A promoter whose company has gone into insolvency cannot ordinarily buy it back. Section 29A of the Code lists the persons who are ineligible to submit a resolution plan, and the list was built to stop the practice of promoters bidding for their own distressed company at a discount, having caused the default in the first place. The section 29a ibc eligibility test is applied at the stage of the plan, and a plan submitted by an ineligible person is rejected, however good its terms.
The provision is not a permanent disqualification in every case. Some of the categories are curable, some are not, and the analysis depends on the precise ground, the entity that is bidding, and the connection between the bidder and the corporate debtor.
The categories of ineligibility
The section lists the persons who may not submit a plan, and the list operates on the resolution applicant and, in defined cases, on the persons who are connected with it. The categories include:
- An undischarged insolvent.
- A person declared a wilful defaulter in accordance with the directions of the Reserve Bank.
- A person whose account has been classified as a non-performing asset for more than a year and who has not paid the overdue amount.
- A person convicted of an offence punishable with imprisonment of two years or more, where the conviction is for an offence involving moral turpitude, or an offence under specified economic laws.
- A person disqualified to act as a director under the companies law.
- A promoter or a person in control of a company whose account has been classified as a non-performing asset for more than a year.
- A person who has executed an enforceable guarantee in favour of a creditor of the corporate debtor against which the process has been admitted.
- A person who has been a promoter or in the management or control of a corporate debtor in which a preferential, undervalued, extortionate or fraudulent transaction has taken place, and in respect of which the tribunal has passed an order.
The list is applied to the person, and to the persons acting jointly or in concert with him. A bid through a newly incorporated company, controlled by an ineligible promoter, is caught, and the tribunal looks through the structure.
Why the provision exists
The rationale is stated in the reports and the debates. A promoter who has run a company into default should not be allowed to acquire it at a fraction of its value through the insolvency process, having retained the upside and transferred the loss to the lenders. The bar is a condition of the market's confidence in the process, and it is applied strictly.
The bar also protects the committee of creditors from a bid that is attractive in the short term but returns the company to the same management. The committee must satisfy itself that the applicant is eligible, and the resolution professional must verify it.
The provision is not a punishment of the promoter, and it does not prevent him from paying off the dues and settling with the creditors before the plan stage. A settlement that results in the withdrawal of the application is a different route, and it is not affected by the bar.
How eligibility is tested
- The resolution professional issues the invitation for plans, with the eligibility conditions.
- The applicant submits a declaration of eligibility in the prescribed form, with the details of its promoters and connected persons.
- The professional examines the declaration, the public records, the credit information and the company filings.
- The committee considers the plan only from an eligible applicant, and records its satisfaction.
- The tribunal examines the eligibility at the stage of approval, and may reject the plan where the applicant is ineligible.
The declaration is not a formality. A false declaration is a ground for the rejection of the plan and for action against the applicant, and the professional is expected to verify the material rather than accept the declaration.
The cure, and the cases where the bar does not apply
Some categories are cured by payment. A person whose account was classified as a non-performing asset becomes eligible once the overdue amount is paid and the classification is rectified, and the payment must be made before the plan is submitted. The same logic applies to the guarantee, where the guarantee has been discharged.
Other categories are not curable within the process: a conviction, a disqualification, a wilful defaulter declaration. In those cases the person is out, and the only route is through a different applicant who is not connected with him.
The bar applies to the resolution applicant, and the applicant may be a financial investor, an operating company or a fund. Where the fund is managed by a person who is also a promoter of the corporate debtor, the connection is examined, and the structure is disregarded if it is a device.
The practical consequences for the committee
A committee that receives a plan from a promoter group must test the eligibility carefully, because an approved plan that is later set aside for ineligibility wastes the process. The tribunal has set aside plans on this ground, and the committee's decision does not cure the defect.
A committee that receives no eligible plan may extend the process or move for liquidation. The bar is one reason why some processes end in liquidation, and the lenders' recovery in liquidation is lower. The tension between the bar and the recovery is a policy debate, not a legal one, and it does not change the section.
Our pages on insolvency and bankruptcy and corporate law cover the plan and the approval, and banking and finance covers the lender's position.
Where the committee is unable to approve a plan from an eligible applicant, it may extend the process or seek liquidation. That outcome is common where the only interested bidder is the promoter group and the bar applies to every member of it, and the lenders then weigh a lower recovery in liquidation against the risk of returning the company to the same hands. The tribunal's approval of the plan is the point at which the eligibility is finally tested, and a plan approved without that test being recorded is exposed to challenge in appeal.
Common questions
Can a promoter bid through a new company?
Not where he controls the new company or is acting in concert with it. The tribunal looks at the substance, and a structure that exists only to avoid the bar is disregarded.
Is a wilful defaulter declaration permanent?
The declaration is made by a lender and is recorded with the credit information companies. It is not a conviction, and its removal depends on the lender's decision and the regulatory process. Until it is removed, the person remains ineligible.
Can an ineligible person join with an eligible bidder?
Not as a resolution applicant, and the joint venture is examined for control. An eligible bidder who is funded by an ineligible person, or whose plan gives the ineligible person a role in the management, is a plan that will be tested.
Does the bar apply to a plan submitted after the process is extended?
Yes. The eligibility is tested at the time of the plan, and an extension does not cure a disqualification. A person who was ineligible at the start and has not cured the ground remains ineligible.
If a plan has been rejected for ineligibility, the declaration and the connected-party details are the documents to examine. Bring the invitation, the declaration and the committee's minutes to a consultation, or write to the office before the next plan stage.