14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Selling inherited property: probate, consent, buyer's risk

A person who has inherited a property can sell it, but he must be able to show three things: how he inherited it, that every other person who had a share has either joined the sale or given up the share, and that any will under which he claims has been proved where the law requires probate. A buyer who completes without those three things takes a title that an omitted heir can attack years later, and the buyer's only remedy is against the seller.

Inherited property is the commonest source of title defects in Kolkata. The family has held the flat for two generations, the mutation was never completed, one branch lives abroad, and the sale is agreed before anyone has asked who the heirs are.

Establishing the seller's title

The first document is the death certificate of the person whose property it was. The second is the proof of heirship: an heirship certificate from the local authority, a genealogy supported by the death certificates of the predeceased heirs, or a court declaration.

The third is the record. The khatian should show the deceased as the holder before the death and the heirs after the mutation. A record that still shows the deceased is a record that the buyer's advocate will query, and the mutation is the seller's job, not the buyer's.

The fourth is the will, if there is one. Where the deceased left a will, the seller's title depends on it, and the will has to be proved. In the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, probate is generally required for a Hindu will before a right as legatee can be established, and a sale by a legatee without it is a sale that the buyer's title will have to defend later.

Probate, or letters of administration

Probate is the court's certification of the will and of the executor's authority. Where the will names an executor, the executor applies for probate; where it does not, the person entitled applies for letters of administration.

The proceeding involves a petition, a citation to the heirs and the next of kin, an affidavit of assets, and the court's grant after the citation period. The time depends on whether anyone contests, and a contested probate can take years.

For a sale, the executor's authority is what the buyer needs. The executor can convey the property in the course of administration, and the buyer should see the probate, the will, and the executor's confirmation that the sale is made in that capacity. Where the will gives the property to specific legatees, the executor's assent to the legacy is the step that completes the legatee's title before the sale.

The consent of every heir

On intestacy, every Class I heir takes a share. A sale by one heir conveys only his share, and the buyer becomes a co-owner with the others. To convey the whole, every heir must join the deed, or must have given up his share by a registered relinquishment, or must be bound by a partition decree or a family settlement.

The heirs who are usually missed are the daughter, the widow of a predeceased son, and the branch that lives abroad. The first two are entitled under the Hindu Succession Act, and the third is entitled if he has not relinquished. A sale that omits any of them is a sale that can be reopened for their shares.

A relinquishment deed is the practical instrument. It is a registered document by which an heir gives up his share in favour of the others, usually for a consideration or in recognition of a family arrangement. It must be stamped and registered, and it should identify the property and the share precisely.

The buyer's risk

The buyer of an inherited property takes the risk that an heir who was not joined will sue for his share. The suit is for partition or for possession, and the limitation is long: twelve years for possession on the basis of title, and three years for a declaration.

The buyer's defence is that he purchased in good faith and for value. That defence does not defeat the heir's title. It gives the buyer a claim against the seller for the price paid, or for the deficiency in what he received, and the seller may have no money by then.

That is why the buyer's advocate insists on the full set of heirs, the relinquishments, the mutation and, where there is a will, the probate. The insistence is not pedantry; it is the only protection the buyer has.

The seller's sequence

  1. Obtain the death certificate of the recorded owner.
  2. Establish the heirs, with the certificates and the genealogy, and identify every branch.
  3. Complete the mutation in the heirs' names, so that the record matches the family.
  4. Obtain probate or letters of administration, where there is a will and probate is required.
  5. Obtain registered relinquishments from the heirs who are not joining the sale, or join them in the deed.
  6. Then market the property, with the documents ready.
  7. Execute and register the sale deed, and apply for the mutation in the buyer's name.

That sequence takes months, and a seller who starts it after finding a buyer will lose the buyer. The documents should be assembled before the property is marketed, and the price should reflect the work that has been done.

The tax position

For capital gains, the heir is treated as having held the property from the date the previous owner acquired it, and the cost of acquisition is the previous owner's cost. The gain on sale is computed on that basis, which means an inherited property sold after many years can produce a large gain measured against an old cost.

The exemptions for reinvestment in a residential house, and for investment in the specified bonds, are available subject to their conditions, and they should be considered before the sale is completed rather than after the year ends.

There is no tax on the inheritance itself. The tax arises on the sale, and it arises in the hands of the heir who sells.

The Kolkata offices and forums

Probate and letters of administration for a Hindu will within the city go before the Calcutta High Court's original side. The relinquishment and the sale deed are registered at the sub-registrar's office, and the mutation is applied for at the BL&LRO. Where the family cannot agree, the partition suit is filed in the City Civil Court at Kolkata or the district court at Alipore or Barasat.

Our title disputes practice handles the heirship and relinquishment work, and the registration practice handles the sale. Where the will needs to be proved, the succession practice deals with the probate.

Can I sell inherited property without probate?

Where there is no will, probate does not arise, and the sale can proceed on the heirship documents and the mutation. Where there is a will, probate is generally required within the ordinary original civil jurisdiction of the Calcutta High Court, and outside it the requirement is narrower but the buyer and the bank will usually ask for it. A sale without probate is possible in some circumstances, but it carries a risk that the buyer will price.

Does one heir's refusal block the sale?

It blocks a sale of the whole, because that heir's share cannot be conveyed without him. The others can sell their shares, and the buyer becomes a co-owner, or the family can sue for partition and have the property sold by the court. A buy-out of the refusing heir is usually cheaper than a partition suit.

Is there a tax when I inherit a property?

No. Inheritance is not a transfer for income tax, and no tax arises at the moment of death. The tax arises when the heir sells, and it is computed on the previous owner's cost and holding period, which is why the old purchase documents matter even though the heir never paid for the property.

Selling inherited property consent works the same way: the property is sold once and defended for decades. The work done before the sale — the death certificates, the heirship, the mutation, the relinquishments, the probate — is the work that makes the sale final, and it is cheaper than the litigation that follows its omission.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422