14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001 Initial consultation ₹2,000+91-7439811422WhatsApp
Practice areas Legal formats Insights Team About Careers Fees Book a consultation — ₹2,000 +91-7439811422
Property & Registration

A daughter's share: what the 2005 amendment did

A daughter is a coparcener in a Hindu undivided family by birth, in the same manner as a son, and she can demand a partition of the coparcenary property in her own right. That is the effect of section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 as substituted by the 2005 amendment. Her daughter share coparcenary right is not a claim on her father's benevolence; it is an interest that exists from the day she is born, subject to the protection the amendment gives to transactions completed before 20 December 2004.

The litigation of the last two decades has been about three questions: which daughters the amendment reaches, whether it applies where the father had already died, and what happens where the family had already divided. Two decisions of the Supreme Court settled most of it, and the practical position is now reasonably clear.

What section 6 now says

The substituted section 6 provides that in a joint Hindu family governed by the Mitakshara law, the daughter of a coparcener shall by birth become a coparcener in her own right in the same manner as a son, have the same rights in the coparcenary property as she would have had if she had been a son, and be subject to the same liabilities as a son. The same section makes her children capable of inheriting her interest.

The proviso is the limit. It says that nothing in the section affects or is deemed to affect a disposition or alienation, including a partition or a testamentary disposition of the property, that took place before 20 December 2004. A partition actually effected before that date stands, and a daughter cannot reopen it on the strength of the amendment.

Which daughters, and the date that matters

The amendment applies to a daughter who was alive on 20 December 2004. In Prakash v Phulmati the Supreme Court held that the right is not retrospective in the sense of conferring a right on a daughter who had died before the amendment, and that the daughter must have been alive on the date of the amendment to claim under it.

The more difficult question was whether the amendment applies where the father had died before 20 December 2004 without a partition. In Vineeta Sharma v Rakesh Sharma the Supreme Court held that a daughter is a coparcener by birth, that the right does not depend on the father being alive on the date of the amendment, and that a partition has to be shown to have been actually effected by a deed or a decree, not merely asserted. The Court also held that the statutory fiction that a daughter is a coparcener by birth operates from the date of her birth, and it laid down how a partition said to have taken place earlier must be proved.

The practical consequence is that an oral family arrangement said to have been made in 1998 will not defeat the daughter's claim; a registered partition deed or a decree will.

What the daughter's share is in

Three different properties need to be kept apart. Coparcenary property — ancestral property in which the daughter is now a coparcener — is divisible on a partition in which she takes the same share as a son. The father's separate, self-acquired property is not coparcenary property at all, and the daughter's share in it arises on his death under the general rules of succession in section 8, in which sons and daughters take equally.

A dwelling house was once subject to a special rule under section 23, which restricted a daughter's right to claim partition of a house until the male heirs chose to divide it. That section was omitted by the 2005 amendment, so the restriction no longer applies. Section 24, which had excluded certain widows who remarried from inheriting, was also omitted.

For the revenue record, the daughter's share appears in the khatian only when a partition is effected or a mutation on succession is applied for. A khatian that records sons alone, prepared before the amendment and never revised, is not evidence that the daughter has no share; it is evidence of an incomplete record.

Can a father defeat the right by a will?

Partly. Section 30 of the Hindu Succession Act allows a Hindu to dispose of by will his interest in coparcenary property, and the courts have upheld such bequests. So a father can will away the interest he holds, and the daughter's coparcenary right is subject to that disposition to the extent the statute allows.

What a will cannot do is take away an interest that has already vested in the daughter as a coparcener by birth, which is the point that has produced the sharper litigation. The distinction between what the father owns and what the daughter holds is the heart of any will challenge in this area, and the answer depends on the date of the will, the date of the death, and whether a partition had already effected a division.

Partition, and the forum in Kolkata

A daughter can file a partition suit before the City Civil Court at Kolkata, or the district court at Alipore or Barasat, for the properties within that court's jurisdiction. Where the estate is large and the property lies within the city, the suit can be filed on the original side of the Calcutta High Court.

The plaint pleads the family tree, the coparcenary property, the plaintiff's share, and the cause of action, which is the defendant's refusal to divide. The court declares the shares by a preliminary decree and appoints a commissioner for the division by metes and bounds in the final decree. Where the property cannot be divided, it is sold and the proceeds are distributed.

Alongside the suit, the daughter should apply for mutation of her share in the record of rights after the decree, and for the municipal record to be corrected. A decree that is not reflected in the record leaves the next purchaser facing a title defect.

What goes wrong

The first failure is a daughter who assumes that the khatian in her brothers' names settles the matter. It does not, and the passage of time is met by the plea of limitation only where she has been openly excluded from possession, not where she has been out of the village.

The second is a partition deed drafted after 2004 that omits the daughter and recites that the family divided in 2002. The recital is not proof, and a deed that records a partition that never happened is exactly what Vineeta Sharma addresses.

The third is the reverse: a brother who believes the amendment applies to a partition completed in 2003 by a registered deed. It does not, and the proviso protects the deed.

Does the 2005 amendment apply to a daughter married before 2004?

Yes. Marital status is irrelevant to coparcenary status under the substituted section 6. What matters is that the daughter was alive on 20 December 2004 and that the property had not been partitioned or alienated before that date.

What if my father died in 1999 and there was no partition?

On the authority of Vineeta Sharma v Rakesh Sharma, the daughter's right is not defeated by the father's death before the amendment, provided no partition was actually effected. The estate is then divided with the daughter as a coparcener, and the burden of proving an earlier partition lies on the person asserting it.

Is the daughter's share equal to the son's?

Yes, in coparcenary property. Each daughter and each son takes an equal share, and the mother is entitled to a share as an heir on the father's death. The arithmetic of the shares must be worked out on the family tree and the date of death, and it changes where some heirs have died after the succession opened.

Can a daughter sell her share before the partition?

She can transfer her undivided interest, and the transferee steps into her position and can sue for partition. The market for an undivided share is thin, so the practical route is to have the share defined by a partition first and then sell it.

The claim turns on documents: the family tree, the deeds, the khatian, the date of any partition, and the date of death of each member. Our partition practice builds that record before filing, and the family law team handles the succession questions that run alongside it. Where the daughter's share has already been recorded wrongly, the title team takes the correction. Start at the contact page.

Looking for a a law firm in Kolkata? FileX Advocates practises from 14 Hare Street, Kolkata 700001, before the Calcutta High Court and the city courts. Consultation ₹2,000.

Book a consultation — ₹2,000 WhatsApp UsAll Articles
Related

More Insights

Guides our advocates wrote on neighbouring questions.

Chat on WhatsApp Call +91-7439811422