A suit against the government, a local authority or a public officer for an act done in his official capacity cannot be filed until two months after a written notice under Section 80 of the Code of Civil Procedure has been delivered. The notice must state the cause of action, the plaintiff's name, description and residence, and the relief claimed. Filing without it is not a technical defect; it is a bar the court will notice.
Who the notice must go to
Where the defendant is the State Government, the notice is delivered to the Secretary to the Government of the concerned department, or to the Collector of the district where the suit is to be filed. For West Bengal that means the departmental Secretary at the state secretariat, which since the administrative shift is at Nabanna in Howrah, with a copy to the Collector of the district concerned. Sending it to the right department matters, because a notice misdirected to a department that has nothing to do with the subject is not a notice about that subject. A large share of these claims are land claims, and the compensation stage is dealt with under land acquisition.
Where the defendant is a local authority, the notice goes to the Secretary of the authority. In Kolkata that means, according to the subject matter, the Secretary of the Kolkata Municipal Corporation, the Kolkata Port authority or the panchayat body, and the municipal statute often contains its own notice requirement with its own period. Where a special statute prescribes a notice, both the Code's requirement and the special one must be satisfied.
Where the suit is against a public officer for something done in his official capacity, the notice is delivered to him. A suit against a public officer for something done in a purely private capacity does not attract the section.
What the notice must contain
The section lists the contents, and each has been litigated.
- The cause of action. The facts on which the claim rests, not a conclusion. A notice that says "your department has illegally taken my land" without dates or survey numbers is not a proper notice.
- The name, description and place of residence of the plaintiff. Enough to identify the claimant and to allow the government to reach him.
- The relief claimed. Damages of a stated amount, possession of a described property, a declaration, or a specific sum. A general request for justice is not a notice.
- The date and the signature, with the mode of service and the acknowledgement.
Courts read a notice liberally and do not insist on the form of a pleading, but the substance has to be there. The test applied is whether the notice gives the government enough information to consider the claim and to decide whether to settle. A notice that omits the cause of action altogether cannot be cured by a detailed plaint, and the suit will fail.
The two months and what they are for
The object of the delay is to allow the government to consider the claim and, where it is just, to settle without litigation. It is not a punishment of the plaintiff, and it is not a bar that the government can waive or extend indefinitely. The two-month period runs from delivery of the notice, and the suit can be filed on the day after it expires.
The notice and the suit must correspond. Where the plaint raises a cause of action that the notice never mentioned, the government will object that the suit has been filed without the statutory opportunity, and the objection often succeeds. A plaintiff who discovers more facts after the notice may have to serve a fresh notice and begin the two months again.
The proviso: urgent relief without notice
The section allows a suit to be instituted without notice, with the leave of the court, where urgent or immediate relief is sought. The proviso that allows this also says that the court shall not grant relief ex parte except after giving the government a reasonable opportunity to show cause. So a plaintiff seeking an interim injunction may file with leave, and may obtain a short notice to the government, but a bare ex parte order against the State is difficult to obtain.
What counts as urgent has to be shown. An injunction to prevent the demolition of a structure next week is urgent. An application filed a year after the cause of action arose rarely qualifies, because the urgency has evaporated by the plaintiff's own delay.
Limitation and the exclusion of the notice period
The notice period does not eat into limitation. The Limitation Act excludes, in computing the period of limitation for a suit for which such a notice is required, the day on which the notice is served and the period thereafter that the section allows. A plaintiff therefore does not lose two months of his limitation by complying with the section.
Where the notice itself is served long before the suit and the suit is filed years later, the exclusion operates only in respect of the notice period, and the balance of the period is counted in the ordinary way. For a suit against the government in tort, the limitation is the same as for any other defendant, and the one-year period for certain torts against a public officer under the Limitation Act should be checked for the particular claim.
Where the notice is not required
A writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution is not a suit and does not require a Section 80 notice, though the court may take a dim view of a writ filed without any prior representation to the authority. A suit against a private individual, even where the State is interested in the subject, does not require notice. An appeal against an assessment order under a tax statute has its own appellate remedy, and a suit to challenge it is barred by the statute's exclusivity.
Proceedings against the State in arbitration are also outside the section, because they are not suits. An application for interim measures in such an arbitration goes to the court under the arbitration law, and the notice requirement does not apply.
What the government does on receiving the notice
The notice is placed before the department and, where the claim is significant, before the legal officers who advise the State. The department can settle, refer the matter for legal opinion, or do nothing. Silence does not amount to an admission, and the plaintiff should diarise the date two months after service and file on time.
Where the government responds with a denial or a set of conditions, that response is worth reading carefully. It often reveals the factual line the State will take, which is useful for the plaint. Our page on civil litigation sets out how a suit against the State is pleaded and who appears for it.
Common questions
Can the two months be shortened?
Only by the route in the proviso, with the leave of the court and on a genuine case of urgency. There is no provision for the government to waive the period, and a letter from the department saying it has no objection does not dispense with the notice.
What if the notice is served on the wrong officer?
The court examines whether the notice reached a person who could act on it. Service on a junior officer who forwarded it to the correct department may be treated as sufficient, but service on a department with no connection to the subject is generally not.
Is a separate notice needed for a counterclaim against the State?
A counterclaim is a suit for this purpose in most cases, and the requirement is applied to it. A defendant who wants to claim against the State in the same suit should serve a notice and wait out the period before pleading the counterclaim.
Does the notice have to be sent by an advocate?
No, the plaintiff can send it. A notice drafted by an advocate is more likely to contain the cause of action and the relief with the precision the section requires, and defects in the notice are the reason most suits against the State fail at the threshold. The form is set out on our legal notice drafting page.
The notice is two pages of careful drafting that decides whether a suit against the State ever begins. A notice that states the facts, the dates and the exact relief allows the department to consider a settlement and leaves the plaintiff free to sue on the same case. A notice that states a grievance allows the department to reply that nothing was ever claimed, and the suit ends before the first hearing.