A succession certificate establishes the holder's right to collect the debts and securities of a deceased person, and a probate establishes the will and the executor's authority over the whole estate. A bank asked to release a fixed deposit or a share portfolio will usually accept either, depending on whether there is a will: without a will, a succession certificate; with a will, probate or letters of administration. Neither document transfers immovable property, and neither replaces the mutation.
The distinction matters because the two proceedings have different scope, different courts and different costs, and a family that starts the wrong one loses months.
What a succession certificate covers
Part X of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 deals with succession certificates. The certificate is granted in respect of debts and securities, and it authorises the holder to collect them and to give a valid discharge to the debtor or the company.
It does not cover immovable property. A flat or a plot does not pass under a succession certificate, and the certificate cannot be used for mutation or for sale. The heirs establish their title to land through the inheritance, the mutation and, if necessary, a declaration suit.
The certificate lists the assets covered. A bank deposit, a demat account, mutual fund units and shares can be included; an asset discovered later requires a fresh application or an amendment, and the bank will not release it on the strength of a certificate that does not mention it.
The court and the procedure
The application is made to the District Judge within whose jurisdiction the deceased ordinarily resided, and in Kolkata to the court exercising that jurisdiction in the city. In the districts, it is the District Judge at Alipore or Barasat, as the case may be.
The petition sets out the deceased's details, the date of death, the heirs, the debts and securities, and the petitioner's right to the certificate. It is supported by the death certificate, the proof of heirship, and the statements or certificates from the banks and companies showing the assets.
The court issues a citation to the other heirs and directs publication in a newspaper, so that any person with an objection can come forward. If no objection is filed, the court grants the certificate, usually after requiring a bond with sureties for the value of the assets, to secure the estate against a later claimant.
The fee
The court fee on a succession certificate is ad valorem on the value of the debts and securities covered. The rate is fixed by the Court Fees Act as applied in West Bengal, and the fee is computed on the amount the certificate authorises the holder to collect.
That is a real cost, and it is the reason families sometimes prefer to rely on a nomination, a joint holder or a bank's own indemnity procedure for small balances. Those routes work for modest amounts and cooperative banks, and they fail when the amount is large or the bank insists on a grant.
What a bank actually asks for
- Without a will: a succession certificate, or a legal heir certificate with an indemnity and the consent of all the heirs, where the bank's policy permits it for small amounts.
- With a will: probate or letters of administration, the will, and the executor's authority.
- With a nomination: the nominee's claim, the death certificate, and the bank's form. The nominee is a trustee for the heirs in law, though the bank usually pays the nominee and leaves the distribution to the family.
- With a joint holder: the survivor's claim, subject to the bank's mandate.
- For shares: the succession certificate or probate, plus the transmission forms of the company or the depository.
The bank's requirements vary. A private bank may accept an indemnity for a small balance and insist on a grant for a large one, and a public sector bank usually follows its circulars strictly. The family should ask the branch, in writing, what it will accept, before starting a proceeding.
When there is a will
Where the deceased left a will, the succession certificate is not the primary document. The will governs, and the person entitled under it applies for probate or letters of administration. A succession certificate can still be granted, but the court will examine the will, and the certificate does not override it.
Where the will is disputed, the probate court decides its validity, and the succession certificate proceeding is usually held over until that is decided. Filing both simultaneously invites duplication and inconsistent findings.
Disputes among the heirs
The certificate is granted to the person entitled, and the court's enquiry into entitlement is summary. A rival heir can file an objection, and the court then decides the right to the certificate on the material before it.
That decision does not bind the civil court on the question of title. A party who loses the certificate proceeding can still sue for a declaration or for partition, and the certificate is not a decree.
The Kolkata courts
The succession certificate application is made to the court exercising the district court's jurisdiction in the city, and the probate petition to the original side of the Calcutta High Court where the will falls within its jurisdiction. Both are supported by the death certificate and the heirship documents, and both require the citation or the publication.
Our succession practice handles both proceedings, and the property law practice deals with the mutation that follows for the immovable assets. Where the family is in dispute, the partition practice is the route for the land.
Which document will the bank accept?
Without a will, a succession certificate; with a will, probate or letters of administration. For small balances, many banks accept a legal heir certificate with an indemnity and the consent of all the heirs, but the policy varies and should be confirmed in writing before the family spends on a court proceeding.
Can I get both a succession certificate and probate?
They cover different things, and a family may need both: probate for the estate under the will, and a succession certificate for a specific deposit or shareholding that the bank will not release on the probate alone, though in practice the probate covers the securities as part of the estate. Filing both is expensive and usually unnecessary, and the sequence should be planned with the bank's requirements in view.
How long does a succession certificate take?
Three to six months for an uncontested application, depending on the court's list and the publication. A contested application takes longer, because the objection has to be tried. The bond and the sureties add time at the end, and the certificate issues after they are furnished.
Two practical points catch families out. The first is the fee. A succession application is charged with ad valorem court fee on the value of the debts and securities covered, so the value has to be stated precisely in the schedule to the petition, and an understated schedule invites an objection from the court office before the matter is even listed. The second is the bond. The certificate issues only after the applicant furnishes a bond, usually with one or two sureties, undertaking to indemnify any person who later establishes a superior right. Where the amount is large the sureties must be able to show property, and the wait at this stage is often longer than the hearing itself.
The succession certificate vs probate choice is made by the asset and by the will, not by preference. A family that identifies what the bank will accept, and what the land requires, avoids the expense of a proceeding that produces a document nobody needs.