge to an interim order goes by way of revision before the Calcutta High Court, and the High Court does not usually interfere with a discretionary order unless the magistrate has acted without jurisdiction or ignored material on record. The time to argue is before the magistrate.

Interaction with the civil claim

Interim compensation is not damages and does not conclude the civil claim. A payee who recovers twenty per cent under Section 143A can still sue for the balance, and the amount received is adjusted. Where the drawer is acquitted and the interim compensation is refunded, the civil suit is unaffected. The balance can be claimed in the suit described under recovery suits.

This is why the two proceedings should be run with one set of figures. Our page on legal notice and recovery sets out how the demand in the notice should be framed so that a later suit and a later interim application are consistent.

Where it is applied for in Kolkata

The application is made in the complaint itself, before the magistrate having jurisdiction, which for a payee banking in the city is the court of the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate at Bankshall or the appropriate metropolitan magistrate's court. In the districts, the application goes before the judicial magistrate hearing the complaint. The order is typed on the same file, and the complainant should keep a certified copy for the execution stage.

Common questions

Is twenty per cent the standard figure?

It is the maximum, not the norm. Magistrates order less where the cheque is large or the defence has some substance. A complainant who claims the ceiling without saying why invites a lower figure.

Can interim compensation be ordered in a case where the accused has not appeared?

The application is usually heard after the accused enters appearance, because the order has to be served and complied with. An ex parte order is possible in principle but rare in practice.

What if the accused pays the interim compensation in full?

That does not end the case. The trial continues, and the amount is adjusted against the final compensation or fine if there is a conviction. Payment is not an admission that disposes of the complaint, though it often leads to a settlement.

Is the amount refundable with interest if the drawer is acquitted?

Yes. The section requires refund with interest at the bank rate, and the complainant can be directed to pay it. That is a real risk for a complainant whose case rests on a defective notice.

Section 143A is a lever, not a jackpot. A complainant who files a clean complaint with the documents attached, and asks for a sensible percentage with reasons, gets an order within weeks. A complainant who treats the section as an entitlement gets a reasoned refusal, and the drawer learns that the case is weaker than the notice suggested.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422