A temporary injunction restrains the other side from doing something until the suit is decided, and the applicant must satisfy three tests: a prima facie case in his favour, the balance of convenience in his favour, and that he will suffer irreparable injury that cannot be compensated in money. The application is supported by an affidavit, and where the matter is urgent it can be moved before the defendant is served.
The three tests, taken one by one
A prima facie case does not mean a case that must succeed. It means material that, if unrebutted, would entitle the applicant to relief, and a serious question to be tried. Courts have repeatedly said that the existence of a serious question is enough at this stage, and that the merits are not to be decided finally.
The balance of convenience asks whose inconvenience is greater if the order is granted and the suit later fails, against whose inconvenience if it is refused and the suit later succeeds. Where the loss is evenly balanced, the order is refused. Where the applicant would be destroyed and the defendant inconvenienced, it is granted.
Irreparable injury is not injury that is serious; it is injury that money cannot repair. An order can be made where a distinctive building would be demolished, where a trade secret would be published, where a person would be removed from premises that are his only home, or where the subject matter would cease to exist before the suit ended.
The three are cumulative, and courts have said so in terms. A strong prima facie case with no irreparable injury does not produce an injunction, and a claim of irreparable injury on a weak case does not either.
The application and the affidavit
The application is filed under the Code's provisions for temporary injunctions, and the affidavit is the evidence. It should be structured to answer each of the three tests in order:
- Paragraphs setting out the facts that constitute the applicant's right and the defendant's threat to it.
- The documents relied on, exhibited and marked.
- The facts showing that the threatened act is imminent, not hypothetical.
- The facts showing that the loss cannot be measured in money, or that the defendant cannot pay.
- The reason the application is being made at this stage and not earlier, particularly where the applicant has known of the threat for some time.
- The undertaking to compensate the defendant if the order turns out to have been wrongly obtained.
Delay is fatal. An applicant who knew of the threatened act for months and moved only when the suit was about to be dismissed is met with the objection that he had acquiesced, and the court takes that seriously.
The ex parte order and what follows
Where the object of the application would be defeated by the delay of a notice, the court may grant an injunction ex parte. The Code requires the applicant to deliver to the defendant, along with the copy of the application, the plaint, the affidavit and the documents, and to record the reasons for not serving notice first. An applicant who obtains an ex parte order and fails to comply with these requirements risks the order being vacated.
The defendant may then apply to discharge, vary or set aside the order within the time the Code allows, and the court hears that application on merits, with both sides on affidavit and sometimes on oral evidence. The court may also order the injunction to continue, or extend it until the suit is decided, on such terms as to security or costs as it thinks fit.
Where the injunction operates for a long period before the suit is heard, the court may order the applicant to keep the relief alive by paying costs or by furnishing security. An applicant who does not follow up is exposed to the order expiring.
Where the subject matter is land or a building
Land disputes produce the largest volume of injunction applications in the Kolkata courts. Two common situations:
- Threatened alienation. A plaintiff claiming a share in a property seeks an injunction restraining the defendant from selling it pending the partition suit. The court looks at the title documents and the sale threat, and will often grant the order over the defendant's objection.
- Threatened construction or demolition. A plaintiff seeks to restrain construction on a plot he claims, or to prevent a neighbour from building in a way that affects his rights. Photographs, the sanction plan and a surveyor's report carry the case.
Where the property is revenue land, the record of rights and the mutation entries are the documents, and the court may direct a local inspection or appoint a commissioner to ascertain the position on the ground. In an encroachment case, a commissioner's report with a measurement is often what decides the application.
An injunction is not a decision on the suit. It decides who holds the position steady until the suit is heard, and the applicant who treats it as a victory often loses the case.
What the applicant should do before filing
Collect the title chain, the notice, the correspondence and the photographs. Send a written notice to the defendant and give a short time to reply, unless the urgency excludes it, because a notice that was ignored strengthens the application. Where the threat is a sale, take a search of the sub-registrar's records so that an imminent conveyance can be shown. Where the threat is construction, take dated photographs.
Decide what order is wanted with precision. "Restraining the defendant from interfering with the plaintiff's possession" is a different order from "restraining the defendant from alienating the property". A vague prayer produces a vague order, and a vague order is difficult to enforce or to comply with.
Common questions
Can an injunction be sought without filing a suit?
No. The interlocutory order is ancillary to a suit, and the suit must be filed. Where the relief is urgent and no suit is contemplated, the remedy is a different one, and advice should be taken before proceeding.
What happens if the applicant loses the suit?
The defendant may claim damages for the loss the injunction caused, on the basis of the undertaking the applicant gave. The undertaking is a real obligation and should not be given without thought.
Can an ex parte injunction be obtained on the same day as the plaint?
It can, where the urgency is shown, and the matter is mentioned before the appropriate judge with the application and the affidavit. The court may hear it at once or give a short date.
Move early, plead the three tests in order, and identify the order you want precisely. Our civil litigation practice handles injunction applications in the City Civil Court and on the original side of the Calcutta High Court, property title disputes covers the underlying title questions, and partition suits covers the share disputes where these orders are most often needed.