Section 14(3) of the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016 requires a promoter to rectify a defect in workmanship, quality or the provision of services within thirty days of a written complaint, at his own cost, and the obligation runs for five years from the date of handing over possession. The rera defect liability five years rule is an implied warranty in every agreement for sale, and it cannot be signed away in the agreement's fine print.
What the warranty does not do is make the builder responsible for everything that goes wrong in a flat for five years. It covers defects in the construction and the services the promoter was obliged to provide, and it does not cover damage the allottee caused, normal wear, or alterations the allottee made.
The statutory terms
Section 14(3) applies where the allottee has taken possession. It provides that the promoter shall be liable to rectify the defects in workmanship, quality or provision of services, and that the rectification must be done within thirty days of the complaint at the promoter's cost. The liability continues for five years from the date of handing over possession.
The section also allows the allottee to claim compensation for the period during which the defect existed, and to claim the cost of rectification where the promoter fails to do it. That second route is important: an allottee who has already paid a contractor to fix the waterproofing can recover the cost, provided the complaint and the photographs are on the file.
What counts as a defect
Structural defects: cracks in the columns, slabs and beams, settlement in the foundation, roof leakage that recurs after repairs. Waterproofing failures in the toilets, balconies and the terrace. Seepage through the external walls. Defective plumbing and drainage, which produce damp and damage to the flooring. Electrical defects in the common wiring and in the flat's own installation. Lift failures and defective fire-fighting equipment, which are common area defects but affect the flat's usability. Absence of the amenities promised in the agreement, from the clubhouse to the covered parking.
What is not a defect: a design the allottee does not like, a change in the layout the allottee consented to, damage caused by the allottee's own contractor, wear from ordinary use, and the absence of something the agreement never promised. A complaint framed around "poor quality" without a specific defect is difficult to sustain; a complaint that says the toilet in the master bedroom leaks into the bedroom below, with photographs and dates, is a case.
The thirty days, and why the sequence matters
The complaint should be in writing, dated, delivered to the promoter with an acknowledgment, and it should list each defect separately with the location and the date it was noticed. The promoter then has thirty days. If the defect is not rectified, the allottee can complain to the Authority, and the complaint should annex the original representation and the acknowledgment.
Allottees who complain by telephone, or through the facility manager, and then approach the Authority a year later have no record of a written complaint, and the promoter's defence that the thirty days never began is difficult to answer. The written complaint is the trigger, so it should be sent by email to the promoter's registered address and by registered post, and it should be repeated if the defect persists.
The five years, and when it starts
The five years run from the date of handing over possession, which is the date on the possession letter or the date of the occupancy certificate coupled with delivery, depending on the facts. Where possession was delayed and delivered in phases, the date for each unit is the date on which that unit was handed over.
A defect that appears in the fifth year is within the warranty, but the complaint must be made and the rectification demanded within the period. A complaint filed after the five years have expired is outside section 14(3), though other remedies — a consumer complaint on the ground of deficiency in service, or a civil suit for damages — may still be available within their own limitation.
Where the complaint is filed
The complaint goes to the West Bengal Real Estate Regulatory Authority under section 31, and the Authority can direct rectification, compensation and the cost of repairs. A parallel complaint can be filed before the consumer commission, and the allottee must choose, because the same relief cannot be recovered twice.
The Authority's order is appealable to the West Bengal Real Estate Appellate Tribunal within sixty days. Where the promoter has not complied, the Authority can direct compliance and the non-compliance is punishable.
For a co-operative society or an apartment association, common area defects are usually taken up by the association on behalf of all the allottees, and the association is an allottee for the purpose of the Act where it holds the common areas. A single flat owner's complaint about the roof is weaker than the association's complaint about the same roof, because the association can speak for everyone affected.
Building the evidence
Photographs with dates, videos of the leakage during the monsoon, the complaint and its acknowledgment, the promoter's replies, the contractor's estimate for the repair, the bills if the repair was done, and a structural engineer's report where the defect is structural. For a structural defect, the report of an engineer is worth the fee, because the Authority cannot direct structural repair on the basis of a photograph.
Where the allottee has already carried out the repair, the bills and the before-and-after photographs establish the cost, and the claim becomes a money claim rather than a rectification claim.
What goes wrong
The first failure is a complaint that mixes a list of grievances with a demand for a refund, which sends the file down the wrong section.
The second is an allottee who lets the builder's contractor into the flat for repairs without a written scope, and then finds the repair incomplete and the complaint already treated as closed.
The third is waiting for the association to act where the defect is inside the flat. The association's complaint covers the common areas; the flat's own defects are the flat owner's complaint.
Does the five-year warranty cover fittings and fixtures?
It covers defects in workmanship and quality in what the promoter was obliged to provide, which includes the fittings and fixtures supplied under the agreement. It does not cover the replacement of items that have simply worn out through use.
Can the builder charge me for the repair?
Not where the defect is within section 14(3). The rectification is at the promoter's cost. A charge is permissible where the damage was caused by the allottee or by an alteration the allottee made.
What if the builder has dissolved or transferred the project?
The obligation runs with the promoter, and a transfer of the project requires the previous written consent of the allottees and of the Authority, so the transferee takes on the obligations. Where the entity has been struck off, recovery is difficult and the practical route is against the persons who were in charge.
Do I need to move out during the repairs?
The statute does not require it, and the Authority can direct the promoter to carry out the work in a manner that does not displace the allottee. Where the flat is uninhabitable, the allottee should ask for alternative accommodation or compensation for the period, and record the request in writing.
The complaint succeeds on the written record: a dated list of defects, the acknowledgment, and the photographs. Our RERA practice drafts the complaint and the engineer's brief, and the consumer practice runs the parallel claim where that forum is better. For the association's common area claim, the property team advises on the handover documents. Begin at our contact page.