14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Accident & Consumer

Settling a Consumer Case: Mediation and Consent Orders

A consumer complaint is not a criminal case, so there is nothing to compound. What the Act offers instead is mediation, a reference the commission can make with the parties' consent at any stage, and a consent order that records the settlement and is enforceable like any other order. The difference between a settlement that is filed and a settlement that is recorded is the difference between a promise and a decree.

What "compounding" means, and why it does not apply

Compounding is the process by which an offence is settled and the prosecution ends, usually on payment of a sum. Consumer law is a civil remedy with a penal provision attached for disobedience of orders. A complaint is withdrawn or settled; it is not compounded. Anyone who tells a consumer that the opposite party will "compound the case" is using the word loosely.

The penal provision that does exist is for failing to comply with an order. Where a party disobeys, the commission can proceed under the penalty clause, and a settlement of the underlying claim does not necessarily undo a proceeding already started for disobedience. In practice, payment ends the matter and the penalty proceeding is not pursued.

Mediation under the Act

The Act provides for mediation at the commission's level. The commission may refer a dispute to mediation with the consent of both parties, at any stage of the proceedings. A mediator is drawn from a panel maintained for the purpose, the process is time-bound, and the mediator reports the outcome to the commission.

If the mediation succeeds, the settlement agreement is recorded and the commission passes an order in its terms. If it fails, the mediator reports that no settlement was reached, and the complaint resumes. The mediation process does not stay the commission's power to pass interim orders, and a party who uses mediation only to delay will find the complaint proceeding regardless.

Mediation is useful where the relationship continues: a builder who is still constructing, a bank that wants to retain the customer, a dealer who will service the vehicle. It is less useful where the opposite party has already refused in writing and the dispute is about the amount.

The consent order

The most reliable settlement is a consent order. The parties file a joint memorandum recording the terms, and the commission passes an order disposing of the complaint in those terms. The order is then enforceable in the same way as a contested order, which means execution, attachment and the penalty provision are available if the terms are broken.

The terms should be precise. A settlement that says the builder will "complete the work at the earliest" is not enforceable. One that says the builder will pay a stated sum by a stated date to a stated account, and will hand over possession by a stated date subject to the occupancy certificate, is.

Include a default clause. If the payment is in instalments, the clause should say that on default of any instalment the entire balance becomes payable, and that the complainant may execute without further notice. Without it, each default requires a fresh application.

Include a withdrawal clause that operates only on performance. A complainant who withdraws the complaint on the signing of the settlement, before the money is paid, has given up the only leverage he had. The order should record that the complaint is disposed of in terms of the settlement, not withdrawn.

The reliefs a commission can order

The Act lists the reliefs available. The commission may direct the removal of a defect in the goods; the replacement of the goods; the refund of the price paid; the payment of compensation for loss or injury; the discontinuance of an unfair trade practice or a restrictive trade practice; the payment of costs; and the withdrawal of hazardous goods from sale. It may also direct a party to do what it promised, which for a builder is the completion of the flat and for a service provider is the restoration of the service.

Punitive damages are available in an appropriate case where the conduct is egregious, and the Act expressly allows compensation for the harm caused by a product. Interest can be awarded where the money was retained without justification.

What the commission cannot do is order something outside the Act: it will not grant an injunction in the civil court's sense, or decide title to property, or award damages for a breach that is really a commercial contract dispute between businesses.

A settlement that fails

Where a settlement is signed but not performed, and the complaint was withdrawn, the complainant must either revive the complaint, which requires the commission's permission and is not automatic, or sue on the settlement as a contract. The second route is slower but independent.

Where the complaint was disposed of in terms of a settlement by an order, the complainant executes the order. That is why the distinction matters. A file disposed of "in terms of the settlement" keeps its execution value; a file "withdrawn as settled" does not.

Settling with a large company

Large companies settle through their legal departments, and the settlement is usually documented in a release or a full and final settlement letter. The consumer should read it for two things: whether it covers only the present complaint or also future claims arising from the same transaction, and whether it requires confidentiality that would prevent the consumer from reporting the conduct.

A full and final settlement that pays less than the claim may still be the right commercial decision, but it should be taken with advice on what the claim was worth. A settlement of a flat delay that waives the right to claim the flat itself is a different bargain from one that pays compensation and leaves the contract alive.

For the Kolkata forums, a settlement can be recorded before the District Commission or the State Commission at Kolkata, and the mediation reference is made by the commission itself. Our consumer protection practice drafts consent terms and appears at the mediation, and the RERA practice deals with the settlements that involve a promoter.

Common questions

Can the opposite party settle after the order is passed?

Yes, and this is common. The settlement is recorded, the order is satisfied, and the execution application is withdrawn. The terms should still be recorded so that a default can be enforced.

Do I lose my fee if I settle?

The filing fee is not refunded on settlement. Costs awarded in the order can include the fee where the commission allows it.

Is a settlement without the commission's order binding?

It is a contract and binds the parties, but it is enforced by a civil suit, not by execution in the consumer forum. Record it if you can.

Can I settle part of the claim and pursue the rest?

Yes, if the settlement says so. A settlement of the compensation claim can leave the question of possession alive, but the terms must be explicit, or the other side will argue that the whole dispute was settled.

Settle in writing, settle on terms, and have the commission record it. A settlement is only as good as the order behind it. To discuss terms before you sign, contact the office; the fees are published.

Looking for a our law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422