A Lok Adalat can settle a cheque dispute and, once it does, the award it passes is treated as a decree of a civil court and is final. There is no appeal against it. Because an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act is compoundable, the same settlement ends the criminal complaint, so the payee gets an enforceable order and the drawer gets the prosecution closed — in one document.
What a Lok Adalat is, and is not
Lok Adalats are constituted under the Legal Services Authorities Act, 1987, by the State and District Legal Services Authorities. In Kolkata, the District Legal Services Authority and the Calcutta High Court Legal Services Committee organise sittings, and cheque matters are among the categories routinely listed.
It is not a court. It has no power to decide a contested question, to record evidence, or to compel a party to settle. It can only record a compromise that the parties have reached, and if they do not agree, the matter goes back to the court where it came from. That distinction matters: a Lok Adalat is a settlement forum, and a party that attends expecting adjudication will be disappointed.
There is also a separate institution, the Permanent Lok Adalat for public utility services, which does have power to decide. That body's jurisdiction is confined to public utility services such as transport, postal, communication, hospital and insurance services. A cheque dispute is not a public utility service and does not go there.
The award and its effect
Once the parties sign the settlement, the Lok Adalat passes an award in terms of it. Two consequences follow from the statute:
- The award is deemed to be a decree of a civil court, or an order of a tribunal, as the case may be.
- It is final and binding on the parties, and no appeal lies against it.
Because it is a decree, it can be executed. If the drawer defaults on an instalment, the payee does not have to file a fresh suit; the award itself is the executable instrument, and execution is moved before the court that would have executed a decree in that matter, or as the award provides. That is a real advantage over a private settlement, which gives the payee nothing but a promise.
A challenge to a Lok Adalat award is confined to narrow grounds — that it was obtained by fraud or misrepresentation, or that the Lok Adalat acted without jurisdiction. It is not an appeal on the merits, and it does not reopen the compromise.
What happens to the criminal case
The composition of a Section 138 offence is permissible at any stage. When the parties settle before a Lok Adalat and the settlement is recorded, the criminal complaint is disposed of on the basis of the composition. In practice the criminal court is informed of the award and closes the proceeding; where the Lok Adalat itself is seized of the matter by reference, the award is the disposal.
Two cautions. First, the settlement must expressly cover the criminal proceeding, not only the money. A compromise that settles the amount and says nothing about the complaint can leave the prosecution alive, and the drawer will have paid without getting the closure he wanted. Second, the payee should not agree to withdrawal of the complaint before the money is actually paid. An award that records payment on a future date and a simultaneous withdrawal of the complaint leaves the payee exposed if the drawer defaults.
The standard protection is to make the criminal complaint's closure conditional on payment, or to record the settlement with instalments and a default clause that revives the complaint. Courts will record such terms if both parties agree.
The terms worth insisting on
A cheque settlement is a contract, and the drafting decides whether it is worth anything. Insist on:
- A fixed schedule of payment with dates, amounts and the mode of payment.
- A default clause: on default of any instalment, the entire balance becomes payable at once.
- A statement that the award is in full and final settlement of the debt, the cheque and the complaint.
- A provision on interest for the period of default.
- A provision on what happens to the criminal complaint on default.
Where the drawer wants time, the instalment schedule is the price of that time, and the payee should be compensated for it. A settlement that gives twelve months without interest is a settlement that has already given the drawer a benefit.
When Lok Adalat is the right route
It suits three situations. A drawer who admits the debt but needs time. A payee whose documentary case is thin and who would rather take a certain smaller sum than risk dismissal. And a family or business dispute where the relationship matters as much as the money.
It does not suit a drawer who denies the debt outright, or a payee who has a strong case and wants the compensation and costs a conviction would bring. In those cases the trial court is the right forum and the settlement value is being given away.
A Lok Adalat award is worth exactly what the payment schedule in it is worth. Read the schedule, not the headline figure.
The Kolkata organisation
Sittings are notified by the District Legal Services Authority for Kolkata and by the legal services authorities for North and South 24 Parganas. Matters are referred by the Magistrate trying the complaint, or brought by the parties on an application. There is no court fee for a Lok Adalat settlement, and the process is designed to be completed in a single sitting.
For cheque matters pending in the Bankshall courts or the City Civil Court, the reference is ordinarily made by the court seized of the matter, so the application is made there.
Common questions
Can a Lok Adalat award be appealed?
No. It is final. The only challenge is a petition on the narrow grounds of fraud, misrepresentation or want of jurisdiction, which is not a merits appeal.
Is a lawyer needed at the Lok Adalat?
Not required, but useful. The terms are drafted at the sitting, and the difference between a settlement that protects the payee and one that does not is usually a clause or two.
What if the drawer does not pay the first instalment?
The payee moves for execution of the award. That is the reason for insisting on a default clause and on a clear schedule rather than a lump-sum promise.
A cheque settlement is worth doing properly. Our cheque bounce practice handles references to Lok Adalat and the drafting of the terms, recovery of money covers the enforcement of an award, and recovery suits is the route where no settlement is possible.