14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

Trust and waqf property: why these titles need care

A property held by a trust or a waqf is not owned by the trustee or the mutawalli. It is held for a purpose, and the person who manages it has only the powers that the trust deed, the trust law or the waqf law gives him. A buyer who deals with a trustee as though he were the owner buys a title that the beneficiaries can attack, and a buyer who deals with waqf land without the statutory sanction buys nothing at all.

These transactions appear in the market as ordinary sales, often at attractive prices, and the defect surfaces years later when the beneficiaries, the board or the charity commission takes notice.

Private trusts

A private trust is created by a deed, and the trust property vests in the trustees. The Indian Trusts Act, 1882 governs the trustee's duties and powers. The central rule is that a trustee may not sell the trust property unless the trust deed confers the power of sale or the court sanctions the sale.

Where the deed confers a power of sale, the trustee must still act in the interests of the beneficiaries, at a fair price, and in good faith. A sale at an undervalue, to a related party, or outside the purpose of the trust is a breach of trust, and the beneficiary can follow the property into the hands of a purchaser who had notice.

Where the deed does not confer the power, the trustee must apply to the court for directions, and the court will sanction a sale only where it is necessary or beneficial for the trust. The sanction is the document the buyer needs, and a sale without it is a sale that can be set aside.

Public charitable trusts

A public charitable trust holds property for a charitable purpose, and the property is not the trustees' to sell at will. The trust deed, the registration and the scheme of the trust govern what may be done, and a change to the purpose or the disposal of the property usually requires the court's approval.

Section 92 of the Code of Civil Procedure requires the consent of the Advocate General for a suit relating to a public charitable or religious trust, and the court's powers in such a suit include settling a scheme for the administration of the trust. That is the forum in which a sale or a change of use is approved, and a buyer who is offered trust property should ask whether such a scheme exists.

For income tax, a trust claiming exemption must be registered under the provisions that require it, and the registration is a matter of public record. Its absence is a sign that the institution's affairs are not in order, which is relevant to the buyer's assessment of the seller's authority.

Waqf property

A waqf is a dedication of property to God for a religious or charitable purpose, and the property vests in God. The mutawalli manages it, but he does not own it, and the Waqf Act, 1995 regulates the administration, the board's supervision and the permitted dealings.

The Act permits the sale or exchange of waqf property only in defined circumstances and with the sanction of the State Waqf Board and the court. A sale without that sanction is void, and the board can proceed to recover the property, cancel the mutation and remove the encroachment.

A waqf may be created by a deed, by a will, or by long user — a property used for a mosque, a graveyard or a dargah for generations may be treated as waqf by user even without a document. That last category is the one that catches buyers, because the record may show a private owner while the land has been used for a religious purpose for a century.

What a buyer must check

  • The trust deed or the waqf deed, and the registration.
  • The authority of the person signing: the trustee's resolution, the mutawalli's appointment, the board's sanction.
  • The court's sanction for the sale, where the deed does not confer a power of sale or where the trust is public.
  • The revenue record: a khatian in the name of the trust, the deity, the mosque or the board is a warning that the property is not privately held.
  • The litigation record: suits under section 92, board proceedings, encroachment cases.
  • The income-tax registration, for a charitable trust, and the filings that show it is active.

Why the record matters so much

A property held by a trust is often recorded in the name of the trustee "as trustee", or in the name of the deity, or in the name of the board. A buyer who reads the khatian without understanding the entry sees a name and assumes an individual owner.

The deeds in the chain will show the same thing: a sale to "Sri X as trustee of the Y Trust", a gift to a temple, a dedication to a mosque. Those recitals are the notice that the property is not ordinary, and a purchaser who ignores them cannot claim to be a bona fide purchaser without notice.

What can be done if the property is trust property

Where the trust genuinely wants to sell, the route is an application to the court for sanction, or a suit under section 92 for a scheme that permits the sale. The court will consider the purpose of the trust, the interests of the beneficiaries, the price and the alternative use of the funds.

Where a sale has already taken place without sanction, the beneficiaries or the board can sue to set it aside, and the purchaser's remedy is against the trustee personally. A trustee who has sold trust property without authority is liable to make good the loss, and his personal assets are the only recourse in most cases.

The Kolkata institutions

Trust deeds are registered at the sub-registrar's office, and the trust's accounts and registrations are with the income-tax authorities. Suits relating to public charitable trusts go before the Calcutta High Court or the civil court, with the Advocate General's consent where section 92 applies. The State Waqf Board for West Bengal is the authority for waqf property, and its sanction is required for any dealing.

Our trust practice handles the creation, the registration and the court sanction, and the title disputes practice deals with the challenge to a sale. Where the property is waqf, the property law practice advises on the board's requirements before any transaction.

Can a trustee sell trust property?

Only if the trust deed gives him the power, or the court sanctions the sale. A trustee who sells without either is acting outside his authority, and the sale can be set aside at the instance of the beneficiaries. A buyer who takes a sale from a trustee should see the deed and, where the power is absent, the court's order.

Can waqf land be sold?

Only in the limited circumstances the Waqf Act allows, with the sanction of the board and the court. A sale without that sanction is void, and the board can recover the property. A buyer who is offered waqf land at a price below the market should treat the discount as the cost of the defect.

What if the khatian shows the trust's name?

Then the property is held by the trust, and the seller must prove his authority to sell it. The khatian entry is notice to the world, and a purchaser who buys in the face of it cannot claim ignorance. The sale should not proceed without the deed, the resolution and the sanction.

Trust wakf property title is not impossible to buy, but it is impossible to buy casually. The authority of the seller is the whole of the transaction, and it is established by documents that the seller should be able to produce before the first payment, not after the last.

Looking for a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422