In a Hindu family in Kolkata, the son share ancestral property question gets two different answers depending on which school of Hindu law governs the family, and this is where most advice goes wrong. Bengal follows the Dayabhaga school, under which the father is the absolute owner of the property during his lifetime and the son has no right by birth. On the father's death, the sons, the widow and the daughters take definite shares as Class I heirs under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. In a Mitakshara family, a son acquires an interest by birth and can ask for a partition during the father's lifetime.
Dayabhaga: what a son has while the father is alive
Under Dayabhaga, the son's interest arises at the father's death and not before. During the father's lifetime the son is entitled to maintenance and, in appropriate cases, to marriage expenses, but he has no enforceable share in the property and cannot demand a partition against the father's will. The father can transfer the property, and in principle he can bequeath his self-acquired property by will.
Inherited property is different. Where the property came to the father from his father, and has not been spent or converted, the heirs hold it as joint property with defined shares; the Dayabhaga joint family does not require the shares to be worked out at a partition because each co-owner's share is known from the moment of inheritance. That is the opposite of the Mitakshara position, where the shares fluctuate with births and deaths until a partition.
The practical consequence is that a son in a Dayabhaga family who wants a share of his father's property usually has to wait, unless the property is inherited joint property already held by the father and other co-owners, in which case the son may stand in the father's shoes only if the father's share has devolved to him.
Mitakshara: the coparcenary and the right by birth
Many families in Kolkata follow Mitakshara law, particularly the Marwari, Agarwal and north Indian communities, and a family may also be governed by the custom of its community. In a Mitakshara coparcenary, the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 as amended in 2005 applies, and Section 6 provides that a daughter of a coparcener shall, by birth, become a coparcener in the same manner as a son, with the same rights and liabilities.
In that structure, a son and a daughter can demand a partition of the coparcenary property, a coparcener's share can be sold to a stranger, and a sale of the whole by the karta requires legal necessity or the consent of the others. On the death of a coparcener, his interest devolves by survivorship or, where the amended Section 6 applies, according to the Act, and the arithmetic has to be done from the date of death.
Working out the shares after a death
Where a Hindu male dies intestate, his property devolves on the Class I heirs, and the heirs in Class I take equally. For a man survived by his widow, two sons and a daughter, the property divides into four equal parts, and if the widow later dies, her one-fourth passes to her own heirs, which may include her sons and daughters and her other children. A son who assumes that the family property will divide only among the sons is working from an older understanding and will be contradicted by the record.
The division also has to distinguish self-acquired from inherited property, because a father's will can dispose of the former but the position on the latter depends on the school and on whether the property was joint family property. Where the family has already partitioned partly, the remaining joint property has to be identified plot by plot.
What a son can file, and where
- Ask for a partition in writing, with a family tree and a schedule of the properties. A legal notice starts the record and often produces a response.
- File a suit for partition and separate possession before the City Civil Court at Kolkata, or the district court at Alipore or Barasat, according to the value and the location of the property.
- Pay the court fee on the value of the plaintiff's share, computed under the West Bengal Court-fees Act, 1970 and checked by the stamp reporter of the court.
- Seek an injunction restraining any defendant from alienating the whole property or constructing on it during the suit.
- Obtain a preliminary decree declaring the shares, and then a final decree after a commissioner divides the property, or an order for sale where division is impractical.
A suit for partition is not a suit for a declaration of title, and the court in a partition suit can decide questions of title incidentally where the shares depend on them. The family tree and the deeds are therefore the heart of the pleadings.
Common questions
Can a father disinherit a son in Bengal?
A father can dispose of his self-acquired property by will, and in Bengal a Dayabhaga father's power over his own property is wide. A will that makes no provision for a dependent son may still be valid, although a court can consider the maintenance obligation in an appropriate case. Where the property is joint family property, the father cannot will away the sons' interest, because their interest is not his to give.
Does a daughter get the same share as a son?
Yes, in both structures the result today is equality: a daughter is a Class I heir with an equal share on intestacy, and in a Mitakshara coparcenary she is a coparcener by birth after the 2005 amendment. A partition that gives her less is open to challenge.
What if the property is still in the grandfather's name?
Then the first step is a mutation on the death of the grandfather, and the shares under the record follow the line of inheritance. A partition suit can proceed against the surviving heirs even where the record has not been updated, but the decree will have to be followed by a mutation before a buyer will accept the title.
Is a family settlement better than a suit?
Usually yes, if the family can agree. A registered partition deed is faster and cheaper than a suit, and it produces the document the revenue office needs. Where one member refuses to agree, the suit is the only way to obtain a binding division.
Identify the school of law before you identify the shares. That single step decides whether the son has a right by birth or an inheritance on death, and it is the question most family discussions skip. Our partition practice handles the suit from the family tree to the final decree, and the property team advises on the mutation that follows. For a family that can settle, the registration practice prepares the deed.